SEC Company Response from KOOR INDUSTRIES LTD (CIK 0000791531) — Nov 21, 2005
KOOR INDUSTRIES LTD (CIK 0000791531)
Date: Nov. 21, 2005 · CIK: 0000791531 · Accession: 0001341004-05-000367
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
Referenced dates: November 8, 2005
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>CORRESP
<SEQUENCE>1
<FILENAME>filename1.txt
<TEXT>
[KOOR INDUSTRIES LTD. (An Israeli Corporation) GRAPHIC OMITTED]
Finance Department
14 Hamelacha Street
Park Afek
Rosh Ka'Ayin, Israel 48091
Tel: 972-3-9008310
Fax: 972-3-9008313
November 21, 2005
VIA FACSIMILE AND EDGAR
-----------------------
Larry Spirgel
Assistant Director
Division of Corporation Finance
Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20549
Re: Koor Industries Ltd. (File No. 1-09178)
Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2004
Filed July 15, 2005
Form 20-F/A for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2004
Filed September 16, 2005
-------------------------------------------------------
Dear Mr. Spirgel:
On behalf of Koor Industries Ltd., a corporation organized under the
laws of the State of Israel (the "Company"), set forth below are the Company's
responses to the comments of the staff of the Securities and Exchange
Commission (the "Staff") to the above-referenced Form 20-F of the Company (the
"Form 20-F") set forth in your letter dated November 8, 2005 (the "Comment
Letter"). For the convenience of the Staff, each response has been numbered to
correspond with the comments in the Comment Letter. Capitalized terms used but
not defined herein shall have the meanings ascribed to them in the Form 20-F.
Form 20-F for the Year Ended December 31, 2004
----------------------------------------------
Principal and Subsidiary Auditor Reports, page F-2
--------------------------------------------------
Report of Independent Auditors, page F-2
----------------------------------------
1
<PAGE>
1. We note your response to comment 3. It is unclear which auditor has
taken responsibility for the conversion of Balton CP Limited's results
from US GAAP to Israeli GAAP. In future filings, in order to make this
point more clear, revise the second paragraph of the audit report
issued for Koor Trade to specifically identify Balton CP Limited and
any other affiliates whose financial statements were not audited by
Koor Trade's auditor.
The Company will comply with the Staff's request and include
in its future filings a revised auditors' report issued for Koor Trade
Ltd. ("Koor Trade") that specifically identifies Balton CP Limited and
any other affiliates whose financial statements were not audited by
Koor Trade's principal auditor.
Auditors' Report of Nutriblend, Ltd., page F-138
------------------------------------------------
2. We note your response to comment 4. It is unclear which auditor has
taken responsibility for the conversion of Nutriblend Limited's
results from US GAAP to Israeli GAAP. In future filings, in order to
make this point more clear, revise the second paragraph of the audit
report issued for Lycored Natural Products Industries, Ltd. to
specifically identify Nutriblend Limited and any other subsidiaries
whose financial statements were not audited by the auditor of Lycored.
The Company will comply with the Staff's request and include
in its future filings a revised auditors' report issued for Lycored
Natural Products Industries ("Lycored") that specifically identifies
Nutriblend Limited and any other subsidiaries whose financial
statements were not audited by Lycored's principal auditor.
Auditor Reports Issued by Hoberman, Miller Goldstein & Lesser, pages F-128,
F-131 and F-132
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. We note your response to comment 6, where Hoberman Miller, Goldstein &
Lesser, CPA's P.C. indicate that there were no identified differences
between US GAAP and Israeli GAAP for either Talla-Com, Tadiran
Electronic Industries, LLC, or Microwave Networks, Inc. In future
filings, in order to make this point more clear, the Hoberman Miller,
Goldstein & Lesser, CPA's P.C. audit report should be revised to
indicate that the "application of accounting principles generally
accepted in Israel did not have any effect on the results of
operations, shareholder's equity and cash flows ..."
The Company will comply with the Staff's request and include
in its future filings revised auditors' reports issued by Hoberman
Miller, Goldstein & Lesser, CPA's P.C. for Talla-Com, Tadiran
Electronic Industries, LLC, and Microwave Networks, Inc. that include
the language suggested by the Staff.
2
<PAGE>
Note 28 Material Differences Between Israeli and US GAAP and their Effect
on Financial Statements, page F-107
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reconciliation of net earnings (loss), page F-119
-------------------------------------------------
4. We note your response to comment 9. In future filings, please revise
to clarify that the difference between Israeli GAAP and US GAAP is
related to timing.
The Company will comply with the Staff's request and clarify
in its future filings that the difference between Israeli GAAP and US
GAAP is related to timing.
5. We note your response to comment 15. Revise your accounting policy to
explain in more detail your basis for proportionately consolidating
Yehuda Hotels, Ltd., Herod's Hotels Spa and Resort, Ltd. and Telrad
Networks, Ltd.
As discussed below in its response to comment 6, the Company
believes that the basis for proportionately consolidating Telrad
Networks, Ltd. ("Telrad") is clearly described in Note 3D(1) to its
financial statements. With respect to Yehuda Hotels Ltd. and Herod's
Hotels Spa and Resort Ltd., the Company advises the Staff that its
investment in each of those companies is immaterial (the Company's
investment in those companies together represents less than two
percent of the Company's consolidated total assets under Israeli GAAP
as of December 31, 2004 and those companies' combined net income for
the year ended December 31, 2004 represents less than one percent of
the Company's consolidated net income under Israeli GAAP for the same
period). The Company believes the disclosure in Notes 2A(3), 2E(1) and
2E(3) to its financial statements explain the main accounting
principles with respect to this issue. Accordingly, the Company
respectfully proposes not to amend its Form 20-F for the sole purpose
of supplementing its accounting policy disclosure; instead the Company
proposes revise future filings to explain in more detail the basis for
proportionately consolidating the above companies by the following
disclosure in Note 2E(1) to its financial statements:
"The consolidated financial statements include the financial
statements of the Company and of all the companies in which
the Company has control. Jointly controlled companies are
included in the consolidated financial statements by the
proportionate consolidation method. A jointly controlled
company is an entity whose significant operating policies
are, by contractual arrangement, jointly controlled by all
parties having an equity interest in the entity."
6. It is not clear how Telrad met the accommodation in Form 20-F under
Item 17(c) (2)(vii) that allows you to omit Israeli GAAP to US GAAP
reconciliation, because it does not appear that all parties with an
equity interest have the right to share in the control of all
significant financial and operating policies. The existence of
significant participating rights that preclude consolidation under
EITF 96-16 would ordinarily mean that not all significant financial
and operating policies of the entity are jointly controlled by all
parties with an equity interest. Please tell us in more detail about
3
<PAGE>
why you believe the above-mentioned accommodation is available to
Telrad. Please refer to section VI(C) of International Reporting and
Disclosure Issues in the Division of Corporation Finance, which is
located on our website at
http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/internatl/cfirdissues1104.
htm#P577_92041.
Telrad is a developer and marketer of telecom products and
end-to-end solutions, thus meeting the operating entity criterion set
forth in Item 17(c)(2)(vii) of Form 20-F. Furthermore, all significant
financial and operating policies of Telrad are jointly controlled by
all the parties with an equity interest.
The Company, as the majority shareholder, and Fortissimo GP
Capital Fund L.P. ("Fortissimo"), as the sole minority shareholder
during 2004, are party to a shareholders'agreement. As described in
Note 3D(1) to the Company's financial statements as of and for the
year ended December 31, 2004, the shareholders' agreement stipulates a
list of matters governing essentially all significant financial and
operating policies of Telrad, which must be approved by the joint
consent of the Company and Fortissimo. These matters include: (i)
approval of Telrad's budget; (ii) appointment of Telrad's executives
and determining their terms of employment; (iii) dividend
distribution; (iv) amending the organizational documents of the
company; (v) issuance of ordinary shares, convertible securities or
other securities; (vi) merger or sale of substantially all of the
company's assets; (vii) increase in the number of directors; (viii)
related party transactions; (ix) loans, advances or guarantees other
than in the ordinary course of business; (x) formation or investment
in an entity that is not wholly owned; (xi) material changes in the
nature of business; (xii) effecting any form of winding up of the
company; (xiii) selling or granting a license to the company's
technology; (xiv) making various financial investments; and (xv)
incurring indebtedness exceeding a certain amount.
Although section VI(C) of International Reporting and
Disclosure Issues in the Division of Corporation Finance, states that
the existence of significant participating rights that preclude
consolidation under EITF 96-16 would ordinarily mean that not all
significant financial and operating policies of the entity are jointly
controlled by all parties with an equity interest, all Telrad's
significant financial and operating policies are in fact jointly
controlled by all parties with an equity interest. As described above,
Fortissimo's rights under the shareholders' agreement confer to
Fortissimo the right to actually participate in essentially all the
significant decisions related to the Telrad's normal course of
business, thereby preventing the Company from actual control over
Telrad and requiring the joint consent of the Company and Fortissimo
in decisions on all matters that are critical for the operating
objectives of Telrad. As a result, according to Israeli GAAP, Telrad
is jointly controlled by the Company and Fortissimo, and is thus
precluded from consolidation by the Company. Accordingly, Telrad is
included in the Company's financial statements by the proportionate
consolidation method.
Therefore, the Company believes that the accommodation set
forth in Item 17(c)(2)(vii) of Form 20-F is applicable to Telrad, as
both the operating entity criterion and the joint control criterion
are met.
4
<PAGE>
If you have any questions regarding the responses to the Staff's
comments, or require additional information, please contact the undersigned at
011-972-3-900-8310.
Sincerely,
/s/ Ran Maidan
Ran Maidan
Senior Vice President
& Chief Financial Officer
cc: Shlomo Heller
Michal Yageel
Koor Industries Ltd.
David Goldschmidt
Yehuda Markovits
Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP
</TEXT>
</DOCUMENT>