SEC Comment Letter for HARMONY GOLD MINING CO LTD (HMY, HGMCF) (CIK 0001023514) (HMY) — Mar 30, 2007
HARMONY GOLD MINING CO LTD (HMY, HGMCF) (CIK 0001023514)
Date: March 30, 2007 · CIK: 0001023514 · Accession: 0000000000-07-016051
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 001-31545
Show Raw Text
UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
100 F Street, NE
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549-7010
DIVISION OF
CORPORATION FINANCE MAIL STOP 7010
March 30, 2007
Ms. Nomfundo Vuyiswa Lila Qangule
Chief Financial Officer
Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
Suite No. 1
Private Bag X1
Melrose Arch, 2076 South Africa
Re: Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
Form 20-F for Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2006
Filed October 31, 2006
File No. 001-31545
Dear Ms. Qangule:
We have reviewed your filing and have the following comments. We have
limited our review of your filings to those issues we have addressed in our comments.
Where indicated, we think you should revise your document in response to these comments. If you disagree, we will consider your explanation as to why our comment is inapplicable or a revision is unnecessary. Please be as detailed as necessary in your explanation. In some of our comments, we may ask you to provide us with information so we may better understand your disclosure. After reviewing this information, we may raise additional comments.
Please understand that the purpose of our review process is to assist you in your compliance with the applicable disclosure requirements and to enhance the overall disclosure in your filing. We look forward to working with you in these respects. We welcome any questions you may have about our comments or any other aspect of our review. Feel free to call us at the telephone numbers listed at the end of this letter.
Ms. Nomfundo Vuyiswa Lila Qangule
Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
March 30, 2007 Page 2
Form 20-F for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 2006
Information on the Company, page 19
Year-on-year reconciliation of Harmony’s ore reserves, page 38
1. We note your statement that you use “the South African code for the Reporting of Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves (the SAMREC Code), which sets out internationally recognized procedures and standards for reporting of mineral resources and ore reserves.” We further note your disclosure that “In reporting of reserves, we have complied with Industry Guide 7 of the United States Securities and Exchange Commission.” Please confirm, if true, that the reserve quantities used to measure the financial results of your mining operations are limited to proven and probable reserves, as defined by Industry Guide 7, or otherwise advise.
Operating and Financial Review and Prospects, page 133
Share-Based Compensation, page 147
2. We note your statement that the “charge in fiscal 2006 relates to the amortization of the fair value of the 2005, 2003 and 2001 options;” and that the “charge in fiscal 2005 relates to the amortization of the fair value of the 2005, 2003 and 2001 option grants for Harmony.” Please expand your disclosure to explain the nature of these charges.
2 Accounting Policies, page F-7
(t) Revenue Recognition, page F-14
3. We note that you have revenues “from silver and other by-products sales” and that these sales are “credited to production costs as a by-product credit.” Please expand your disclosure to include the amount of such revenue for each period reported. Additionally, please expand your MD&A to clearly indicate that you generate by-product revenues on certain of your operating units and why you believe that presentation of these revenue streams as a by-product is appropriate. Furthermore, include a trend analysis to identify the amount and types of by-product revenue generated for each period presented and indicate whether or not you believe, based on your best estimate that presentation of these revenue streams as by-products will continue to be appropriate in the future.
Ms. Nomfundo Vuyiswa Lila Qangule
Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
March 30, 2007 Page 3
3 Accounting Changes, page F-16
(b) Stripping costs incurred during the production phase of a mine, page F-17
4. Please tell us what you mean by your disclosure that states “capitalization of post-production stripping costs is appropriate only to the extent product inventory exists at the end of a reporting period” and clarify your disclosure to explain how your accounting policy complies with EITF 04-6.
15 (Loss)/Earnings Per Share, page F-34
5. We note your disclosure that the “inclusion of share options issued to employees as of June 30, 2006, as potential ordinary shares, would have an anti-dilutive effect on diluted loss per share. Accordingly, such additional shares have not been taken into account in the determination of diluted loss per share.” Please disclose the number of securities that could potentially dilute basic earnings/loss per share in the future that were not included in the computation of diluted earnings/loss per share because to do so would have been antiduilutive for the periods presented in accordance with paragraph 40(c) of FAS 128.
26 Long Term loans, page F-41
6. We note that you issued an international unsecured fixed rate convertible bond totaling R1,700 million in May 2004 and that the “bonds are convertible at the option of the bondholders at any time on or after July 1, 2004 and up to and including May 15, 2009.” We further note that the “number of ordinary shares to be issued at such a conversion shall be determined by dividing the principal amount of each bond by the conversion price in effect on the relevant conversion date.” Please tell us how you considered the guidance in FAS 150, FAS 133 and EITF 00-19 with respect to your convertible bond and any associated embedded derivatives. You may wish to refer to section II.B. within the outline entitled Current Accounting and Disclosure Issues in the Division of Corporation Finance,
located at
http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cfacctdisclosureissues.pdf .
35 Cash (Utilized)/Generated by Operations, page F-54
7. We note that in providing the reconciliation to net cash flows from operating activities you begin with loss before taxation, minority interest and effect of change in accounting principal rather than net income/loss. Please revise your presentation to reconcile net income/loss to net cash flow from operating activities, as contemplated by paragraph 28 of FAS 95.
38 Geographical and Segment Information, page F-56
Ms. Nomfundo Vuyiswa Lila Qangule
Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
March 30, 2007 Page 4
8. Please tell us how you have complied with the reconciliation requirement for segment revenues, reported profit or loss, assets and other significant items to the corresponding enterprise amounts in accordance with paragraph 25(c) of FAS 131.
Exhibits 4.20 and 4.21
9. We note that your certification pursuant to Section 302 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 is worded such that it does not precisely match the language as set forth in the Act. Refer to Instruction 12 to Item 19 of Form 20-F for the exact text of the required Section 302 certifications, and amend your exhibits as appropriate. In this regard and without limitation, there is no provision for your certifying officer to identify the position held with the Company in the first line of the certification. Please refer to FAQ 11 within the Division of Corporation Finance: Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 – Frequently Asked Questions, located at
http://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/faqs/soxact2002.htm and amend your
exhibits as appropriate.
Engineering Comments
General
10. We note that your website and some press releases refer to or use the terms “measured,” “indicated,” and “inferred,” resources. If you continue to make references on your web site or press releases to reserve measures other than those recognized by the SEC, please accompany such disclosure with the following cautionary language:
Cautionary Note to U.S. Investors -The United States Securities and Exchange Commission permits U.S. mining companies, in their filings with the SEC, to disclose only those mineral deposits that a company can economically and legally extract or produce. We use certain terms on this website (or press release), such as “measured,” “indicated,” and “inferred” “resources,” which the SEC guidelines strictly prohibit U.S. registered companies from including in their filings with the SEC. U.S. Investors are urged to consider closely the disclosure in our Form 20-F, File No. 001-31545, which may be secured from us, or from the SEC’s website at
http://www.sec.gov/edgar.shtml .
11. Insert a small-scale map showing the location and access to each property, as required by Instruction 1(a) to Item 4.D of Form 20-F. Note that SEC’s EDGAR program now accepts Adobe PDF files and digital maps, so please include these
Ms. Nomfundo Vuyiswa Lila Qangule
Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
March 30, 2007 Page 5
maps in any amendments that are uploaded to EDGAR. It is relatively easy to include automatic links at the appropriate locations within the document to GIF or JPEG files, which will allow figures and diagrams to appear in the right location when the document is viewed on the Internet. For more information, please consult the EDGAR manual, and if additional assistance is required, please call Filer Support at 202-551-8900. We believe the guidance in Instruction 1(a) to Item 4.D of Form 20-F would generally require maps and drawings with the following features:
• A legend or explanation showing, by means of pattern or symbol, every pattern or symbol used on the map or drawing.
• A graphical bar scale should be included. Additional representations of scale such as "one inch equals one mile" may be utilized provided the original scale of the map has not been altered.
• A north arrow.
• An index map showing where the property is situated in relationship to the state or province, etc., in which it was located.
• A title of the map or drawing, and the date on which it was drawn.
• In the event interpretive data is submitted in conjunction with any map, the identity of the geologist or engineer that prepared such data.
Any drawing should be simple enough or of sufficiently large scale to clearly show all features on the drawing.
Papua New Guinea, page 28
12. Please describe only geology, history, or e xploration results that are directly
related to the properties that your company has the right to explore or mine as other disclosure of adjacent properties may cause investors to infer that your property also has commercial mineralization because of its proximity. Unless you also control the Bulolo, Wall and Edie Creek areas, remove all references to these mines, adjacent or analogous properties, deposits, occurrences, or exploration activities by other companies outside of your company’s properties and restrict your disclosure solely to your properties.
Wafi Golpu and Morobe, page 28
Ms. Nomfundo Vuyiswa Lila Qangule
Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
March 30, 2007 Page 6
13. You have quantified ore reserves of 9.3 million ounces of gold and 3.6 billion pounds of copper in the Wafi Hill area and identified a further 5.5 million ounces in Morobe areas. Please classify these quantities as either proven or probable reserves and separately provide to our engineers the executive summary of the feasibility study which established the technical, legal, and economic validity of these reserves. Please disclose within the filing the reserve tonnage, ore grade or tenor, economic cutoff grade, and expected metallurgical recovery within the reserve tables. Please note that combining proven and probable reserve categories is contrary to the explicit guidance of Industry Guide 7, which provides that reserves may be combined as "proven and probable" only if proven and probable reserves cannot be readily segregated.
In the event a feasibility study has not completed for these product quantities, you may classify them as mineralized material, provided the mineralization that has been sufficiently sampled at close enough intervals to reasonably assume continuity between samples within the area of influence of the samples. In this instance you would need to disclose that such a deposit would not qualify as a reserve, until a comprehensive evaluation based upon unit cost, grade, recoveries, and other material factors conclude the technical, legal, and economic feasibility.
Moa Creek, page 28
14. You cite the best intersections for your drill results. As a general checklist, when reporting the results of sampling and chemical analyses, the following points may assist you in preparing meaningful disclosure about mineralization of existing or potential economic significance on your property:
• Disclose only weighed-average sample analyses associated with a measured length or a substantial volume.
• Eliminate all analyses from “grab” or “dump” samples, unless the sample is of a substantial and disclosed weight.
• Eliminate all disclosure of the highest values or grades of sample sets.
• Eliminate grades disclosed as “up to” or “as high as” or “ranging from.”
• Eliminate statements containing grade and/or sample-width ranges.
• Aggregated sample values from related locations should be aggregated based on a weighted average of lengths of the samples.
Ms. Nomfundo Vuyiswa Lila Qangule
Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
March 30, 2007 Page 7
• Generally, use tables to improve readability of sample and drilling data.
• Soil samples may be disclosed as a weighted average value over an area.
• Refrain from reporting single soil sample values.
• Convert all ppb quantities to ppm quantities for disclosure.
Please revise your disclosures to comply with this guidance.
Evander, page 31
15. You state gold grade ranges using cmg/t units of measurement. Please explain this measurement term within the filing and discuss the significance of these sample result and measurements as it relates to your mining operations and the use of this evaluation compared to other methods for the average investor. Please define these terms and other terms in the text or glossary.
Description of Property, page 36
16. Please correlate the operational mining areas to the mine sites areas or shaft-operational zones and/or the reserve areas. Is the ARMgold operation the same as the Orkney operation as discussed on pages 40 and 53?
Ore Reserve Statement (Imperial) as at June 30, 2006, page 40
17. Please disclose the cutoff grades or tenor used to define your ore reserves within your ore reserve tables. In establishing the cut-off grade, it must realistically reflect the location, deposit scale, continuity, assumed mining method, metallurgical processes, costs, and reasonable metal prices. These cutoff grades may be included within the reserve table or as footnote following the reserve declaration.
18. Please state the estimated metallurgical recovery for the Western Area South Deep deposit.
Ms. Nomfundo Vuyiswa Lila Qangule
Harmony Gold Mining Company Limited
March 30, 2007 Page 8
Elaneskraal Operations, page 42
19. You use the terms “lost time frequency” and “fatality frequency rates” in describing the accident and death rates incurred by your mining operations. Please include the workforce staffing levels to which these statistics apply and define these terms in the text or glossary.
Plants, page 44
20. The actual metallurgical recovery stated for the Elansrand plant of 91.12 % does not closely correlate to the approximate reserve recoveries of 95.6% for the Elaneskraal as found on page 40. Similar variances were noted for the weighted average of the Central and Saaiplaas plants, Free State 1, and Target plants. Please discuss any metallurgical recovery challenges you may have experienced and the actions taken to address these concerns. Please state whether this will affect your reserve estimates in the future. Please state how well your actual performance compares to your reserve estimate assumptions as your reconcile your ore reserve estimates.
Tshepong, page 59
21. You refer to the reserves associated with the Tshepong sh