SEC Company Response from AXA ENTERPRISE FUNDS TRUST (CIK 0001312580) — Feb 25, 2005
AXA ENTERPRISE FUNDS TRUST (CIK 0001312580)
Date: Feb. 25, 2005 · CIK: 0001312580 · Accession: 0000898432-05-000201
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-122083
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT>
<TYPE>CORRESP
<SEQUENCE>1
<FILENAME>filename1.txt
<TEXT>
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART NICHOLSON GRAHAM LLP 1800 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W.
Suite 200
Washington, DC 20036-1221
202.778.9000
Fax 202.778.9100
www.klng.com
Mark C. Amorosi
202.778.9187
Fax: 202.778.9100
mamorosi@klng.com
February 23, 2005
VIA EDGAR AND E-MAIL
--------------------
Ms. Laura Hatch
U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
450 Fifth Street, NW
Washington, DC 20549-0506
Re: Responses to Comments on the Registration Statement on Form N-14 of
the AXA Enterprise Funds Trust (File Number 333-122083)
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Ms. Hatch:
On behalf of the above-referenced registrant, set forth below are the
comments that you provided by telephone on February 9, 2005 concerning the
Registration Statement on Form N-14 (the "Registration Statement") of the AXA
Enterprise Funds Trust (the "Trust"), which was filed with the U.S. Securities
and Exchange Commission (the "SEC") on January 14, 2005, and the Trust's
responses thereto. Your comments are set forth in italics and are followed by
the Trust's responses, which are reflected in the changed pages from the draft
definitive Proxy Statement/Prospectus and Statement of Additional Information
that are enclosed with this letter. Unless otherwise noted, defined terms have
the same meaning as in the Registration Statement.
PROXY STATEMENT/PROSPECTUS
--------------------------
1. General
-------
(a) INCORPORATE CHANGES IN RESPONSE TO APPLICABLE COMMENTS SEPARATELY
PROVIDED ON THE REGISTRATION STATEMENTS ON FORM N-1A AND FORM N-14 OF
THE TRUST AND AXA ENTERPRISE MULTIMANAGER FUNDS TRUST.
The Trust has incorporated changes in response to those comments,
where applicable.
<PAGE>
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART NICHOLSON GRAHAM LLP
February 23, 2005
Page 2
(b) EXPLAIN SUPPLEMENTALLY WHETHER THERE WILL BE A SEPARATE PROXY CARD
FOR EACH PROPOSAL.
Each shareholder will receive a single proxy card entitling the
shareholder to vote on the Reorganizations affecting the Acquired
Funds of which that shareholder held shares on the Record Date.
(c) PROVIDE SUPPLEMENTALLY A SUMMARY OF THE ANALYSIS OF THE ACCOUNTING
SURVIVOR DETERMINATION FOR EACH REORGANIZATION.
The general criteria that are applied to determine the proper
accounting survivor are outlined in the "AICPA Accounting and Audit
Guide for Investment Companies" (the "Guide"). The Guide states that
the legal survivor normally is considered the accounting survivor of
a fund combination, but that continuity and dominance in one or more
of the following areas might lead to a determination that the fund
legally dissolved should be considered the accounting survivor: (1)
portfolio management; (2) investment objectives, policies and
restrictions; (3) portfolio composition; (4) expense structure and
expense ratios; and (5) asset size.
The staff of the SEC has taken the position that these same factors
generally should be considered in determining which fund's historical
performance should be presented following a fund combination.(1) In
this connection, the SEC staff has stated that the survivor of a fund
combination for accounting purposes generally will be the fund whose
historical performance may be used by a new or surviving fund. In
making the determination of which fund's performance to use, the SEC
staff has stated that "funds should compare the attributes of the
surviving or new fund and the predecessor funds to determine which
predecessor fund, if any, the surviving or new fund most closely
resembles."(2)
Based on its review, the Trust determined that the Enterprise Growth
Fund will be the accounting survivor in the Reorganizations and that
the performance history of that Fund will be used after the
Reorganizations. In this connection, the Board and management of the
Funds noted that: (1) the combined Fund will be managed in accordance
with investment objectives, policies and restrictions that mirror
those of the Enterprise Growth Fund; (2) the Enterprise Growth Fund
is by far the largest of the Funds involved in the Reorganizations;
(3) the combined Fund will be advised by the subadviser that advises
----------
(1) SEE, E.G., NORTH AMERICAN SECURITY TRUST, SEC No-Action Letter (August 5,
1994).
(2) ID.
<PAGE>
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART NICHOLSON GRAHAM LLP
February 23, 2005
Page 3
the Enterprise Growth Fund and in a manner that is substantially
identical to that used for the Enterprise Growth Fund; (4) the
portfolio composition of the combined Fund will most closely resemble
the portfolio structure of the Enterprise Growth Fund because the
combined Fund will be managed by the Enterprise Growth Fund's
subadviser and in accordance with investment objectives, policies and
restrictions that mirror that Fund; and (5) the expense structure and
expense ratios of the combined Fund will closely resemble those of
the Enterprise Growth Fund.
2. Cover Page
----------
INCLUDE THE DATE OF ANY SUPPLEMENT (IF THERE IS ONLY ONE SUPPLEMENT)
TO THE CORPORATION'S PROSPECTUS AND STATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL
INFORMATION THAT IS BEING INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE INTO THIS
DOCUMENT. NO CHANGE IS REQUIRED IN RESPONSE TO THIS COMMENT IF THERE
ARE MULTIPLE SUPPLEMENTS.
The Trust has not made any change in response to this comment, as
there are multiple supplements to the Corporation's prospectus and
statement of additional information, dated May 3, 2004.
3. Introduction
------------
(a) USE THE TERM "SIMILAR" INSTEAD OF "SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR" TO COMPARE
THE INVESTMENT OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OF THE ENTERPRISE MULTI-CAP
FUND WITH THOSE OF THE AXA GROWTH FUND. USE THE TERM "SOMEWHAT
SIMILAR" INSTEAD OF "SIMILAR" TO COMPARE THE INVESTMENT OBJECTIVES
AND POLICIES OF THE ENTERPRISE STRATEGIC FUND WITH THOSE OF THE AXA
GROWTH FUND.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised pages 5, 8, 29
and 31.
(b) DISCUSS THE CONSEQUENCES OF ANY DIFFERENCES IN THE INVESTMENT
OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OF THE ACQUIRING FUND AND EACH ACQUIRED FUND
AND ANY ADDITIONAL RISKS AS A RESULT OF THOSE DIFFERENCES.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised page 5.
<PAGE>
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART NICHOLSON GRAHAM LLP
February 23, 2005
Page 4
(c) CLARIFY THAT THE INVESTMENT MANAGER, INVESTMENT SUBADVISER AND
INVESTMENT OBJECTIVES AND POLICIES OF THE SURVIVING FUND IN EACH OF
THE REORGANIZATIONS WILL BE THOSE OF THE ACQUIRING FUND AS DISCLOSED
IN THE PROXY STATEMENT/PROSPECTUS AND WILL NOT BE REVISED IN
CONNECTION WITH THE REORGANIZATIONS.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised pages 5-6.
(d) REVISE THE FOURTH PARAGRAPH TO STATE, IF APPLICABLE, THAT BOTH THE
CORPORATION'S BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND AXA EQUITABLE (RATHER THAN ONLY
AXA EQUITABLE) BELIEVE THAT THE FUNDS GENERALLY APPEAL TO THE SAME
TYPES OF INVESTORS AND THAT THE RISK PROFILE FOR EACH FUND IS
SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR.
The Trust has made the requested change. See revised page 5.
(e) REVISE THE FIRST FULL PARAGRAPH ON PAGE 5 DISCLOSING THAT CERTAIN OF
THE ACQUIRED FUND'S HOLDINGS WILL BE SOLD IN CONNECTION WITH THE
REORGANIZATION BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT COMPATIBLE WITH THE ACQUIRING
FUND'S INVESTMENT POLICIES, TO DISCLOSE THAT SUCH SALE WILL RESULT IN
THE FUND REALIZING GAINS THAT WILL HAVE TO BE DISTRIBUTED TO
SHAREHOLDERS. ALSO DISCLOSE THE IMPACT OF CAPITAL LOSS CARRY
FORWARDS.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised pages 7-8.
4. Shareholder Fees Table
----------------------
(a) INCLUDE A PRO FORMA SHAREHOLDER FEES TABLE OR INDICATE IN THE
NARRATIVE ACCOMPANYING THE TABLE THAT THE SHAREHOLDER FEES
INFORMATION IS EXACTLY THE SAME BEFORE AND AFTER EACH REORGANIZATION.
The Trust has made the requested change by revising the Shareholder
Fees table to include PRO FORMA information. See revised page 12.
(b) DISCLOSE THE $35 ANNUAL ACCOUNT FEE IN THE FEE TABLE OR IN A NOTE TO
THE FEE TABLE.
The Trust has made the requested change by adding the account fee to
the fee table and including a note to the table. See revised pages
12-13.
<PAGE>
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART NICHOLSON GRAHAM LLP
February 23, 2005
Page 5
5. Annual Fund Operating Expenses Table
------------------------------------
INDICATE IN FOOTNOTE 1 THAT THE INVESTMENT MANAGERS MAY ONLY RECAPTURE
PAYMENTS AND WAIVERS FOR THE LAST THREE FISCAL YEARS. ALSO DISCLOSE THE
DOLLAR AMOUNT SUBJECT TO RECAPTURE. SUPPLEMENTALLY DESCRIBE THE LEGAL AND
ACCOUNTING BASIS FOR RECAPTURING ANY AMOUNTS WAIVED PRIOR TO THE
REORGANIZATIONS.
The Trust has made the requested change to clarify that the investment
managers may only recapture payments and waivers for the last three fiscal
years. In addition, AXA Equitable has determined not to recapture any
payments or waivers made prior to the Reorganizations. Therefore, the
Trust has deleted from Footnote 1 the disclosure stating that AXA
Equitable would recapture such amounts. See revised pages 13-15.
6. Example of Fund Expenses
------------------------
AS THE CLASS B SHARES CONVERT TO CLASS A SHARES PRIOR TO 10 YEARS, THE
NUMBERS SHOWN FOR 10 YEARS SHOULD BE LOWER BECAUSE OF THE CONVERSION
FEATURE. REVISE THE TABLES TO REFLECT THE LOWER EXPENSES FOR YEARS 9 AND
10.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised pages 16-17.
7. Comparison of Principal Risk Factors
------------------------------------
SUMMARIZE THE CONSEQUENCES OF THE DIFFERENCES IN THE PRINCIPAL RISKS.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised page 5.
8. Capitalization Tables
---------------------
REVISE THE CAPITALIZATION TABLES TO INCLUDE AN ADJUSTMENTS COLUMN AND TO
REFLECT THE ADJUSTMENTS FOR THE REORGANIZATION EXPENSES (INCLUDING THE
PROXY SOLICITING COSTS DESCRIBED ON PAGE 2) THAT WILL BE BORNE BY THE
FUNDS. ALSO INCLUDE THESE ADJUSTMENTS IN THE ACQUIRING FUND'S PRO FORMA
STATEMENT OF ASSETS AND LIABILITIES.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised pages 24-26.
<PAGE>
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART NICHOLSON GRAHAM LLP
February 23, 2005
Page 6
9. Reasons for the Reorganizations
-------------------------------
(a) IN THE SIXTH BULLET ON PAGE 21, PLEASE STATE THAT THE ACQUIRING FUND
EXPENSES ARE "SLIGHTLY HIGHER" THAN STRATEGIC FUND'S, RATHER THAN
"COMPARABLE."
The Trust has made the requested change by inserting the phrase
"somewhat higher" in place of the word "comparable." See revised page
32.
(b) DESCRIBE WHETHER THE BOARD CONSIDERED THE SALE OF ASSETS IN
CONNECTION WITH ITS APPROVAL OF THE REORGANIZATIONS, AND ADD A
SENTENCE REGARDING THE SAME TO THE BULLET LIST AT THE END OF THIS
SECTION.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised page 32.
10. Federal Income Tax Consequences of the Reorganizations
------------------------------------------------------
REVISE TO CLEARLY DISCLOSE THE LIMITATIONS ON THE CAPITAL LOSS CARRY
FORWARDS.
The Trust has made the requested change. See revised page 33.
11. How Fund Shares are Priced
--------------------------
INCLUDE FUND SPECIFIC EXAMPLES FOR THE FAIR VALUATION OF SECURITIES. TO
THE EXTENT THAT A FUND INVESTS IN SECURITIES THAT ARE LIKELY TO BE FAIR
VALUED, INCLUDE A STATEMENT TO THAT EFFECT.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised pages 58-59.
12. Appendix B
----------
ON PAGE B-1, CONSIDER INCLUDING THE DISCUSSION FROM THE THIRD PARAGRAPH
RELATING TO THE CONTINGENCIES OF EACH REORGANIZATION'S APPROVAL IN THE
PROXY STATEMENT/PROSPECTUS.
The Trust has made the requested change. See revised page 28.
STATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
-----------------------------------
13. Portfolio Holdings
------------------
REVISE THIS SECTION TO INCLUDE ALL OF THE INFORMATION REQUIRED BY ITEM
11(F) OF FORM N-1A, AS THAT ITEM APPLIES TO THE REGISTRATION STATEMENT.
FOR EXAMPLE, INCLUDE DISCLOSURE OF ANY LAG TIMES FOR PORTFOLIO HOLDINGS
DISCLOSURE, SPECIFIC THIRD PARTIES THAT RECEIVE INFORMATION AND WHEN THEY
<PAGE>
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART NICHOLSON GRAHAM LLP
February 23, 2005
Page 7
RECEIVE IT, ANY CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENTS, THE MANNER IN WHICH THE BOARD
EXERCISES ITS OVERSIGHT OF PORTFOLIO HOLDINGS DISCLOSURE, AND ANY
COMPENSATION RECEIVED FOR DISCLOSING PORTFOLIO HOLDINGS INFORMATION.
The Trust has made the requested changes. See revised SAI page 22.
14. The Sub-Advisers
----------------
DISCLOSE THE FEES THAT ARE PAID TO THE SUB-ADVISERS.
The Trust has considered this comment and respectfully declines to make
any changes. Item 14(a)(3) of Form N-1A, as relevant here, generally
requires disclosure of the advisory fees "payable by the Fund." In this
connection, we note that the subadvisory fees are not payable by the Fund
but rather are obligations of AXA Equitable pursuant to the investment
advisory agreement it enters into with each subadviser and are paid out of
the management fees that AXA Equitable earns from the Funds. We also note
that the approach reflected in the Registration Statement is consistent
with that taken by other "manager of managers" funds. As the SEC has
recognized, a manager of managers may be able to negotiate lower fees with
subadvisers if it does not have to disclose the contractual rate of those
fees separately.(3)
In recognition that the payment of subadvisory fees by a manager of
managers could be deemed to be an indirect payment of advisory fees by the
Funds, however, AXA Equitable intends to disclose the following
inform