SEC Comment Letter for SANDRIDGE ENERGY INC (SD) (CIK 0001349436) (SD) — Jul 30, 2013
SANDRIDGE ENERGY INC (SD) (CIK 0001349436)
Date: July 30, 2013 · CIK: 0001349436 · Accession: 0000000000-13-041610
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 001-33784
Show Raw Text
July 30 , 2013 Via E -mail Eddie M. LeBlanc III Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer SandR idge Energy, Inc. 123 Robert S. Kerr Avenue Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73102 Re: SandR idge Energy, Inc. Form 10 -K for the Fis cal Year E nded December 31, 2012 Filed March 1 , 2013 Form 10 -Q for the Fiscal Quarter ended March 31, 2013 Filed May 8, 2013 Definitive Proxy Statement on Schedule 14A Filed May 29, 2013 File No. 001-33784 Dear Mr. LeBlanc: We have reviewed your filing s and have the following comment s. In some of our comments, we may ask you to provide us with information so we may better understand your disclosure. Please respond to this letter within ten business days by amending your filing s, by providing the requested information, or by advising us when you will provide the requested response. If you do not believe our comment s apply to your facts and cir cumstances or do not believe amendment s are appropriate, please tell us why in your response. After reviewing any amendment s to your filing s and the information you provide in response to these comment s, we may have additional comments. Form 10 -K for the Fiscal Year ended December 31, 2012 Business, page 1 Business Segments and Primary Operations, page 4 West Texas Overthrust, page 6 1. Please revise your disclosure to discuss and quantify (i) the annual amount of natural gas that you would be required to deliver to meet the carbon dioxide delivery requiremen t, (ii) the annual carbon dioxide delivery requirement, and (iii) the liquidated damages per Eddie M. LeBlanc III SandR idge Energy, Inc. July 30 , 2013 Page 2 1,000 standard cubic feet of carbon dioxide not delivered . Alternatively, provide the information necessary to understand the potential impact to earnings and liq uidity if it is reasonably possible that you will be unable to meet your long -term contractual obligations under the treating agreement. Please also disclose the relationship between the natural gas input and carbon dioxide output, and the methodology tha t liquidation damages are calculated to comply with Item 1207 of Regulation S -K. Reserve Quantities, PV -10 and Standardized Measure, page 10 2. You state “the Company estimates that approximately 80% of its current proved undeveloped reserves will be deve loped by the end of 2014 and all of its current proved undeveloped reserves will be developed by the end of 2016.” For purposes of determining the five year period, Item 1203(d) of Regulation S -K identifies the initial disclosure and date thereof as the s tarting reference date. Please tell us if any of your proved undeveloped volumes disclosed as of December 31, 2012 will take more than five years since initial disclosure to develop. 3. The footnote to the reserves disclosure on pages 10 and F -65 states tha t prior to 2012, NGLs did not comprise a significant portion of total proved reserves and were included with oil reserves. Please tell us the net quantities of NGLs for 2011 and 2010 and explain how you have determined disclosure of these quantities was n ot warranted per the requirements set forth in FASB ASC 932-235-50-4. Proved Undeveloped Reserves, page 12 4. Item 1203(b) of Regulation S -K requests that registrants “[d]isclose material changes in proved undeveloped reserves that occurred during the year, including proved undeveloped reserves converted into proved developed reserves.” It appears you have disclosed only the PUD volumes that you converted to proved developed stat us. Please expand your disclosure to provide a reconciliation of the material changes in the net quantities of your proved undeveloped reserves due to revisions, extensions/discoveries, acquisition/divestiture and improved recovery. Production and Price History, page 14 5. Your disclosure of the production and average sales price on page 14 and elsewhere in this Form 10 -K excludes separate disclosure of information relating to natural gas liquids. As Items 1204(a) and 1204(b)(1) of Regulation S -K require s eparate disclosure by final product sold or produced, please advise or revise your disclosure to provide separate disclosure relating to natural gas liquids. Eddie M. LeBlanc III SandR idge Energy, Inc. July 30 , 2013 Page 3 Developed and Undeveloped Acreage, page 15 6. We note from the disclosure on page 15 that a significant percentage of the Company’s net undeveloped acreage will expire in 2013 and 2014. Please tell us the net amounts by product of your December 31, 2012 proved undeveloped oil and gas reserves assigne d to locations on acreage scheduled to expire in 2013 and in 2014. Also tell us if all such proved undeveloped locations are included in a development plan adopted by management as of December 31, 2012 indicating that these locations are scheduled to be drilled prior to lease expiration. Risk Factors “Unless the Company replaces its oil and natural gas reserves…,” page 35 7. Please expand this risk factor to discuss the impact of the February 2013 sale of the Permian Basin properties. “The Company’s devel opment and exploration operations require substantial capital …,” page 37 8. Please provide context for this risk factor by quantifying the amount of your capital expenditures in the recent past financed from asset sales and sales of equity and debt, as compa red to those capital expenditures financed from cash generated from operations. Similarly, quantify the amount of capital expenditure that the Company “expects” to finance from asset sales and other financing arrangements and sales of equity and debt, as compared to those capital expenditures expected to be finance d from cash generated from operations . Management's Discussion and Analysis, page 61 Results by Segment , page 62 9. We see that you have disclosed on page 64 average prices related to your oil and natural gas production reflecting the impact of derivative contract settlements. Tell us the extent to which the derivatives utilized in computing these measures included ins truments that entailed some cost (e.g. premiums) to acquire, or instruments that reflected terms or provisions that were effected by amendment for cost prior to or in conjunction with settlement; please quantify the effects of any such cost recovery on the average prices that you have disclosed. Liquidity and Capital Resources, page 73 10. We note that you depend on funding commitments from third parties for drilling carries to fund your capital expenditures. Please quantify the amount you receive from these Eddie M. LeBlanc III SandR idge Energy, Inc. July 30 , 2013 Page 4 third parties. Additionally, please discuss whether you expect these amounts to re main stable in the near future or, if not, why and to what extent these amounts could fluctuate . Contractual Obligations and Off -Balance Sheet Arrangements, page 78 11. Notwithstanding your textual disclosure at the bottom of page 78, tell us why you have not included your development agreements with the Mississippian Trust I, Permian Trust and Mississippian Trust II, and your treating agreement, in your tabular presentation of contractual obligations pursuant to Item 303(a)(5) of Regulation S -K. Please also expand your disclosure to clarify the extent to which your table of contractual obligations includes amounts under these agreements. 12. Please quantify the payments that would be required under your CO 2 supply arrangement if you are unable to deliver natura l gas for processing and describe the factors that are reasonably likely to impact this obligation. Financial Statements Note 1 - Summary of Significant Accounting Policies, page F -9 Revenue Recognition and Natural Gas Balancing, page F -13 13. We note that you account for your two construction contracts under the completed - contract method of accounting, although you record contract gains or losses as development costs within oil and natural gas properties , as part of the full cost pool. We understand from your disclosures on pages F -34 and F -42 that these contracts pertain to the Century Plant and associated compression and pipeline facilities that you constructed for Occidental Petroleum Corporation during 2012 in exchange for $796.3 million and an agreeme nt to either provide specific quantities of CO 2 over a thirty -year period by supplying natural gas for processing, or to provide financial compensation in the event you unable to deliver natural gas for processing. Please address the followin g points: Please explain how you determined it was appropriate to record contract losses amounting to $180 million as additions to the full cost pool rather than to expense these amounts as would ordinarily be required to comply with FASB ASC 605 - 35-25-45. Please clarify the nature and extent of any ownership interest in the facilities you have retained. I t should be clear how you determined that contract losses had the characteristics of assets, were properly accounted for under the full cost method apar t from the revenues and other expenses incurred in completing the contract, and why you believe incurring costs to perform under the contract are properly considered to have been undertaken for your own account, as would generally be anticipated under Rule 4-10(c)(2) of Regulation S -X. Eddie M. LeBlanc III SandR idge Energy, Inc. July 30 , 2013 Page 5 Submit the analysis that you performed in determining that you were unable to make reasonably dependable estimates in selecting the completed contract method of accounting for these construction contracts, rather than the percentage of completion method, b ased on the criteria in FASB ASC 605 -35-25-56 through 66. Given that you received payment for construction according to the percentage of completion , also explain your perspective on the financial reporting implications of applying your method in comparis on to the percentage of completion method . Since your agreement to provide 3,200 Bcf of CO 2 to Occidental Petroleum Corporation was entered into in conjunction with these two construction contracts, it is unclear why you have neither disclosed nor rec ognized a liability for the value of the CO 2 that you must provide as part of your contract accounting. Tell us how the value of the CO 2 compares to the payments required if you do not deliver natural gas for processing, and explain your reasons for defer ring recognition. 14. We note your disclosure on page F -13 indicating that you recognize revenues and expenses under day work and footage drilling contracts as services are performed and that fees received for mobilization and the costs of mobilization are recognized "...over the term of the related drilling contract." Although it appears your approach generally corresponds to the percentage of completion method, we would like to understand how your accounting differs when the terms of your drilling contrac ts do not correspond precisely with the time spent drilling. Please identify any instances in which the contract dates utilized in defining the terms relied upon as a basis for recognizing mobilization fees preceded or extended beyond the dates that dri lling services were actually provided for each year covered by your report, describe the extent to which those periods did not coincide, and quantify where applicable the difference that would arise if recognition were more precisely aligned with contract performance. Tell us the manner by which you have reviewed and confirmed through observation or inspection the acceptability of the input or output measures utilized to determine the percentage of completion in accordance with FASB ASC 605 - 35-25-78. 15. We n ote your disclosure on page 67, under Drilling and Oil Field Services Segment, stating that you record revenues related to services performed for third -parties, including third -party working interests in wells that you operate. Tell us how you determined that your accounting does not conflict with the guidance in Rule 4 -10(c)(6)(iv)(C) of Regulation S -X, stating that “no income may be recognized for contractual services performed on behalf of investors in oil and gas producing activities managed by the registrant or an affiliate.” Eddie M. LeBlanc III SandR idge Energy, Inc. July 30 , 2013 Page 6 Note 7 - Property, Plant and Equipment, page F -32 16. We note from the Form 8 -K that you filed on May 8, 2013, Note 2(c), that you estimate you would have “incurred an impairment from full cost ceiling limitations of approxima tely $102.6 million” during the first quarter of 2013, although you provided no adjustment because this is not recurring. Please clarify the basis for this disclosure and explain why a full cost ceiling write -down was not recorded in historical financial statements for this period . Note 14 - Derivatives, page F -37 17. We note that you have disaggregated your measures of gain and loss on derivatives into measures described as "realized" and "unrealized" in the table on page F -39, although your accompan ying narrative indicates you are presenting "cash settlements and valuation gain and loss." Tell us how you determined the realized and unrealized gains and losses so that we may understand how your method complies with FASB ASC 815 - 10-35-2. For example, if realized gains do not reflect only the change in fair value during the period of settlement, identify the specific elements reflected in each measure (e.g. premiums paid, change in fair value from period -to-period, and settlement proceeds/payments). Given that you have a similar presentation on page 66, with realized gain or loss attributed to early settlements, amended contracts, and settlements at maturity, please also explain your rationale for differentiating these categories in your presentation and describe any corresponding accounting distinctions. Please also explain the inconsistent labeling of these amounts in your disclosures and how the measures would be properly regarded as valuation gain and loss. 18. Tell us why you have identified rea lized loss on amended derivative contracts in the amount of $117 million as a positive adjustment in your 2012 reconciliation of net income to operating cash flows on page F -8. Note 25 Supplemental Information on Oil and Natural Gas Producing Activities, page F -62 Oil and Natural Gas Reserve Quantities (Unaudited), page F -63 19. Please refer to the requirements set forth in FASB ASC 932-235-50-5. Revise the disclosure on page F -64 relating to the 2010, 2011 and 2012 revisions of previous estimat es to provide the net quantities associated with a change in economic factors separately from the changes resulting from new information obtained from development drilling and well performance. Eddie M. LeBlanc III SandR idge Energy, Inc. July 30 , 2013 Page 7 Form 10 -Q for the Fiscal Quarter ended March 31, 2013 Note 2 - Acquisitions and Divestitures, page 10 2013 Divestitures, page 13 20. We note from the Form 8 -K that you filed on March 1, 2013 that you sold assets in the Permian Basin which were held by SandRidge Exploration and Production LLC, an entity that you have identified in disclosure and Exhibit 21 to your annual report as a wholly -owned subsidiary. Please explain how you computed the loss allocated to the noncontrolling interest mentioned under this hea ding, and explain how you have properly identified SandRidge Exploration and Production LLC as a wholly -owned subsidiary with a minority interest. 21. We note that you allocated net book value to the Permian Properties based on the relative fair value of pr oved reserves associated with these properties and the oil and natural gas properties that you retained . Please explain to us why you did not allocate capitalized costs under the same methodology as used to compute amortization, pursuant to the guidance i n Rule 4 -10(c)(6)(i) of Regulation S -X