Correspondence 0000950103-23-015174 from NOVO NORDISK A S (NVO, NONOF) (CIK 0000353278) (NVO)
NOVO NORDISK A S (NVO, NONOF) (CIK 0000353278)
Date: Oct. 20, 2023 · CIK: 0000353278 · Accession: 0000950103-23-015174
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-82318
Referenced dates: September 27, 2023
Show Raw Text
CORRESP
1
filename1.htm
October 20, 2023
Via EDGAR (form type label CORRESP)
Anuja A. Majmudar
Karina Dorin
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
Office of Life Sciences
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20549
Re:
Novo Nordisk A/S
Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2022
Filed February 1, 2023
File No. 333-82318
Dear Ms. Majmudar and Ms. Dorin:
By letter dated September 27, 2023, you provided comments on behalf
of the Division of Corporation Finance, Office of Life Sciences (the “Staff”) of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
(the “SEC”) with respect to our Annual Report 2022 (the “Annual Report”) incorporated by reference into our Form
20-F for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2022 (the “2022 Form 20-F”). On behalf of Novo Nordisk A/S (“we” or
the “Company”), we have provided responses to your comments as indicated below. For your convenience, we have repeated your
comments prior to our responses.
SEC Comment #1:
We note your response to prior comment 2 states that you did not identify
any material indirect consequences of climate-related regulations or business trends to your business, financial condition or results
of operations. Please include a discussion explaining in greater detail your analysis and how you concluded on the materiality of each
of the items noted in our prior comment for which disclosure was not deemed necessary, including qualitative or quantitative support for
such analysis and conclusion. For example, please explain how you determined that "physicians and end-users of [your] products primarily
focus on other factors such as innovation to address unmet medical needs, efficacy, safety, and usability of such lifesaving medicines,
rather than the climate impact of these products."
Our response
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and respectfully
advises the Staff that it has not identified any material indirect consequences of climate-related regulations or business trends to the
Company’s business, financial condition or results of operations. To reach this conclusion we have relied on our enterprise risk
management process, which is owned by the Company’s Chief Financial Officer, but also involves the full Executive Management, the
Board of Directors and the Audit Committee. The Company actively monitors and evaluates risks faced by its business and which, over the
Company’s 100 years of experience in the field of diabetes care, has allowed it to develop a deep knowledge of patient and physician behavior and needs. The Company’s processes include the
employment of inhouse anthropologists to interview patients, daily communication between the Company’s sales force and
Healthcare Professionals (HCPs) and engagement of HCPs to act as advisors on the Company’s advisory boards.
1
In response to the Staff’s request for additional detail as to
our consideration of each of the factors listed in the Staff’s prior comment #2, we note the following:
Decreased demand for goods or services that produce significant
greenhouse gas emissions or are related to carbon-based energy sources
To date, the Company has not experienced any significant decrease in
demand for products due to their greenhouse gas emissions arising from manufacturing or distribution but will continue to monitor such
risk.
86% of the Company’s revenue in 2022 was related to the sale of
life saving medicines within diabetes and hemophilia care. Patients within these disease areas will suffer life-threatening complications
if they do not receive treatment. We therefore believe it is unlikely that the demand for such medicines will decrease, despite their
related greenhouse gas emissions. 4% of the Company’s revenue in 2022 came from its endocrine business which is related to the absence
of natural growth hormone in children. This disease is not life-threatening, but children that do not receive treatment will never reach
normal stature, and as a result we also believe that it is unlikely that demand for such products will decrease due to the related greenhouse
gas emissions.
10% of our revenue in 2022 was related to the sale of products for the
treatment of obesity. Our obesity portfolio is a great example where physicians and users of our products primarily focus on factors such
as innovation to address unmet medical needs, efficacy, safety and usability of medicines. The Company’s obesity product WegovyTM
is currently the only approved obesity medicine which provides 17% - 18% weight reduction, only surpassed by gastric bypass procedures.
At the same time the product provides a safe and well-tolerated profile. Finally, the patient only needs to administer the product once
weekly. The combination of meeting an unmet need within obesity care and developing a product which is safe and user friendly, has led
to an increase in the Company’s obesity portfolio sales of 157% in the first 6 months of 2023 compared to the same period in 2022,
despite any greenhouse gas emissions associated with the product.
Increased demand for goods that result in lower emissions
than competing products
The Company monitors top prescription drivers for our main products
as well as patient perception of the Company vs competitors. Any major changes in patient preferences or prescription drivers, including
climate related drivers, would be captured as part of this process. To date the Company has not noted an increased demand for goods that
result in lower emissions than the Company’s products. However, we start to see that some countries include carbon footprint of
pharmaceutical products as part of their evaluation criteria when issuing tenders. As a response to this development, the Company has
calculated the carbon footprint for each of its products on a yearly dose basis to be able to respond to such tenders as well as to assist
the Company in its efforts to decreasing the carbon footprint of each of its product.
Generally, patients who use pharmaceutical products have a product transition
barrier, which means that if their disease is well controlled, they will generally be reluctant to swap to other pharmaceutical products.
In addition, in
2015, Novo Nordisk made a commitment to The Climate Group and CDP joining RE100, alongside 165 other global companies, to reach the
ambitious goal of using 100% renewable power in its production facilities. The Company was the first pharmaceutical company to have reached
this goal in 2020 and is now moving towards net zero emissions across its entire value chain by 2045. Based on such
initiatives, we believe that the risk of patients choosing competitors’ products over our own due to lower emissions is not
material.
2
Increased competition to develop innovative new products
that result in lower emissions
It is our assessment that competition within the pharmaceutical space
is essentially driven by scientific developments, i.e. meeting unmet medical needs in a safe, effective and user friendly manner. That
being said, we strive to be a sustainable business and integrate environmental considerations in everything we do. This is why we measure
and report on our environmental performance as well as on our financial and social performance. Our supply chain accounts for the majority
of our total CO2 emissions. Having achieved our goal of using 100% renewable power in our own production, we are striving
to ensure our supply chain partners also use renewable power when producing for the Company and we expect that all our suppliers related
to our production will use 100% renewable power by 2030.
Based on the Company’s many environmental initiatives, it is our
assessment that the risk of competitors developing pharmaceutical products which result in significantly lower emissions than ours is
not material.
Increased demand for generation and transmission of energy
from alternative energy sources
The Company is not in the business of generation or transmission of
energy from alternative energy sources. However the Company is taking active measures to facilitate sustainable energy, such as a USD
70 million investment in a 672-acre solar park installation which ensures 100% sustainable power to our US operations. Furthermore, the
Company is heavily engaged in supporting other companies’ transition towards alternative energy sources. In addition to the initiatives
explained immediately above, to collaborate with suppliers towards a target of a 100% renewable power usage, the Company has entered into
an agreement with the Danish shipping company Maersk to transport its products using sustainable bio fuels. This agreement covers shipments
representing an estimated 50% of sea-freight within our product distribution. The Company also partners with SkyNRG for the purchase of
sustainable aviation fuel which can reduce CO2 emissions by up to 85% compared to conventional aviation fuel. The Company’s
ambition is a reduction in CO2 emissions from product distribution via air freight of 27% by 2025. The Company has also partnered
with European Energy for the supply of e-methanol, which is produced based on renewable energy, with the purpose of replacing fossil-based
plastics used in insulin pens with an e-methanol based sustainable plastic.
Any anticipated reputational risks resulting from operations
or products that produce material greenhouse gas emissions
The Company is aware of the increased focus on climate change and mitigation
activities of many of the Company’s stakeholders, including end-users, suppliers, customers, employees and public authorities, as
well as the related reputational impact. The Company closely monitors reputational risks, including climate-related risks, which are assessed
and ranked through our enterprise risk management process. Based on our enterprise risk management process and given our continued focus
towards sustainability, as described above, we have concluded that none of the identified reputational risks related to operations or
products that results greenhouse gas emissions are material.
3
The Company will continue to monitor the indirect consequences of climate-related
regulation and business trends and will disclose any material consequences in future SEC filings in accordance with applicable requirements.
SEC Comment #2:
We note your response to prior comment 3 and re-issue it in part. Please
tell us how you considered disclosure regarding the impact of water availability and quality in the manufacturing of your products, including
your determination of materiality on your business and operations. In this regard, we note your CDP Water Security 2022 Report indicates
that "[s]ufficient amounts of good quality freshwater are highly important for production...."
In addition, provide us with information quantifying all weather-related
damages to your property and operations, and the cost of property insurance, for each of the periods for which financial statements are
presented in your Form 20-F and explain whether changes to the cost of insurance are expected in future periods.
Our response
The Company acknowledges the Staff’s comment and respectfully
advises the Staff that availability of high-quality water is essential for the production of diabetes and biopharmaceutical products and
hence the Company’s operations. The production of Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (API) is the step in the Company’s value
chain that consumes the majority of the Company’s water usage. Our main production facilities, including API production facilities,
are located in Denmark where the majority of the water used in production is extracted and which, according to the World Resource Institute,
is a country with low water stress levels.
Water in Denmark is mainly extracted from underground, but the Company
also uses surface water for the cooling of its production facilities. The Company has risk management processes in place to assess and
mitigate risks related to water shortages. An example of the risk process is related to the surface water used in the cooling of production
processes. The Company has concluded that the lake that currently supplies its production facility with surface water for cooling does
not hold the water capacity needed to meet future up-scaling of the Company’s production capacity. Based on this conclusion, the
Company has initiated an investment project to ensure sustainable extraction of water for cooling, which in the future will be extracted
from the ocean instead of lakes.
The Company has production facilities in countries with higher water
stress levels or high seasonal variations (France, Brazil, China, Iran and Algeria). These sites account in total for 13% of the water
used in our global production. Risk assessment and mitigation plans are in place for each of these sites. An example of such mitigation
plans is the establishment of local water collection facilities to ensure water availability in drought seasons.
The fact that 87% of our water consumption is in countries with low
water stress level (mainly Denmark), and the fact that the remaining 13% which is consumed in areas with higher water stress levels is
geographically diversified, has led us to conclude that the risk of a significant water shortage or inferior water quality is not material.
Furthermore, the Company has to date not encountered water shortages or material issues with water quality at any of its production sites.
We have therefore not included this risk in our 2022 Form 20-F.
4
In response to the Staff’s comment on weather-related damage to
properties and operations, the Company respectfully advises the Staff that it has recognized weather-related damages to properties amounting
to DKK 0.14 million in 2020, DKK 0.01 million in 2021 and DKK 0.03 million in 2022. Comparing these amounts to the overall operating profit
of the Company for the same periods (DKK 54,126 million in 2020, DKK 58,644 million in 2021 and DKK 74,809 million in 2022), as well as
the fact that the Company has not experienced any weather-related impact to its operations, we have concluded that weather-related damages
have not been material to the Company during the reporting periods included in the Company’s 2022 Form 20-F. Furthermore, we advise
the Staff that our insurance program is a combined program covering physical damages and business interruption (a PDBI program). It is
thus not possible to split insurance cost for properties only, as requested by the Staff. The cost of the PDBI insurance program was DKK
37 million in 2020, DKK 42 million in 2021 and DKK 55 million in 2022. The program cost increase from 2021 to 2022 was due to an increase
in business interruption coverage. We expect that the future insurance cost will follow overall market loss experience and inflation.
The Company’s insurance cost is not deemed material compared to the operating profit results listed immediately above.
* * * * *
If you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact Trine
Haastrup, Corporate Vice President of Corporate Accounting, at (+45) 3075 9551 or me at (+45) 3075 8611.
Sincerely,
/s/ Karsten Munk Knudsen
Karsten Munk Knudsen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
5