SEC Company Response from INNOVATIVE CARD TECHNOLOGIES INC (CIK 0001300578) — Jan 12, 2005
INNOVATIVE CARD TECHNOLOGIES INC (CIK 0001300578)
Date: Jan. 12, 2005 · CIK: 0001300578 · Accession: 0001144204-05-001049
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-119814
Referenced dates: December 30, 2004
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>CORRESP
<SEQUENCE>1
<FILENAME>filename1.txt
<TEXT>
RICHARDSON & PATEL LLP
10900 WILSHIRE BOULEVARD
SUITE 500
LOS ANGELES, CA 90024
TELEPHONE (310) 208-1182
FACSIMILE (310) 208-1154
January 12, 2005
VIA EDGAR AND FACSIMILE
Securities and Exchange Commission
Division of Corporation Finance
Mail Stop 05-11
450 Fifth Street, NW
Washington DC, 20549
Attn.: William A. Bennett, Esq.
John Reynolds, Esq.
RE: INNOVATIVE CARD TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
REGISTRATION STATEMENT ON FORM SB-2/A
FILE NO. 333-119814
Messrs. Bennett and Reynolds:
On behalf of Innovative Card Technologies, Inc. (the "Company"), we
respectfully submit the Company's responses to the comments received from the
staff ("Staff") of the Securities and Exchange Commission in their letter dated
December 30, 2004. We have reproduced the Staff's comments in bold type and have
followed each comment with our response. References in this letter to "we,"
"our" or "us" mean the Company or its advisors, as the context may require.
GENERAL
1. WE NOTE THAT THE REGISTRATION STATEMENT CONTINUES TO COVER THE RESALE
OF OVER 75% OF SHARES TO BE OUTSTANDING AND APPROXIMATELY 60% BY
OFFICERS, DIRECTORS, MAJOR SHAREHOLDERS, PROMOTERS AND AFFILIATES OF
THE COMPANY. WE VIEW RESALE TRANSACTIONS OF THIS MAGNITUDE AS AN
OFFERING "BY OR ON BEHALF OF THE ISSUER" FOR PURPOSES OF RULE 415(A)(4)
OF REGULATION C. UNDER THE RULE, EQUITY SECURITIES OFFERED BY OR ON
BEHALF OF THE REGISTRANT CANNOT BE SOLD "AT THE MARKET" PRICE UNLESS
THE OFFERING SATISFIES THE REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH IN THE RULE. YOUR
OFFERING DOES NOT APPEAR TO MEET THE REQUIREMENTS. PLEASE REVISE YOUR
REGISTRATION STATEMENT TO PRICE THE SHARES AT THE FIXED PRICE FOR THE
DURATION OF THE OFFERING. THE PROSPECTUS SHOULD ALSO MAKE CLEAR THE
FACT THAT CERTAIN PERSONS ARE DEEMED UNDERWRITERS IN THIS OFFERING.
REVISE YOUR PROSPECTUS ACCORDINGLY, INCLUDING YOUR COVER PAGE, SUMMARY
AND PLAN OF DISTRIBUTION SECTION.
<PAGE>
Securities and Exchange Commission
January 12, 2005
2
The Staff's comment is noted with respect to Rule 415(a)(4) of
Regulation C, which permits an offering on a continuous or delayed
basis for an at the market offering of securities "by or on behalf of
the issuer" only on Form S-3, and subject to further conditions stated
therein. We spoke by telephone with Mr. Bennett on January 7, 2005, and
we understand from that telephone conversation the Staff's concern over
the applicability of Rule 415(a)(4) to officers, directors, major
shareholders, promoters or founders and affiliates of the Company,
which were selling stockholders for up to 7,870,377 shares of common
stock or approximately 60% of shares to be outstanding.
We have revised the shares being registered in the Registration
Statement to cover the resale of up to 3,219,500 shares of common
stock, or approximately 30% of the Company's total issued and
outstanding shares. We have removed the following officers, directors,
founders or promoters, major stockholders and affiliates from the
selling stockholder table in the Registration Statement: Alan
Finkelstein, Forest Finkelstein, Karim Souki with respect to shares
held by him as an individual, Bradley Ross, Luc Berthoud and Merco
Trustees (BVI) Limited. The 3,219,500 shares being registered include:
o 50,000 shares of common stock issued to Richardson & Patel LLP
o 960,000 shares of common stock underlying warrants issued in
conjunction with the Securities Purchase Agreement dated as of
December 23, 2003 ("Securities Purchase Agreement") (including
150,000 shares for Diana Kessler, 150,000 shares for Paul
Kessler, 280,000 shares for Elmsmere Group, 280,000 shares for
Freemount Trading Ltd, 80,000 for Steve Emerson and 20,000 for
Tyler Runnels); and
o 2,209,500 shares of common stock underlying series A preferred
stock issued to a number of investors pursuant to a private
placement from April 7, 2004 to October 18, 2004 (as described
in more detail in Attachment A to this letter)
The shares being registered that are beneficially owned by Paul Kessler
and Diana Derycz-Kessler represent 825,000 shares of common stock
(consisting of 525,000 shares of common stock underlying series A
preferred stock in the name of Bristol Investment Fund, Ltd. and an
aggregate 300,000 shares underlying warrants held by them as
individuals), or approximately 7.6% of the Company's total issued and
outstanding shares. With respect to shares beneficially owned by Karim
Souki, 200,000 shares underlying series A preferred stock in the name
of BSR Investment, Ltd. are being registered, or approximately 1.8% of
the Company's outstanding shares. The shares being registered that are
beneficially owned by David Mun-Gavin represent 585,000 shares of
common stock (consisting of 25,000 shares of common stock underlying
series A preferred stock, 280,000 shares of common stock underlying
warrants held by Elmsmere Group and 280,000 shares of common stock
underlying warrants held by Freemount Trading Ltd.), or 5.4% of the
Company's outstanding shares. Upon effectiveness of the Registration
<PAGE>
Securities and Exchange Commission
January 12, 2005
3
Statement, the shares being registered and beneficially held by Mr.
Kessler, Ms. Derycz-Kessler, Mr. Souki and Mr. Mun-Gavin will represent
approximately 50% of the 3,219,500 shares of tradable securities
without restriction. At April 6, 2005 and May 5, 2005, we expect the
number of tradable shares to increase as approximately 3,947,803 shares
of common stock, and the 250,000 shares of common stock and warrants to
purchase 1,540,000 shares of common stock issued pursuant to the
Securities Purchase Agreement, respectively, and not included in the
Registration Statement, will then be saleable, subject to restrictions
under Rule 144.
We do not believe that the offering of up to 825,000 shares
beneficially held by Mr. Kessler and Diana Derycz-Kessler, 200,000
shares beneficially held by Karim Souki and 585,000 shares beneficially
held by Mr. Mun-Gavin is an offering by or on behalf of the Company.
Those shares were purchased from the Company pursuant to the Securities
Purchase Agreement or in the Company's series A preferred stock
financing for gross cash consideration of $800,000. The terms of each
offering were based on arms' length negotiations. With respect to those
shares issued pursuant to the series A preferred stock financing, the
terms were identical to the terms for the shares purchased by other
investors. Given that the capital beneficially owned by these
individuals remains at risk to the same extent as all other investors,
it would not in our view be accurate or appropriate to describe the
offering of these shares as an offering by or on behalf of the Company.
SELLING STOCKHOLDERS, PAGE 11
2. PLEASE CLARIFY THE NATURAL PERSON WHO HAS VOTING AND INVESTMENT CONTROL
OVER THE SHARES BEING OFFERED BY BRISTOL CAPITAL ADVISORS. IN THIS
REGARD, WE DO NOT UNDERSTAND REFERENCE TO THE KESSLER REVOCABLE TRUST
IN FOOTNOTE 7 OR TO MR. KESSLER'S DISCLAIMER OF BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP,
ESPECIALLY GIVEN THE REVOCABLE NATURE OF THE TRUST. PLEASE ADVISE. SEE
ALSO FOOTNOTE 4 ON PAGE 22.
In response to the Staff's comment, we have revised footnote 7 on page
11 and footnote 4 on page 22 to identify the natural person who has
voting and investment control over shares being offered by Bristol
Capital Advisors, and we have deleted Mr. Kessler's disclaimer of
beneficial ownership.
3. WE DO NOT UNDERSTAND THE REPEATED USE OF FOOTNOTES 6 AND 12 FOR SEVERAL
OF THE SELLING SHAREHOLDERS.
We have revised the footnotes to the selling stockholder table to
reduce the number of footnotes and eliminate repeated use of footnotes.
SECURITY OWNERSHIP OF CERTAIN BENEFICIAL OWNERS AND MANAGEMENT, PAGE 20
4. PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT EACH SPOUSE IS DEEMED THE BENEFICIAL OWNER OF
THE SHARES HELD BY THE OTHER SPOUSE. REFER TO SECURITIES ACT RELEASE
NO. 33-4819 ("A PERSON IS REGARDED AS THE BENEFICIAL OWNER OF
SECURITIES HELD IN THE NAME OF HIS OR HER SPOUSE AND THEIR MINOR
CHILDREN"). IN THIS REGARD, PLEASE GROUP TOGETHER THE SHARES OWNED BY
DIANA DERYCZ-KESSLER AND PAUL KESSLER FOR PURPOSES OF CALCULATING
BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP.
<PAGE>
Securities and Exchange Commission
January 12, 2005
4
We have revised the disclosure to group together the shares owned by
Diana Derycz-Kessler and Paul Kessler for purposes of calculating
beneficial ownership.
5. BASED ON THE SELLING STOCKHOLDER TABLE, WE NOTE THE FOLLOWING: KARIM
SOUKI HAS BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP OVER THE SHARES BEING OFFERED BY BSR
INVESTMENT, LTD, LANVER PROPERTIES AND UNION FINANCE INT., WHICH
REPRESENTS TOTAL BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP OF 12.9%; AND DAVID MUN-GAVIN HAS
BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP OVER THE SHARES BEING OFFERED BY THE ELSMERE GROUP
LTD. AND FREEMONT TRADING LTD., WHICH REPRESENTS TOTAL BENEFICIAL
OWNERSHIP OF 12% OF THE SHARES OUTSTANDING. PLEASE INCLUDE MESSRS.
SOUKI AND MUN-GAVIN IN THE TABLE OF BENEFICIAL OWNERSHIP AND INDICATE
BY FOOTNOTE THE VARIOUS SOURCES AND AMOUNTS OF THEIR SHARE OWNERSHIP.
The requested disclosure has been added to the beneficial ownership
table.
DESCRIPTION OF BUSINESS, PAGE 24
6. WE NOTE THAT THE POWER INLAY TECHNOLOGY WILL BE BUILT BY A DOMESTIC
MANUFACTURER. PLEASE INDICATE WHETHER YOU HAVE IDENTIFIED SUCH A
MANUFACTURER AND IF SO THE NAME IS REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH ITEM
101(B)(5) OF REGULATION S-B.
In response to the Staff's comment, the identity of the manufacturer,
HEI, Inc., of our power inlay technology has been added.
7. PLEASE IDENTIFY THE SUPPLIER OF THE BATTERY. WE NOTE YOU ARE WORKING
WITH OTHER BATTERY MANUFACTURERS. PLEASE ELABORATE.
In response to the Staff's comment, disclosure regarding the identity
of the supplier of the battery, Solicore, has been added on page 24.
Additional disclosure has been added to explain more clearly why we are
working with other battery manufacturers.
Although our intention is to purchase the majority of our batteries
from our current supplier, we are working with other battery
manufacturers to find batteries suitable to our cards so that we are
not dependent upon a sole source of batteries for the manufacturing of
our power inlay technology and future products.
8. PLEASE ELABORATE ON THE STATEMENT ON PAGE 27 THAT YOU HAVE "PROVEN THE
PROCESS OF MAKING POWER INLAYS AND INCORPORATING THEM INTO AN ISO
COMPLIANT PAYMENT CARD."
In response to the Staff's comment, this statement has been revised to
explain more clearly that we have successfully assembled power core
sheets, 24 cards per sheet, of the LightCard, which have been finished
by an approved manufacturer of financial credit cards.
<PAGE>
Securities and Exchange Commission
January 12, 2005
5
MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS, PAGE 28
Liquidity and Capital Resources
9. REFERENCE IS MADE TO YOUR VARIOUS "LINES OF CREDIT". FOR EACH LINE,
DISCLOSE THE AMOUNT AVAILABLE AS OF THE MOST RECENT PRACTICABLE DATE.
The requested disclosure regarding each "line of credit" has been
revised to clarify that there are no amounts available for borrowing as
of the most recent practicable date. The disclosure has further been
revised to replace the term "line of credit" with "note payable."
10. WITH RESPECT TO OUR PREVIOUS COMMENT 63, WE NOTE YOUR REVISION TO THE
STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS. ALSO, IN YOUR SUPPLEMENTARY RESPONSE TO PRIOR
COMMENT 63, YOU STATE "THE THREE $150,000 NOTES ARE NOT A "LINE OF
CREDIT", RATHER THEY ARE NOTES PAYABLE." HOWEVER, IN MD&A YOU DISCUSS
THREE $150,000 LINES OF CREDIT. PLEASE REVISE TO CONSISTENTLY REFER TO
EACH AGREEMENT AS A NOTE PAYABLE OR LINE OF CREDIT, AS APPROPRIATE. WE
ALSO NOTE YOUR SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO COMMENT 57, DISCUSSING A
"MAXIMUM BORROWING LIMIT." REVISE THE DISCUSSION OF THE NOTES IN MD&A
AND THE FOOTNOTES AS NECESSARY TO FULLY DESCRIBE THE TERMS AND
CONDITIONS OF THE NOTES.
In response to the Staff's comment, the disclosure has been revised to
consistently refer to each of the three $150,000 agreements as a note
payable. The disclosure also has been revised to fully describe the
terms and conditions of these notes.
CERTAIN RELATIONSHIPS AND RELATED TRANSACTIONS, PAGE 32
11. IN PRIOR COMMENT 50 WE ASKED THAT YOU IDENTIFY YOUR PROMOTERS AND
PROVIDE THE INFORMATION REQUIRED UNDER ITEM 404(D) OF REGULATION S-B.
WE NOTE YOUR RESPONSE AND DIRECT YOUR ATTENTION TO THE DEFINITION OF
"PROMOTER" IN RULE 405 OF REGULATION C.
The requested disclosure regarding Alan Finkelstein, Bradley Ross and
Luc Berthoud as promoters of the Company has been added.
12. THE ADVANCES AND ACCOUNTS PAYABLE TO RELATED PARTIES INDICATED ON THE
BALANCE SHEETS AND IN NOTE 8 TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS SHOULD BE
FULLY DESCRIBED HEREUNDER, INCLUDING NAMES OF THE PARTIES, HIGH AMOUNTS
DURING EACH OF THE TWO YEARS, AMOUNTS OUTSTANDING AT THE LATEST
PRACTICABLE DATE, MATURITY DATES AND INTEREST RATES.
In response to the Staff's comment, the requested disclosure has been
added.
13. TERMS OF THE $130,833 OBLIGATION TO FOREST FINKELSTEIN SHOULD BE
SIMILARLY DISCLOSED.
The requested disclosure regarding the terms of the $130,000 obligation
to Forest Finkelstein has similarly been added.
<PAGE>
Securities and Exchange Commission
January 12, 2005
6
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION, PAGE 36
14. PLEASE BE AWARE THAT COMPENSATION PAID FOR THE CURRENT FISCAL YEAR
ENDING DECEMBER 31ST SHOULD BE INDICATED, IF KNOWN, AND, IN ANY CASE,
MUST BE DISCLOSED IN ANY PROSPECTUS AFTER THAT DATE.
Disclosure regarding compensation paid for the year ended December 31,
2004 has been added. The Staff's comment is noted with respect to
disclosure of such compensation in the prospectus after that date.
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS, PART II
NOTE 5-NOTES PAYABLE
15. WITH RESPECT TO OUR PREVIOUS COMMENT 57, WE NOTE YOUR REVISION AND
SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE. PLEASE CONTINUE YOUR REVISIONS BY CLARIFYING
THAT $350,000 AND $100,000 WAS RECEIVED IN GROSS PROCEEDS FOR THE YEARS
ENDED 2002 AND 2003, RESPECTI