SEC Company Response from LANOPTICS LTD (CIK 0000892534) — Sep 26, 2005
LANOPTICS LTD (CIK 0000892534)
Date: Sept. 26, 2005 · CIK: 0000892534 · Accession: 0000910662-05-000512
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>CORRESP
<SEQUENCE>1
<FILENAME>filename1.txt
<TEXT>
CARTER LEDYARD & MILBURN LLP
Counselors at Law
2 Wall Street
New York, NY 10005-2072 1401 Eye Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20005
Steven J. Glusband o (202) 898-1515
Partner o
o Tel (212) 732-3200 570 Lexington Avenue
Direct Dial: 212-238-8605 Fax (212) 732-3232 New York, NY 10022
E-mail: glusband@clm.com (212) 371-2720
September 26, 2005
Mr. Stephen G. Krikorian
Branch Chief - Accounting
Division of Corporation Finance
Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20549
Re: LanOptics Ltd.
Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2004
File No. 0-20860
----------------
Dear Mr. Krikorian:
On behalf of our client, LanOptics Ltd. (the "Company"), we are submitting
this letter in response to the written comments of the Staff of the Securities
and Exchange Commission (the "Staff"), in a letter to Mr. Meir D.Burstin,
Chairman of the Board of the Company, dated September 6, 2005, with respect to
the Company's Form 20-F for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2004. We have
repeated your numbered comments below and have provided a response to each
comment.
Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2004
-----------------------------------------------------
Controls and Procedures, Page 71
--------------------------------
1. We note your statements in the third paragraph regarding the inherent
limitations of internal control systems. You should state clearly, if true,
that yours disclosure controls and procedures are designed to provide
reasonable assurance of achieving their objectives. In the alternative,
remove the reference to the level of assurance of your disclosure controls
and procedures. Please refer to Section II.F.4 of Management's Reports on
Internal Control Over Financial Reporting and Certification of Disclosure
in Exchange Act Periodic Reports, SEC Release No. 33-8238.
The Company believes that its disclosure controls and procedures are
designed to provide reasonable assurance of achieving their objective and will
revise the disclosure in its future annual reports in response to this comment.
The Company seeks permission to provide this updated disclosure in its annual
report for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2005.
<PAGE>
Mr. Stephen G. Krikorian
Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements
----------------------------------------------
Note 2 : Significant Accounting Policies
----------------------------------------
Note 2j - Redeemable Preferred shares in a subsidiary and Preferred shares in a
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
subsidiary, page F-12
---------------------
2. With regard to the redeemable preferred shares in EZchip,
a. Tell us how you are accounting for the accretion to the redemption
value, including the amounts recorded in each period presented.
The Staff is advised that the Company accounted for the accretion to the
redemption value (the accrued and the unpaid annual 6% coupon interest) in
accordance with ASR 268 as an annual addition to the original issuance price of
EZchip's Series C Redeemable Preferred Shares (the "Series C Shares"). The
Company credited the Series C Shares in a "Redeemable Preferred Shares and
Warrant issued By Subsidiary" account (as presented in the financial statements)
and debited financial expenses. The amounts recorded are presented in a summary
table included in the response to comment 2b below.
b. Provide a roll-forward of the related balances and a description of
how the amounts recorded were computed, including the initial
valuation of the shares in March of 2003.
The Staff is advised that during March 2003, EZchip issued 16,542,267
Series C Shares at a price per share of $0.8161 receiving total consideration of
$13.5 million (the "C1 Round"). Of such amount, the Company invested $2.3
million in consideration of receiving 2,818,312 Series C Shares. During March
2004, EZchip issued an additional 9,802,825 Series C Shares at the same price
per share receiving total consideration of $8 million (the "C2 Round"). Of such
amount, the Company invested $5.3 million in consideration of receiving
6,564,274 Series C Shares.
The holders of the Series C Shares may request redemption of such shares
after four years. The Series C Shares will be redeemed at the higher of the
original investment amount plus annual 6% accrued interest or the fair value of
the shares. As discussed in the response to comment 2a above, the Series C
Shares were recorded at their issuance price (less issuance expenses), while the
accrued and the unpaid annual 6% coupon interest has been accumulated
periodically, as follows:
2
<PAGE>
Mr. Stephen G. Krikorian
---------------- -------------------------- ----------------------------------
Period Description Investment by Minority
(third parties), net of
issuance expenses
---------------- -------------------------- ----------------- ----------------
C1 Round C2 Round
---------------- -------------------------- ----------------------------------
U.S Dollars
---------------- -------------------------- ----------------------------------
March 2003 Minority Interests in C1 $10,927,000(1) -
Round (net of issuance
expenses)
---------------- -------------------------- ---------------- -----------------
April - Accretion of Interest -
December 2003 504,000(2)
---------------- -------------------------- ---------------- -----------------
Redeemable 11,431,000(*) -
Shares in
Subsidiary as
of December
31, 2003
---------------- -------------------------- ---------------- -----------------
March 2004 Minority Interests in C2 - $2,562,953(3)
Round (net of issuance
expenses)
---------------- -------------------------- ---------------- -----------------
March - Accretion of Interest 672,000(4) 132,150(5)
December 2004
---------------- -------------------------- ---------------- ------------------
Redeemable 14,798,103(*)
Shares in
Subsidiary as
of December
31, 2004
---------------- -------------------------- ----------------------------------
--------------
* In the financial statements as of December 31, 2003 and 2004, the
"Redeemable Preferred Shares and Warrant issued By Subsidiary" account
included additional amounts of $176 thousand and $147 thousand,
respectively, which represents the warrants issued by EZchip (See note 11
to the financial statements).
(1) $0.81609 * 13,723,955 shares - $273,000 issuance expenses = $10,927,000
investment
(2) $0.81609 * 13,723,955 shares * 0.06 * 3/4 = $504,000 accretion of interest
(3) $0.81609 * 3,238,551 shares - $80,000 issuance expenses= $2,562,953
investment
(4) $0.81609 * 13,723,955 shares * 0.06 = $672,000 accretion of interest
(5) $0.81609 * 3,238,551shares * 0.06 * 10/12= $132,150 accretion of interest
3
<PAGE>
Mr. Stephen G. Krikorian
c. Tell us the fair value of the shares as of December 31, 2004 and how
this value was determined.
The Staff is hereby advised that the Company believes that the fair value
of the Series C Shares as of December 31, 2004 approximates the fair value of
such Series C Shares as reflected in the three closings of the Series C
financing rounds in March 2003, March 2004 and July 2005. The price per share
was kept constant during the three periods.
d. Provide us any additional information necessary surrounding your
subsidiary to support your accounting for its preferred shares and
refer to the relevant literature that supports your accounting.
Address in your response the option you gave to the Major Shareholders
to exchange their shares in EZchip for Ordinary shares of LanOptics.
The Staff is hereby advised that since the Series C Shares are only
redeemable at the election of the holders of a majority of the Series C Shares
and that they may be converted into EZchip's ordinary shares at any time, the
Series C Shares are not mandatory redeemable shares according to SFAS 150 and
are not considered as a liability under SFAF 150.
According to ASR 268 all equity securities that are redeemable at the
option of the holder, or upon the occurrence of an event that is not solely
within the control of the issuer and that are not otherwise required to be
classified as liabilities by SFAS 150 should be classified outside permanent
equity, and should be normally presented between liabilities and shareholder's
equity as a "mezzanine account" (regardless of the likelihood that those
circumstances will arise). Therefore, the Company accounted for the net amount
that was invested in EZchip's Series C Shares by third parties as redeemable
preferred shares in a subsidiary as a mezzanine account according to ASR 268.
The initial carrying amount of redeemable preferred shares is their fair
value at the date of issue (which is the amount invested) and such amount is
adjusted to equal the redemption amount at the end of each reporting date.
Please also see Topic 5-h question 3, which evaluated whether a gain may be
recognized for issuance of subsidiary stock, according to which a gain should
not be recognized before exercise or conversion into common stock of preferred
shares issued by a subsidiary.
As for the option that was given to the major shareholders to exchange
their shares in EZchip for ordinary shares of Lanoptics, please refer to the
response to comment 3, below.
Note 3 - Investment in EZchip, page F-21
----------------------------------------
3. Tell us more about the Swap Options you granted to the Major Shareholders
in May 2003, which allows them to exchange their shares in EZchip for
Ordinary shares of LanOptics. Include in your response the business reasons
for granting the Swap Options and the underlying formula that will
determine the exchange ratio. Explain your accounting for the Swap Option
at issuance (May 2003) and
4
<PAGE>
Mr. Stephen G. Krikorian
the subsequent interim periods, including upon exercise. Refer to the
authoritative literature that supports your accounting, including your
consideration of EITF 00-19. Tell us whether the exchange transaction
completed in June 2005 was completed under the provisions of the Swap
Option and if so, discuss the exchange ratio and the respective accounting.
The Staff is advised that as part of the Series C Shares funding that
occurred in March 2003, LanOptics executed an agreement (the "Exchange Right
Agreement") with four major EZchip shareholders (the "Major Shareholders") who
hold 41.4% of EZchip's shares (on an "as converted basis"). The Company offered
these EZchip shareholders the option to exchange their EZchip preferred shares
for ordinary shares of LanOptics ("the Swap Option" or "Exchange Right"). The
business reasons for granting the Swap Option were:
o Attain Absolute Control. LanOptics' business currently consists
exclusively of the business of EZchip, an Israeli company that is
engaged in the development of high performance network processors.
Because of this, the value of LanOptics derives from the value of
EZchip. Over the last few years, LanOptics has taken various steps to
maintain its control over EZchip and has publicly indicated its desire
to increase its ownership interest in EZchip to 100%. Increasing the
ownership percentage of EZchip held by the Company should increase the
value of LanOptics, and may result in greater consideration to
LanOptics' shareholders over the long-term in a future transaction
involving a merger or acquisition of EZchip.
o Unifying the Companies. The Company believes that it is desirable to
rationalize the structure of LanOptics and EZchip by unifying the
shareholdings in the two companies. A unification of the shareholdings
would allow various efficiencies in the operation of the businesses.
o No Economic Change for the Shareholders. Despite the resulting
dilution in each LanOptics shareholder's percentage ownership, the
economic interest of each LanOptics shareholder should remain
unchanged. This is because the exchange rate mechanism fully
compensates for the dilution in LanOptics' shareholders' percentage
ownership by the increased percentage that LanOptics holds in EZchip.
As a first step toward unifying LanOptics and EZchip, in August 2002,
LanOptics increased its ownership interest in EZchip from 57% to 66% in an
exchange transaction with four entities affiliated with Apax Partners. As
mentioned above, in early March 2003, EZchip and several investors, including
the Company and other existing investors, entered into definitive agreements for
a new financing round involving the issuance of EZchip Series C Shares for total
proceeds to EZchip of up to $21.5 million. The Company indicated to the
investors in this financing round that it would ultimately be interested in
acquiring their shares in EZchip on a basis similar to that in the Apax Partners
transaction. The Major Shareholders and the Company reached an agreement in
principle concerning exchange rights that would follow the Apax Partners model.
5
<PAGE>
Mr. Stephen G. Krikorian
In the proxy material for an extraordinary meeting of shareholders that was
held on April 15, 2003, the Company's shareholders were notified of the proposed
exchange and that the exchange ratio would be calculated assuming the exchange
of all the shares of EZchip (on a fully-diluted basis) into shares of the
Company (on a fully-diluted basis) and that the exchange ratio would be
identical for all classes and series of EZchip shares. Such exchange ratio would
of course be subject to adjustment in the event of changes in the capital
structure of either LanOptics or EZchip such as stock splits, reverse splits,
stock dividends and the like.
On April 15, 2003, the shareholders of Lanoptics approved a resolution at
the extraordinar