SEC Company Response from GRAN TIERRA ENERGY INC. (GTE) (CIK 0001273441) (GTE) — Jul 18, 2006
GRAN TIERRA ENERGY INC. (GTE) (CIK 0001273441)
Date: July 18, 2006 · CIK: 0001273441 · Accession: 0001144204-06-028917
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-111656, 333-132352
Referenced dates: April 7, 2006, April 7, 2006
Show Raw Text
CORRESP
1
filename1.htm
Jason
H. Scott
jscott@mcguirewoods.com
Direct:
704.373.8862
Direct
Fax: 704.353.6181
July
18,
2006
Mr.
H.
Roger Schwall
Assistant
Director
Division
of Corporation Finance
Mail
Stop
7010
Washington,
D.C. 20549-7010
Re:
Gran
Tierra Energy Inc. (the
“Company”)
Registration
Statement on Form SB-2
Filed
March 10, 2006
File
No. 333-132352
Form
10-KSB for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2005
Filed
March 10, 2006
File
No. 333-111656
Dear
Mr.
Schwall:
This
is
in response to your comment letter of May 10, 2006 to Dana Coffield with respect
to the above-referenced filings. The Company is simultaneously filing Amendment
No. 2 to the Annual Report on Form 10-KSB for the period ended December 31,
2005, and pursuant to a conversation with the staff, will not file Amendment
No.
2 to Registration Statement No. 333-132352 until deemed appropriate in light
of
any pending acquisitions.
We
have
set forth below the comments in your letter of May 10, 2006 in italics with
the
Company’s responses to each.
General
1.
You
will expedite the review process if you address each portion of every
numbered comment that appears in this letter. Provide complete responses
and, where disclosure has changed, indicate precisely where in the
marked
version of the amendment you file we will find your responsive changes.
Similarly, to minimize the likelihood that we will reissue comments,
please make corresponding changes where applicable throughout your
document. For example, we might comment on one section or example,
but our
silence on similar or related disclosure elsewhere does not relieve
you of
the need to make appropriate revisions elsewhere in the same document
or
other document as appropriate.
July
18,
2006
Page
2
RESPONSE:
We have
addressed your comments in the letter below and in the filed amendment to the
Company’s annual report on Form 10-KSB/A. We will also address your comments to
the registration statement when the Company files its amended registration
statement on Form SB-2/A. We have indicated in this letter where our responsive
changes appear in the Form 10-KSB/A.
Registration
Statement on Form SB-2
Recent
Developments, page 2
2.
Expand
this section to clearly discuss the reverse takeover cited in prior
comment 3. We note your discussion on page
39.
RESPONSE:
We
will
modify the “Recent Developments” section in response to this comment 2 when the
Company files its amended registration statement.
3.
We
note your response to our prior comment 5. We note your updated disclosure
in regard to the loan. Please explain what you mean when you say
the loan
“will be extinguished.”
RESPONSE:
The
loan
will remain outstanding as inter-company debt. We will modify the Form SB-2/A
in
response to this comment 3 when the Company files its amended registration
statement.
4.
We
note your response to our prior comment 6. You indicated in your
response
that you provided copies of the private placement memorandum and
Canadian
offering memorandum. However, these documents were not included in
the
package you sent us. Please provide these
documents.
RESPONSE:
Enclosed
herewith please find copies of the private placement memorandum and Canadian
offering memorandum.
5.
Please
separate your discussion of the first and second private placements
to
more clearly state the total proceeds received from each placement
(we
note that you discuss the first placement and the first closing on
the
second placement together), the amount of cash commissions paid from
the
proceeds, identifying the persons who received the commissions, the
net
proceeds to you, and the use of proceeds. Please also provide the
same
information for the third
offering.
RESPONSE:
We
will
modify the Form SB-2/A in response to this comment 5 when the Company files
its
amended registration statement.
6.
You
provide two different dates for the date of the first closing on
the
second private placement, September 27 and October 27. Please revise
or
advise.
July
18,
2006
Page
3
RESPONSE:
October
27 is the date of the first closing on the second private placement. We will
modify Form SB-2/A to reflect this date when the Company files its amended
registration statement.
Selling
Stockholders, page 17
7.
We
note your response to our prior comment 11. However, there are still
several entities for which the identity of the natural persons with
power
to vote or to dispose of the securities offered for resale has not
been
provided. Please provide this
information.
RESPONSE:
We
will
modify the “Selling Stockholders” section in response to this comment 7 when the
Company files its amended registration statement.
Management’s
Discussion and Analysis
8.
We
note that you have included a discussion about your ability to continue
as
a going concern in response to prior comment 13 in our letter dated
April
7, 2006. As previously explained, you should also disclose that there
is
substantial doubt about your ability to continue as a going concern,
and
include details of your plans to overcome your financial difficulties,
to
comply with the guidance in FRC Section 607.02; comparable disclosure
is
generally required in your financial statements under this guidance.
In
addition, indicate what you believe the outcome will be in the event
your
plans are unsuccessful in addressing the going concern
uncertainty.
RESPONSE:
We
will
modify the “Management’s Discussion and Analysis” section in response to this
comment 8 when the Company files its amended registration statement, and we
have
modified the “Management’s Discussion and Analysis” section on page 14 of
the Form 10-KSB/A.
Plan
of Operations, page 28
9.
Within
your response to prior comment 16 in our letter dated April 7, 2006,
you
state the consummations of the acquisitions you announced in the
Form 8-Ks
are not considered probable. Given that you had deemed information
about
these agreements to be material to security holders in filing the
Form
8-K’s, coupled with the level of detail of the terms of the agreements
you
have provided in the press releases, it is unclear to us how you
reached
the conclusion that these acquisitions are not
probable.
The
determination of a transaction’s probability of occurrence is based on facts and
circumstances; however, FRC 506.02.c.ii, states that the consummation of a
transaction is considered probable whenever the registrant’s financial
statements alone would not provide investors adequate financial information
with
which to make an investment decision. Based on the information you have
disclosed, these potential acquisitions would appear to be material to your
current and future financial position, results of operations and cash flows,
and
would therefore trigger a reporting obligation under this
guidance.
July
18,
2006
Page
4
Please
provide further detail to support the conclusions you have reached regarding
the
probability of these acquisitions as well as the potential acquisition of Argosy
Energy International, announced in the Form 8-K that you filed on April 7,
2006.
It should be clear how you have evaluated each aspect of each transaction,
including the likelihood of satisfying each of the contingencies
mentioned.
If
you continue to regard these transactions as being not probable, you should
submit the draft disclosure revisions that you would file in amendments to
each
of the Form 8-K’s to advise readers of your skepticism and uncertainty
surrounding the prospect of completing these acquisitions, including details
sufficient to understand the basis for your earlier disclosures, and the reasons
that you believe financial information about the targets is no longer relevant.
Under these circumstances, disclosure in your registration statement would
also
be essential to correct any misperceptions over the likelihood of
occurrence.
To
the extent these business combinations are considered probable, you will be
required to include financial statements of these businesses along with related
pro forma financial information to comply with item 310(c) and (d) of Regulation
SB. Please note we presume these acquisitions would be considered significant
at
the greater than 50% level; therefore, the acquiree financial statements would
need to be included within the registration statement.
In
addition, please discuss the terms of each of these agreements (including the
amount of any break-up fees), how you intend to fund the acquisitions, your
increase in your capital expenditures, and how you anticipate these interests
will impact your future results of operations and cash flows. If required by
Item 601(10)(C) of Regulation S-B, please also file the acquisition agreements
as exhibits.
RESPONSE:
Pursuant
to our conversation with the Staff, the Company will not file an amended Form
SB-2 until deemed appropriate in light of any pending acquisitions. If required,
the Company will file financial statements of acquired businesses along with
related pro forma financial information to comply with Item 310(c) and (d)
of
Regulation S-B.
10.
You
state that no drilling is planned for 2006 and that your current
cash and
expected cash flow will fund operations through 2006. Please add
a
discussion of how your 2006 business plan will change if you close
on any
of your three planned acquisitions. We note that in the press release
filed as an exhibit to the Form 8-K filed April 7, 2006, you state
that
“[a] total of nine (gross) wells have been planned for 2006/early
2007….”
You also state that the corresponding capital budget is approximately
$25
million.
RESPONSE:
Pursuant
to our conversation with the Staff, the Company will not file an amended Form
SB-2 until deemed appropriate in light of pending acquisitions. The Company
will
add a discussion of any changes to the 2006 business plan, if
applicable.
July
18,
2006
Page
5
Liquidity
and Capital Resources
Liquidity,
page 20
11.
We
note your response to our prior comment 20. You state that after
escrow is
terminated, you will still be subject to additional cash calls. Please
discuss the reasons for any additional cash calls, their amount and
their
anticipated timing.
RESPONSE:
We
will
modify the “Liquidity” section in response to comment 11 when the Company files
its amended registration statement, and we have modified the “Liquidity” section
on page 16 of the Form 10-KSB/A.
Business
The
Argentina Acquisitions, page 38
12.
We
note your response to our prior comment 22. We re-issue this comment
in
light of your need to discuss the CGC acquisition in the registration
statement. Please state whether your pending acquisition of interests
of
CGC include any of the properties listed in this section. If so,
please
discuss how the acquisition would affect your
operations.
RESPONSE:
Pursuant
to our conversation with the Staff, the Company will not file an amended Form
SB-2 until deemed appropriate in light of any pending acquisitions. The Company
will discuss the acquisition of CGC assets as required at that
time.
Directors,
Executive Officers, Promoters and Control Persons
Board
Committees, page 47
13.
We
note your statement that you audit committee charter will be available
on
your website as soon as practicable. We also note that you filed
your
audit committee charter as an exhibit to your Form 10-KSB filed on
March
10, 2006. Please advise as to when your audit committee charter will
be
posted to your website.
RESPONSE:
The
Company’s audit committee charter has been posted to its website.
2005
Equity Incentive Plan
Duration,
Amendment and Termination, page 52
14.
You
state that the plan terminates on November 10, 2005. The incentive
plan
filed as an exhibit states that the plan will expire on November
10, 2015.
Please revise or advise.
RESPONSE:
The plan
terminates on November 10, 2015. We will modify the “Duration, Amendment and
Termination” section to reflect the November 10, 2015 expiration date when the
Company files its amended registration statement, and we have modified the
Form
10-KSB/A on page 61.
July
18,
2006
Page
6
Description
of Securities
Exc