SEC Comment Letter for HouseValues, Inc. (CIK 0001298978) — Oct 1, 2004
HouseValues, Inc. (CIK 0001298978)
Date: Oct. 1, 2004 · CIK: 0001298978 · Accession: 0000000000-04-031585
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-118740
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT> <TYPE>LETTER <SEQUENCE>1 <FILENAME>filename1.txt <TEXT> Mail Stop 0409 October 1, 2004 Ian Morris Chief Executive Officer HouseValues, Inc. 15 Lake Bellevue Drive, Suite 100 Bellevue, Washington 98005 Re: HouseValues, Inc. Registration Statement on Form S-1 Registration No. 333-118740 Filed September 1, 2004 Dear Mr. Morris: We have reviewed your filing and have the following comments. Where indicated, we think you should revise your document in response to these comments. If you disagree, we will consider your explanation as to why our comment is inapplicable or a revision is unnecessary. Please be as detailed as necessary in your explanation. In some of our comments, we may ask you to provide us with supplemental information so we may better understand your disclosure. After reviewing this information, we may or may not raise additional comments. Please understand that the purpose of our review process is to assist you in your compliance with the applicable disclosure requirements and to enhance the overall disclosure in your filing. We look forward to working with you in these respects. We welcome any questions you may have about our comments or on any other aspect of our review. Feel free to call us at the telephone numbers listed at the end of this letter. For purposes of this comment letter, we refer to the pagination, paragraphs, sentence and line numbers as displayed by the courtesy copy version of your Form S-1 filed on September 1, 2004. Form S-1 General 1. Please tell us the exemption from registration relied upon for each of the following transfers and the facts relied upon to make the exemption available: * We note that on page 65 you disclose that on April 22, 2004, Mr. Powell, your founder and Chairman of the Board, and the holders of Series B convertible preferred stock that elected to purchase or sell shares of common stock under the Co-Sale Agreement transferred an aggregate of 6,960,314 shares of common stock to William Blair Capital Partners. * We note that on January 29, 2002, Mr. Powell sold 700,000 shares of common stock to Second Avenue Partners and certain other holders of your Series A and Series B convertible preferred stock for $1,400,000. 2. Please provide supplementally copies of any graphics, charts, maps, photographs, and related captions or other artwork including logos that you intend to use in the prospectus. Such graphics and pictorial representations should not be included in any preliminary prospectus distributed to prospective investors prior to the staff`s review of those items. 3. Please avoid using the term "solution" as it is jargon. Without identifying a problem or question, the term "solution" is abstract and should be replaced by a more concrete term or terms. Instead of using the term solution, please replace the term with a description of your actual products and services. We specifically note your description of your business in the summary and throughout as an "innovative marketing solution." Due to its vagueness, the term "solution" is unhelpful to investors and does not adequately describe any product or service. Please revise to eliminate your use of the word "solution" throughout the prospectus. 4. We note that you cite data from REAL Trends, Borrell Associates, National Association of Realtors and Hebert Research throughout the prospectus. Please provide us with supporting evidence, such as a copy of the published report or study, for this information and highlight the specific information that you relied upon for the disclosure. Also, please tell us whether any of the reports were prepared specifically for you. If so, tell why you have not named the preparers as experts and included their consents pursuant to Rule 436. Since you commissioned Hebert Research to provide you with the 2004 Survey, it appears that Hebert should be named as an expert and you should file an expert`s consent as an exhibit to this registration statement. Prospectus Summary Our Company, page 1 5. We note your disclosure on page 46 appears to state that nearly all personalized coaching and training instruction sessions are provided to your agent customers over the telephone except for potentially your In-Market Training Seminars. In light of this disclosure, please revise to clarify that nearly all of your coaching and training services are conducted over the telephone or online. 6. Briefly outline the components of the "Market Leader online prospect management system integrated offering." Without more specificity describing the software and web site lead tracking components of Market Leader, the present description of this tool may be confusing and too vague to investors. 7. Please briefly discuss how you generate revenues from your operations, i.e. your short-term subscription service contracts to provide homebuyer and seller leads to real estate agents. Our Solution, page 1 8. We note your disclosure on page 45 appears to state that your agent customers, not you, provide the free comparative market analysis/estimates of a home`s current value. Please revise to explain this fact here and whether you serve any role in preparing the estimate. Also, briefly explain whether you conduct any due diligence when selecting your agent customers. For example, do your agent customers hold certified appraiser credentials? Do you conduct criminal or other background checks of these real estate agents who you provide the personal information of those homebuyers and sellers visiting your web site? Our Strategy, page 2 9. Please revise the fourth bullet point to briefly describe the "related markets" into which you intend to extend your business. We note your competitor, InterActiveCorp., recently expanded its business when it announced its intent to acquire ServiceMagic, an online home services company. Is this type of related market you intend to enter? Company Information, page 2 10. Please list your other registered trademarks or trade names, such as "JustListed.com" and "Market Leader." Supplementally, please tell us whether you use the trademarks, trade names or service marks of other companies to sell your services. If so, please tell us whether you have sought and been granted permission to use these trademarks. The Offering Use of Proceeds, page 3 11. Please revise to describe with more specificity what portion of the proceeds will be used for your listed purposes. Item 504 of Regulation S-K requires that you provide an estimate for the multiple uses of proceeds to convey. Further, confirm that the listed order in the prospectus reflects your order of priority for using these net proceeds. For example, consider the amount of the net proceeds you will allocate to: (1) expansion of operations; (2) capital expenditures; (3) future working capital; (4) general corporate purposes; and (5) acquisition or investment of businesses, products or technologies that are complimentary to your own. Please further revise to disclose the specific uses of the proceeds designated as "general corporate and working capital," given that your business plan appears to focus primarily on the expansion of your operations. Similarly, revise your disclosure on page 21. Risk Factors, page 6 General 12. Revise to eliminate mitigating language from the risk factor section. Mitigating language directly counters the point of disclosing the risk and is therefore inappropriate for this section of disclosure. For example, please revise to delete the following dependent clauses: * "Although we endeavor to train and provide tools to agent customers" and ending "client satisfactions." (Our brand could be harmed if agent customers . . ., page 13); * "Although we have not experienced any material security breaches to date" (Our reputation and customer service offerings may be harmed by security breaches, page 16); and * "Although our management currently intends to use the net proceeds in the manner described in "Use of Proceeds" (Our management has broad discretion in the use of the net proceeds from this offering many not use them effectively, page 19). Our operating results are subject to fluctuations that may cause our stock price to decline, page 6 13. We note your statement in the first sentence of the second paragraph concerning investors and securities analysts. Please revise to delete you reference to securities analysts. In addition, on a supplemental basis, please tell us whether you have had any discussions with securities analysts about covering your stock following the completion of the IPO, the extent of these conversations and whether you are currently aware of any analysts that intend to cover your stock following the IPO. Similarly, revise the first bullet point of the first full risk factor on page 18. We may be unable to compete successfully with our current or future competitors, page 7 14. Please revise to generally describe the barriers to entry, which you refer to as low. For example, clarify whether you are referring to the financial cost of entering into your online market, the technological expertise needed or the ability to attract clients from the fragmented real estate agent industry. Any failure to increase the number of our customers would harm our business, page 8 15. It appears that you believe you will be able to estimate when you have approached the majority of residential real estate agents. Please clarify what percentage of real estate agents you believe you have currently approached to join subscribe as clients, i.e. the percentage or extent of your market penetration. Any failure to retain agent customers could harm our business, page 8 16. We note your statement that you have occasionally failed to deliver the guaranteed minimum number of leads to your customers. We further note your disclosure on page 28 stating that during the first half of 2004, you were unable to deliver approximately 3% of your total lead obligations to customers. Please revise this risk factor to state the percentage of total lead obligations you were unable to deliver for fiscal year ended 2003 and for the six months ended June 30, 2004. We experience high turnover of agent customers and have a limited ability to predict the rate of contract extensions, page 8 17. We note your statement that in the past, you have experienced high termination rates. Please revise your disclosure to provide one or two key reasons why customers have not extended their initial contracts. 18. In the fifth sentence, you refer to "many" of your customers that use the JustListed service are still in their initial contract terms. Please revise to quantify the number of customers in their initial term. Prospective home buyers and sellers may be reluctant to sign up for our services due to general privacy concerns, page 10 19. Supplementally, please tell us whether you have experienced any material adverse events, such as a misappropriation of third-party information or other like events. 20. Please revise the text of this risk factor to describe the specific type of "adverse judicial determinations" that would place prospective homebuyer and seller personal information at risk. We collect personally identifiable information from prospective homebuyers and sellers and evaluate the use of our Market Leader prospect management system . . ., page 10 21. Revise to list the "other" types of information, other than personal information, that you collect from prospective homebuyers, sellers and agents. 22. If you believe your published privacy statement is material to how you conduct your operations, where you deem appropriate, revise your prospectus to include a summary of the material terms of this policy. 23. Supplementally, please tell us whether in the past you acted inconsistently with the terms of your privacy statement or privacy laws. If so, please tell us whether any material adverse events to your operations originated from such actions. 24. Please tell us on a supplemental basis whether you disclose, homebuyer or seller personal or other information to third parties other than real estate agents. If so, who do you share this information? For what reasons do you share such information? Do you receive compensation for sharing these lists? The value of our products and services could be diminished if anti- spam software filters out email we send, page 10 25. Please revise your disclosure to clearly state, if true, that a portion of the email you send out to homebuyers and sellers on behalf of agents and email you send out to attract real estate agent customers is unsolicited or spam. Our JustListed service is enhanced by our access to real estate multiple listing services provided by third parties that we do not control, page 11 26. Please consider clarifying what you mean by the "selected" markets serviced by your subsidiary Soar Solutions. Does Soar Solutions service 10 or 100 markets? Specific regional markets? Major metropolitan markets? Decreases in agent acquisition or retention may not be immediately reflected in our operating results, page 11 27. Supplementally, please tell us how long, duration in months or quarters, you believe that your financial statements may not accurately reflect your operating results due to a decrease of real estate agent customers. If we fail to comply with the various laws and regulations that govern the real estate industry, our business may be harmed, page 11 28. We note your statement that you may not have always been in compliance with each of these requirements. To your knowledge, please tell us whether you believe you have materially failed to comply with these rules and regulations including RESPA. Changes in real estate laws and regulations and the rules of industry organizations could harm our business, page 11 29. Please revise the risk factor caption to include the specific harm that could be caused to your operations from a change in the real estate laws. We depend on key personnel and cannot assure you that these employees will continue to stay with us, page 13 30. Please revise to list the names of the senior executive officers that you view as key personnel and the reasons why you have so designated these officers as key to your operations. Any efforts to expand into new lines of business may not be successful . . ., page 13 31. Revise the text of this risk factor to describe the "areas" for which you have "limited experience" and the extent of this experience. Third parties may copy or otherwise obtain and use our proprietary information without authorization or develop similar technology independently, page 14 32. Please revise to specifically state the number of copyrights and trademarks you currently hold versus the number of applications for additional intellectual property protection. We may have to pay additional state taxes on our revenues for past years an for future periods, page 16 33. Please revise to quantify the amount of additional state taxes you may be required to pay. Supplementally, please provide us with an update of the current audit being conducted by the State of Washington and whether any other states claim that owe them unpaid sales or service taxes based on your operations in their state. If we fail to maintain an effective system of internal controls, we may not be able to accurately report our financial results or prevent fraud, page 17 34. Please revise to clearly convey to investors the potential adverse consequences, other than general regulatory scrutiny, for failing to accurately report your financial results and the potential adverse effect on your operations. Our existing shareholders have significant control of our management and affairs . . . page 18 35. If true, please revise this caption to reflect that existing shareholders "will continue" to have significant control after the offering. 36. Revise to