SEC Company Response from FUTUREMEDIA PLC (CIK 0000906476) — Dec 17, 2004
FUTUREMEDIA PLC (CIK 0000906476)
Date: Dec. 17, 2004 · CIK: 0000906476 · Accession: 0001144204-04-022024
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 000-21978
Referenced dates: November 29, 2004
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>CORRESP
<SEQUENCE>1
<FILENAME>filename1.txt
<TEXT>
VIA EDGAR
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
ATTN: Linda Cvrkel, Branch Chief
450 Fifth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20549-0306
December 17, 2004
Re: Futuremedia PLC
Form 20-F for the fiscal year ended August 30, 2004
File No. 000-21978
Ladies and Gentlemen:
This letter is in response to the letter from the Commission's staff dated
November 29, 2004 regarding the above referenced filing. The headings below
correspond to the headings in the staff's letter, and each of the Company's
responses is preceded by the text of the comment from the staff's letter.
In connection with this response letter, the Company acknowledges that (i)
the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in
the filing; (ii) staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff
comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to
the filing; and (iii) the Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in
any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal
securities laws of the United States.
Annual Report on Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year ended April 30, 2004 - Filed
September 30, 2004
Item 3. D. Risk Factors
Dependence on Limited Source of Supply - Page 12.
1. SEC Comment: We note from page 12 that you are dependent on one or
only a limited number of suppliers for certain key software and
hardware components and obtaining an alternative source of supply
could involve significant delays and other costs, and may ultimately
not be available to you. In light of this situation, consider in
future filings, disclosing the nature and financial impact of this
concentration in accordance with paragraphs 20-24 of SOP 94-6.
<PAGE>
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
ATTN: Linda Cvrkel, Branch Chief
December 17, 2004
Page 2
COMPANY RESPONSE: The Company acknowledges the Commission's comment and
will provide such expanded disclosure in future filings.
Item 7. Major Shareholders and Related Party Transactions - Page 39.
2. SEC Comment: Reference is made to key (2) on page 39. Please tell us
supplementally and identify in future filings the natural person or
persons that have voting or investment power over each entity identified
in key (2).
COMPANY RESPONSE: As indicated in Item 7 (key 2), to the Company's
knowledge, Rennes Foundation and Jobelin Foundation are beneficially
owned by entities of which directors or executive officers (or
former directors or executive officers) of the Company are also
directors, executive officers or shareholders. The directors and
executive officers of the Company disclaim beneficial ownership of
these shares. To the Company's knowledge, Rennes Foundation and
Jobelin Foundation are under common control. The Company does not
have access to any further information beyond what Rennes Foundation
and Jobelin Foundation disclosed in Schedule 13D (Amendment No. 3)
filed with the Commission on March 5, 2004 or in other filings with
the Commission, or the information Rennes Foundation and Jobelin
provided directly to the Company. The Company has no further
information on the ultimate beneficial owners of Rennes Foundation
and Jobelin Foundation.
Financial Statements
Notes to the Financial Statements
Note 1. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies
General.
3. SEC Comment: We note from your business section that you incurred
GBP196,000 of research and development costs. In future filings, please
disclose the amount of research and development costs charged to expense
in each period for which an income statement is presented. Refer to
paragraph 13 of SFAS 2.
<PAGE>
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
ATTN: Linda Cvrkel, Branch Chief
December 17, 2004
Page 3
COMPANY RESPONSE: The Company acknowledges the Commission's comment
and in future filings will provide such expanded disclosure relating
to research and development costs charged to expense in each period
for which an income statement is presented.
Revenue Recognition
4. SEC Comment: It appears that you derive substantially all of your revenue
from Learning for All(TM). From your disclosure, this e-learning
management system consists of providing all hardware, operating system
software and other software packages and support services such as
delivery, installation, training and support. Tell us supplementally and
disclose in future filings how you determine the fair value of each
element. From your filing it appears you do not supply support services
only. Tell us supplementally and indicate in future filings what
accounting guidance you apply when recording revenue in connection with
Learning for All(TM).
COMPANY RESPONSE: Fair Values. The fair values of each element were
determined by taking the price of similar products being offered by
competitors, as advertised on the Internet or in trade publications.
This was done at the outset of each campaign, and therefore
reflected the `spot price' of each element. Once established, the
fair values remained unchanged for the duration of the campaign,
typically two to three months. These values are then used to compile
a fair value for the total package being offered, and the percentage
of this total that each element represents was used to derive the
actual revenue recognized in the income statement.
Accounting Guidance. The Guidance applied when recording revenues in
connection with Learning For All(TM) is in accordance with EITF
00-21 "Accounting for revenue arrangements with multiple
deliveries". Having identified the various elements that make up a
Learning for All(TM) package, each is examined and classified by its
nature into either a `delivered' or `deferred' category. The
`delivered' category comprises the hardware, operating software,
delivery and installation fees and other miscellaneous software
supplied at the time and subject to a once-off charge. `Delivered'
revenues are recognized on installation. The remaining elements
making up the `deferred' revenues comprise the provision of the
Learning Management System, hosting of the associated website,
telephone support and e-learning content. Deferred revenues are
recognized over the period of the agreement, typically three years.
The Company acknowledges the Commission's comment and will provide
this disclosure in future filings.
<PAGE>
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
ATTN: Linda Cvrkel, Branch Chief
December 17, 2004
Page 4
Stock-based Compensation, page F-11
5. SEC Comment: We note your disclosure in Note 1 that you only issue fixed
term stock options at or above the quoted market price on the date of
grant and therefore no compensation expense is recognized in the
accompanying financial statements. However, we note from page F-27 you
issue performance-based options that are subject to variable plan
accounting. Tell us supplementally and disclose in future filings the
amount of stock compensation recorded in connection with your
performance-based options for each income statement period presented.
Revise Note 1 as necessary in future filings.
COMPANY RESPONSE: The conditions attaching to performance based
options had not been met, therefore no amount of stock compensation
was included in the income statement for any period in respect of
the granting of performance-based options.
The Company acknowledges the Commission's comment and will provide
this disclosure in future filings.
6. SEC Comment: We note that you recorded compensation expense related to
options that were cancelled and replaced in fiscal year 2004 and presented
such below your operating loss. In future filings, please include stock
compensation within the income statement caption operating expenses
presented within income (losses) from continuing operations.
COMPANY RESPONSE: The Company acknowledges the Commission's comment
and in future filings will provide such expanded disclosure ensuring
that stock option compensation is included within `operating
expense' within income/(losses) from Company operations.
Note 9. Acquisitions - Page F-18.
7. SEC Comment: We note that you acquired a 29.8% interest in Luvit AB in
April 2003. Please provide us supplementally with discussion of the
changes and a rollforward schedule of your investment account between the
periods presented. Also, tell us supplementally why you believe audited
financial statements of Luvit AB under Rule 3-09 of Regulation S-X were
not required for fiscal year 2004 in your Form 20-F.
<PAGE>
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
ATTN: Linda Cvrkel, Branch Chief
December 17, 2004
Page 5
COMPANY RESPONSE: In April, 2003, Futuremedia invested GBP944,000 in
cash and shares in purchasing 11,150,000 shares in Luvit AB, which
at the time had a total of 37,416,107 shares on issue, for a holding
of 29.8%. During the period April 2003 to June 2003, Luvit completed
a `reverse split' whereby their shares were consolidated on a ten
for one basis. Furthermore, in the same period, Luvit issued a
further 6,233 shares (post consolidation).
In January 2004, Futuremedia sold 25,200 Luvit shares, and in April
2004, sold a further 70,869 Luvit shares, reducing its holding to
1,018,931 shares, aggregating 27.2%.
The following table summarizes the movements:
Futuremedia No. Luvit AB Futuremedia %
Date (month end) Shares held Shares on issue holding
April 2003 11,150,000 37,416,107 29.80%
June 2003 1,115,000 3,747,844 29.75%
January 2004 1,089,800 3,747,844 29.08%
April 2004 1,018,931 3,747,844 27.18%
The sale of shares during the year reduced the original investment
value from GBP204,000 at May 1 2003, by GBP17,000 to GBP187,000.
During the year to April 30, 2004, Luvit AB recorded losses of
approximately GBP1,000,000. Futuremedia's share of these losses, at
27.2% therefore amounted to GBP272,000, which reduced the investment
value in the year from GBP187,000 to GBPnil at April 30, 2004, and
resulted in a further impairment taken against the carrying value of
goodwill resulting in an overall charge of GBP287,000 As noted in
response to question 8, the Company will also revise its disclosure
to include goodwill and the related investment together.
<PAGE>
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
ATTN: Linda Cvrkel, Branch Chief
December 17, 2004
Page 6
NB all values in GBP000's
Investment Goodwill
Balance at April 30, 2004 204 739
Sale of Luvit AB shares (17) -
Share of Luvit AB losses (187) -
Impairment charge - (100)
Balance at April 30, 2004 Nil 639
At April 30, 2004, there were no amounts due from Luvit AB.
The audited accounts of Luvit were not required for fiscal year 2004
in our Form 20F under the following guidance:
Accounting Technical Guidance
The Company has assessed the requirements to present supplemental
audited financial statements of Luvit AB under Rule 3-09 of
Regulation S-X.
Rule 3-09 of Regulation S-X notes that if the first or third
conditions set forth in Rule 1-02(w) substituting 20% for 10%, are
met for a 50% or less owned investee accounted for by the equity
method, separate financial statements of the investee shall be
filed.
The Company has considered the first and third condition, in
relation to the net assets and income of the Company compared to the
investee. Based on our considerations, the 20% threshold was not
exceeded in either case.
As a result, supplemental audited financial statements of Luvit AB
have not been presented in the Company's Form 20-F for the fiscal
year 2004.
8. SEC Comment: We note that on the date you acquired your interest in Luvit
AB you recorded goodwill of GBP 739,000 representing the difference
between the cost of your investment and your share of the underlying
equity in net assets of Luvit AB. The goodwill of an equity investment
should not be separate from the related investment but presented as a
single amount on your balance sheet. In future filings, include equity
method goodwill and the related investment as a separate line item on your
balance sheet. Refer to paragraph 19 of APB 18 and paragraphs B169-B170 of
SFAS 142.
<PAGE>
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
ATTN: Linda Cvrkel, Branch Chief
December 17, 2004
Page 7
COMPANY RESPONSE: The Company acknowledges the Commission's comment
and will comply in future filings. For your information we have
amended this in the company's filing under Form 6-K (filed with the
Commission on December 15, 2004) of its unaudited quarter results to
the end of October 2004.
9. SEC Comment: We note that you recorded an impairment charge of GBP 100,000
related to the goodwill portion of your equity investment in Luvit AB. An
equity investment (collectively the cost of your investment and related
goodwill) should be reviewed for a loss in value that is other than
temporary in accordance with paragraphs 19(h) of APB 18 and should not be
reviewed for impairment using the guidance in SFAS 142. Refer to paragraph
40 of SFAS 142. Please review you eq