SEC Company Response from E DIGITAL CORP (CIK 0000886328) — Jan 25, 2005
E DIGITAL CORP (CIK 0000886328)
Date: Jan. 25, 2005 · CIK: 0000886328 · Accession: 0001144204-05-002241
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-121546
Referenced dates: December 30, 2004, January 6, 2005, January 7, 2005
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>CORRESP
<SEQUENCE>1
<FILENAME>filename1.txt
<TEXT>
<TABLE>
<CAPTION>
<S> <C>
HIGHAM, MCCONNELL & DUNNING LLP
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
15 ENTERPRISE, SUITE 360
ALISO VIEJO, CALIFORNIA 92656-2655
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TELEPHONE: (949) 900-4400 o FACSIMILE: (949) 900-4401 o WEBSITE: www.hmdlaw.com
</TABLE>
January 25, 2005
VIA EDGAR
Securities and Exchange Commission
450 Fifth Street, N.W.
Mail Stop 03-06
Washington, D.C. 20549-1004
Attention: Peggy Fisher, Assistant Director, Electronics and Machinery
Russell Mancuso, Branch Chief
Re: e.Digital Corporation - Response to Comment Letter dated
January 7, 2005; File No. 333-121546
Ladies and Gentlemen:
This letter is being provided to you on behalf of e.Digital Corporation
(the "Company"), in connection with Registration Statement on Form S-3 (File no.
333-121546), filed by the Company on December 22, 2004 (the "Registration
Statement"). By letter dated December 30, 2004, the staff acting on behalf of
the Commission informed the Company that it had reviewed the Registration
Statement to determine whether the Registration Statement had been filed on the
appropriate form and issued the following comment:
"It appears that the registrant does not meet the requirements
for registration of securities for resale under Instruction I.B.3 of
Form S-3. Note that the Over-the-Counter Bulletin Board does not
qualify as a national securities exchange or automated quotation
system. See July 1997 Division of Corporation Finance Manual of
Publicly Available Telephone Interpretations H.54. Please revise your
filing accordingly."
On behalf of the Company, we advised the staff by letter dated January
6, 2005 that the Company was not relying upon Instruction I.B.3 to support its
use of Form S-3 but, rather, Instruction I.B.4(a)(3) which expressly permits use
of Form S-3 to register securities to be offered upon "conversion of outstanding
convertible securities or the exercise of outstanding warrants" without any
listing requirement.
<PAGE>
Securities & Exchange Commission
January 25, 2005
Page 2
On January 7, 2005, the staff on behalf of the Commission responded to
our letter as follows:
"We have received your response to our December 30, 2004
comments. Please note that Form S-3 General Instruction I.B.4(a)(3)
applies to registration statements filed to register conversion
transactions. By contrast, your filing appears to be registering shares
for resale by selling stockholders. Therefore, we reissue our December
30 comment."
Given the apparent clarity of General Instruction I.B.4(a)(3) and the
seeming lack of outstanding precedent, we respectfully request that the staff
reconsider the foregoing comment and permit the Company to utilize Form S-3 to
register securities to be offered from time-to-time upon conversion of
outstanding convertible securities or the exercise of outstanding warrants,
pursuant to Rule 415(a)(1)(iii)-(iv) under the Securities Act of 1933, as
amended (the "Securities Act").
I. Background.
The shares of common stock described in the Registration Statement are
issuable upon conversion of outstanding shares of Series EE preferred stock and
the exercise of outstanding warrants issued in connection with the Company's
Series EE preferred stock and 12% Subordinated Promissory Note financings. The
securities had been acquired from the Company on or about July 1, 2004 and
November 30, 2004, respectively, in private transactions pursuant to Rule 506 of
Regulation D and are considered "restricted securities" under the Securities
Act.
II. Form S-3 Eligibility Requirements.
General. Instruction I. of the General Instructions sets forth the
"Eligibility Requirements For Use of Form S-3." Instruction I. provides that
"[a]ny registrant which meets the requirements of paragraph A. below
("Registrant Requirements") may use this form for the registration of securities
under the Securities Act of 1933 which are to be offered in any transaction
specified in paragraph B. below ("Transaction Requirements"), provided that the
requirements applicable to the specified transaction are met." (Emphasis added.)
Registrant Requirements. Inasmuch as the Company (i) is organized under
the laws of the State of Delaware, (ii) has a class of securities registered
pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Securities Exchange Act or 1934 (the "Exchange
Act"), (iii) has been subject to the requirements of Section 12 of the Exchange
Act and has filed all material required to be filed pursuant to Section 13, 14
or 15(d) for a period in excess of twelve calendar months immediately preceding
the filing and (iv) has not failed to pay any dividend or defaulted on any
indebtedness or long-term lease payment material to the financial position of
the registrant, it has met each of the applicable Registrant Requirements
specified by paragraph A. of Instruction I.
<PAGE>
Securities & Exchange Commission
January 25, 2005
Page 3
Transaction Requirements. Paragraph B. of Instruction I sets forth the
Transaction Requirements. This paragraph provides that "[s]ecurities offerings
meeting any of the following conditions and made by a registrant meeting the
Registrant Requirements specified in I.A above may be registered on this form."
(Emphasis added.) Subparagraph 4(a) of Instruction I.B. specifically lists
securities to be offered "[u]pon the conversion of outstanding convertible
securities or the exercise of outstanding warrants" as a transaction for Form
S-3 eligibility purposes. The requirements applicable to the specified
transaction are specified in Subparagraphs 4(b) and (c) were met by delivery of
the specified information to the selling shareholders at the time of their
initial investment. The requirements applicable to the transaction specified in
Subparagraph 4(a) do not include either (i) a market capitalization requirement
comparable to that specified in Instruction I.B.1 or (ii) a listing requirement
comparable to that specified in Instruction I.B.3 and according to the General
Instructions it would be inappropriate to impose any requirement other than the
requirements "applicable to the specified transaction."
III. Legal Analysis.
The Company has met the "Registrant Requirements" for use of Form S-3
listed under I.A. and also appears to have met the "Transaction Requirements"
specified under Section I.B.4 (a)(3). Accordingly, it is our belief that the
Company may use Form S-3 for the registration of its securities. This belief is
supported by the clarity of the aforementioned General Instructions which
expressly permit use of Form S-3 to register securities to be offered "[u]pon
the conversion of outstanding convertible securities or the exercise of
outstanding warrants," which is the case here. The fact that the Company does
not have a market capitalization in excess of $75 million or securities listed
on a national securities exchange or quoted on an automated quotation system of
a national securities association is not germane to the "Transaction
Requirements" specified under Section I.B.4 (a)(3) and should not be raised as
an issue or be an impediment to effectiveness.
Alternatively, in the event that you are unable to conclude that the
above-described transaction is a "conversion transaction" as contemplated under
Section I.B.4 (a)(3), we believe that the Company would still be entitled to use
Form S-3 to register the primary issuance of underlying common stock [pursuant
to Rule 415(a)(1)(iii)-(iv) under the Securities Act] that may occur from
time-to-time upon the conversion of outstanding convertible securities or the
exercise of outstanding warrants. Although the exemption from registration for
exchange transactions provided by Section 3(a)(9) would typically be relied upon
to avoid registration, it is our belief that the foregoing would nonetheless
constitute a registerable conversion transaction consistent with the transaction
requirements of Section I.B.4 (a)(3). Since the foregoing necessarily will
require the Company to amend the Registration Statement, we seek your guidance
(pre-filing) that such amendment if submitted will be acceptable to you.
<PAGE>
Securities & Exchange Commission
January 25, 2005
Page 4
IV. Conclusion.
Based upon the foregoing facts and analysis, we believe that the
staff's prior comments on behalf of the Commission are distinguishable and/or
not applicable and that the Company is eligible to use Form S-3 in connection
with the instant offering. If you should have any questions regarding this
letter, or if you should require any additional information, please do not
hesitate to call the undersigned at (949) 900-4400. We would appreciate it if
you would advise us as soon as possible in the event that you conclude that you
are unable to concur with any of the opinions expressed in this letter and, in
any event, prior to issuing a written response declining to agree with any such
conclusion.
Very truly yours,
HIGHAM, McCONNELL & DUNNING LLP
/s/Curt C. Barwick
Curt C. Barwick, Esq.
cc: Eduardo Aleman, Esq. (via - facsimile)
</TEXT>
</DOCUMENT>