SEC Comment Letter for MIKOHN GAMING CORP (CIK 0000912241) — May 25, 2005
MIKOHN GAMING CORP (CIK 0000912241)
Date: May 25, 2005 · CIK: 0000912241 · Accession: 0000000000-05-025892
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-124311
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT> <TYPE>LETTER <SEQUENCE>1 <FILENAME>filename1.txt <TEXT> May 25, 2005 By facsimile to (858) 550-6420 and U.S. Mail Mr. Russel H. McMeekin President and Chief Executive Officer Mikohn Gaming Corporation, d/b/a Progressive Gaming International Corporation 920 Pilot Road Las Vegas, NV 89119 Re: Mikohn Gaming Corporation, d/b/a Progressive Gaming International Corporation Registration Statement on Form S-4 Filed April 25, 2005 File No. 333-124311 Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2004 and Subsequent Exchange Act Reports File No. 0-22752 Dear Mr. McMeekin: We reviewed the filings and have the comments below. Where indicated, we think that you should revise the documents in response to the comments. If you disagree, we will consider your explanation why a comment is inapplicable or a revision is unnecessary. Be as detailed as necessary in your explanation. To understand better your disclosure, we may ask you in some comments to provide us supplemental information. We may raise additional comments after reviewing this information. Our review`s purpose is to assist you in your compliance with applicable disclosure requirements and to enhance the overall disclosure in your documents. We look forward to working with you to achieve these objectives. We welcome any questions that you may have about comments or any other aspect of our review. You may call us at the telephone numbers listed at the end of this letter. S-4 1. If applicable, comments on the S-4 are comments on the 10-K and subsequent Exchange Act reports and vice versa. 2. We note that information is omitted throughout the S-4. To the extent practicable, complete the information before you amend the S- 4. 3. Tell us why Progressive`s stockholders are not voting on the merger. Letter to Stockholders of VirtGame Corp. 4. Revise the first paragraph to describe the transaction in clear, plain English. Where you discuss the existence of merger subs for the mechanics of the transaction, also simply state that Progressive will acquire VirtGame through a merger. Comply with this comment here and the Q&A section. 5. Present the information about the transaction in bullet format so that it is easier for VirtGame`s stockholders to read. 6. Quantify here and, where appropriate, in the S-4 the estimated aggregate value of the stock swap. We understand that the aggregate value of the Progressive common stock that VirtGame stockholders will receive in the transaction will vary as the market price of Progressive`s common stock changes. Notice of Special Meeting of Stockholders 7. Describe briefly in the second bullet point what section 7(c)(viii) of the series B preferred stock`s certificate of designations encompasses. Questions and Answers about the Transaction, page 1 8. You repeat information in the Q&A section and the summary section. The Q&A should not repeat any information that appears in the summary, and the summary should not repeat information in the Q&A. For purposes of eliminating redundancies and grouping together like information, view the Q&A and the summary as one section. When revising the disclosure, we strongly suggest that you discuss only procedural questions, that is, voting procedures, appraisal procedures, etc., with short, clear answers in the Q&A, and place the material, substantive disclosure in the summary. 9. State what the exchange ratio calculation will be based upon. We note that if the exchange ratios were calculated as of the date of the prospectus, each outstanding share of VirtGame common stock would be converted into .0297 shares of Progressive common stock. Will the calculation be based upon the number of outstanding shares? We note statements that the estimated exchange ratios are based upon the 61.8 million shares of VirtGame common stock outstanding. If the exchange ratio is based upon the number of outstanding VirtGame shares, disclose this and the formula that you will use to determine the exchange ratio based upon the number of outstanding shares. It is unclear from the exchange ratio calculation example in annex 1 how you will determine the amount of consideration. 10. Include a table disclosing the number of shares that Progressive may issue to stockholders in the merger on a per share basis based upon: * A reasonable range of outstanding shares of common stock. * Potential adjustments for working capital deficiencies, projected new contract revenue, and the credit facility provided to VirtGame by Progressive. Include columns for the number of shares that holders of common stock, preferred stock, and options and warrants would receive. 11. Explain in clear and concise terms the collar on the number of shares and the collar`s economic purpose and its effect from the perspective of Progressive and from the perspective of VirtGame`s holders. Explain what you do assure or do not assure to Progressive and VirtGame`s holders relating to the number of shares to be issued in the transaction using the agreed upon exchange ratios. For example, to what extent does this arrangement increase or decrease the opportunities of VirtGame`s holders to gain or lose from expected changes to VirtGame`s working capital level, projected new contract revenue, and the amounts outstanding under the Progressive credit facility between the date of the proxy statement/prospectus and the transaction`s closing? We note the disclosure on page 38 that the exchange ratio was "at or about the same price" as the current market price of VirtGame`s common stock. 12. Refer to annex 1, and explain here in economic terms the purpose and effect of each item used to calculate the closing adjustment to purchase shares. 13. You indicate in the fourth and fifth Q&A on pages 1 and 2 that the estimated exchange ratio is based in part on VirtGame`s current working capital level and the aggregate amount currently outstanding under the Progressive credit facility. Quantify VirtGame`s current working capital level and the aggregate amount currently outstanding under the Progressive credit facility used to calculate the estimated exchange ratios. It is unclear how the exchange ratio is related to the reduction in the maximum number of transaction shares that you discuss on page 48. Please clarify. 14. You indicate in the fifth Q&A on page 2 that if the difference between the total number of shares actually issued and the maximum transaction shares is greater than 5,000, Progressive will issue the balance shares to the former holders of VirtGame`s common stock and preferred stock and the holders of assumed VirtGame options and warrants who exercised those options or warrants after the transaction`s closing. How will Progressive identify the former holders of VirtGame common stock and preferred stock? For example, will they be the record holders entitled to vote on the transaction at the special meeting, will they be the holders who surrender their VirtGame certificates for Progressive certificates after the transaction`s closing, or will another method be used to identify who will receive the balance shares? 15. Provide a quantified example of how the issuance of balance shares will work in the issuance of the maximum transaction shares. 16. We note the eighth Q&A on page 3. Reconcile these statements with the statement throughout the proxy statement/prospectus that Progressive will issue shares of its common stock for all of the outstanding warrants and options of VirtGame. Summary of the Proxy Statement/Prospectus, page 6 17. Disclosure on pages 8-9 and elsewhere indicates that the merger`s closing is conditioned upon receipt of written opinions on tax matters from VirtGame`s counsel and Progressive`s counsel. Since each party may waive the condition, you must: * File executed opinions before effectiveness even though the merger agreement is conditioned upon the receipt of one or more favorable tax opinions at closing. * Undertake to recirculate and resolicit if the condition is waived and the change in tax consequences is material. 18. Provide more prominent disclosure of Progressive`s $2.5 million loan to VirtGame, including its terms. Termination of the Merger Agreement, page 10; Termination Fees and Expenses, page 10; and No Solicitation, page 11 19. Scale back the information in these subsections, and avoid copying text directly from legal documents so that the information is easy to read. Interests of Directors, Officers and Affiliates of VirtGame and Progressive, page 12 20. Disclosure in the fifth risk factor on page 23 indicates that some VirtGame directors and officers have rights to acceleration of stock options. Quantify the rights` monetary value of those directors and officers here. 21. Confirm that there are no post-merger consulting agreements or arrangements for any of VirtGame`s directors and officers. Alternatively, if there are post-merger consulting agreements or arrangements for any of VirtGame`s directors and officers, disclose the material provisions of those agreements or arrangements. Risk Factors, page 22 22. Some risk factors include language like "it can not assure," "there can be no guarantee," and "There can be no assurance." For example, refer to the eleventh and twelfth risk factors. Since the risk is the situation described and not VirtGame`s inability to assure or guarantee, revise. 23. We note the disclosure about the exchange ratio in the last bullet statement on page 37. Consider adding a risk factor to discuss this fact. Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Statements, page 29 24. Since VirtGame is a penny stock issuer, VirtGame in ineligible to rely on the safe harbor. See section 27A(b)(1)(c) of the Securities Act, and revise. Background of the Transaction, page 34 25. In this subsection`s second paragraph, disclose why Mr. Mark Newburg chose Progressive as a potential business combination candidate. 26. In this subsection`s fourth paragraph, explain why the offer made by the potential acquirer "was not financially suitable." 27. In this subsection`s sixth paragraph, disclose what other "options for maximizing shareholder value" VirtGame considered and why they were not pursued. 28. In the second full paragraph on page 35, explain Ms. Victoria Abajian`s relationship to VirtGame. 29. In the third full paragraph on page 35, disclose briefly what aspects of valuation you discussed. 30. In the sixth full paragraph on page 35, discuss what "issues" about the merger you discussed at the January 5, 2005 meeting. 31. In the eighth full paragraph on page 35, disclose what detailed information about the merger the Progressive board reviewed at its January 17, 2005 meeting. 32. In the third paragraph on page 36, discuss how the capitalization of VirtGame affected the exchange ratio in the course of the merger negotiations. 33. Refer to the fifth paragraph on page 36. Summarize in appropriate detail the financial analysis of VirtGame received by Progressive`s board of directors before its February 14, 2005 meeting. Further, indicate who prepared the financial analysis. 34. Refer to the seventh paragraph on page 36. Summarize in appropriate detail the February 16, 2005 oral presentation of Trenwith Valuation, LLC or Trenwith to Progressive`s board of directors. 35. Provide us copies of any documentation such as outlines, summaries, or reports prepared and furnished by Trenwith to Progressive`s board of directors. Further, provide us copies of the financial forecasts prepared by VirtGame that were provided to Trenwith. VirtGame Board of Directors` Reasons for the Transaction, page 37 36. On page 38, disclose what aspects of these items you considered: * "Financial market conditions, historical market prices, volatility and trading information with respect to each company`s common stock." * "The terms of the $2.5 million credit facility provided by Progressive." * "The exchange ratio at which VirtGame shares will be exchanged for Progressive shares in the merger." 37. Disclose here or elsewhere details and quantify to the extent practicable the strategic rationale and the economic and operational benefits of the merger. For stockholders to make an informed decision about the merger, you should explain what the combined company will look like going forward and anticipated synergies. For example, add discussion on how each company complements or overlaps each other, whether you are focused on the same markets, and, if so, what plans you have to integrate operations or eliminate duplicative functions. Opinion of VirtGame`s Financial Advisor, page 39 38. Refer to this subsection`s second paragraph. Disclose also whether Trenwith has provided services to VirtGame or any affiliates during the preceding two years. If so, disclose those services and the compensation Trenwith received for them. See Item 4(b) of Form S-4 and Item 9(b)(4) of Schedule 13E-3. 39. Revise this subsection`s fourth paragraph to clarify that the summary includes all material information about the Trenwith opinion and the methodologies that Trenwith employed in arriving at its opinion. 40. Clarify what you mean by the "qualified in its entirety" language in the last paragraph on page 39 because a prospectus must contain all material information about the contents of any document filed as an exhibit to the S-4 or incorporated by reference into the S-4 and to which the prospectus refers. 41. Refer to the fourth, fifth, and sixth bullet points on page 40. Summarize in sufficient detail each of the analyses performed by Trenwith. Disclose how each analysis related to Trenwith`s opinion that the consideration is fair to VirtGame`s stockholders so that you disclose the bases for and methods of arriving at your findings. See Item 1015(b)(6) of Regulation M-A. Where appropriate, consider tabular presentation of data to assist the reader. Material United States Federal Income Tax Consequences, page 40 42. We understand that you intend to file by amendment the tax opinions. If VirtGame`s counsel and Progressive`s counsel elect to use a short form tax opinion, the exhibit 8 short form opinion and the prospectus both must state clearly that the discussion in this subsection is their opinions. It is unacceptable for the short form opinion or the prospectus to state that the discussion in the prospectus is a fair and accurate summary or a fair and accurate discussion of the tax consequences. If applicable, revise this subsection`s first sentence. Exchange of VirtGame Common Stock or Preferred Stock for Progressive Common Stock, page 42 43. Refer to the phrase "Assuming that the integrated mergers qualify as reorganization." Since it is inappropriate to assume any legal conclusion underlying the tax opinions, revise the disclosure. Appraisal Rights, page 75 44. Clarify in this section`s second paragraph that the discussion includes all material information about the law pertaining to appraisal rights under Delaware`s General Corporation Law. Unaudited Pro Forma Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements, page 79 45. Since you will have to revise the S-4 to update both Progressive`s and VirtGame`s financial statements to reflect the first quarter 2005, update your unaudited pro forma condensed consolidated financial statements. The pro forma balance sheet should be based on the latest balance sheets included in the S-4, and the pro forma statement of operations should be based on the latest fiscal year and interim period included in the filing. You should present a pro forma balance sheet as of March 31, 2005 and a pro forma statement of operations for both the three months ended March 31, 2005 and the year ended December 31, 2004. Unaudited Pro Forma Condensed Consolidated Statement of Operations, page 81 46. For adjustments (a) and (b), explain to us whether "the elimination of costs associated with emp