SEC Comment Letter for X Financial (XYF) (CIK 0001725033) (XYF) — Feb 6, 2018
X Financial (XYF) (CIK 0001725033)
Date: Feb. 6, 2018 · CIK: 0001725033 · Accession: 0000000000-18-004136
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
Show Raw Text
Mail Stop 4720 February 5, 2018 Yue (Justin) Zhang, Chief Executive Officer and Chairman X Financial 7-8F, Block A, Aerospace Science and Technology Plaza No. 168, Haide Third Avenue, Nanshan District Shenzhen, 518067, the People's Republic of China Re: X Financial Draft Registration Statement on Form F -1 Submitted January 8, 2018 CIK No. 0001725033 Dear Mr. Zhang : We have reviewed your draft registration statement and have the following comments. In some of our comments, we may ask you to provide us with information so we may better understand your disclosure. Please respond to this letter by providing the requested information and either submitting an amended draft registration statement or publicly filing your registration statement on EDGAR. If you do not believe our comments apply to your facts and circumstances or do not believe an amendment is appropriate, please tell us why in your response. After reviewing the information you provide in response to these comments and your amende d draft registration statement or filed registration statement, we may have additional comments. General 1. Please supplementally provide us with copies of all written communications, as defined in Rule 405 under the Securities Act, that you , or anyone authorized to do so on your behalf , present to potential investors in reliance on Section 5(d) of the Securities Act, whether or not they retain copies of the communications . 2. Based on your current disclosure, it appears that recent PRC regula tions, such as Circular 141, Notice on Rectification of Cash Loan Business , issued on December 1, 2017 and Circular 57, Notice on the Special Rectification and Inspection of Risk of Online Lending Intermediaries , may have a material effect on your business model . Please expand your Summary, Risk Factor and Business disclosure to fully treat the implications of this circular and any other recent PRC regulations directed to P2P lenders, as applicable, on Yue (Justin) Zhang X Financial February 5, 2018 Page 2 your product offerings, funding sources, business prac tices, strategic partnerships and other relevant loan, investment, intermediation, servicing and collection attributes . Please identify the specific activities, and their respective amounts, affected and describe specific steps you have taken or plan to t ake in response to the regulations . Prospectus Summary Overview, page 1 3. Please enhance the key operating data of your business to include the following metrics for the periods presented: Number of repeat borrowers; Number of active repeat investor s, Number and value of loans by product as described on page 126, including average loan amount; and New borrower acquisition costs. 4. We note that the Oliver Wyman Report determined that you were a “leading technology - driven personal finance company in C hina focused on serving China’s underserved prime borrowers and mass affluent investors.” Please describe the “mass affluent investors” category and disclose the number of other marketplaces against which you were measured . We also note your statement th at your platform is “one of the very few platforms able to enhance investors' confidence in the investment products with insurance protection.” Please also disclose the number of other marketplaces against which you compared yourself for determining that there were “very few” marketplaces that offer insurance . In this regard, please tell us how you are defining “insurance protection.” 5. Please revise to describe the types and ranges of fees that you charge, describing the services provided and the proportion of your revenues attributable to each over recent periods . In addition, please disclose the APR range on a product by product basis for your major loan products . Our Industry, page 3 6. You state that the Chinese credit card balance transfer l oan market emerged due to very different reasons than in the United States and the market in China emerged as to credit card holders not having sufficient credit lines from issuing banks, and need to repay in advance to free up their credit lines . Clarify if the credit lines from issuing banks are paid off as a requirement for obtaining a loan through your platform or if the credit card transfer loan is an additional credit facility for the borrower . Yue (Justin) Zhang X Financial February 5, 2018 Page 3 Risk Factors Risks Relating to Our Business and Indu stry If we are unable to maintain or increase the amount of loans we facilitate or if we are unable to retain existing bor rowers or attract new borrowers . . . , page 21 7. Please expand this risk factor to explicitly address and identify, as applicable, whether any of your products will be prohibited under recent PRC guidelines. Our platform requires adequate funding from investors and access to adequate lending capital on terms acceptable to us cannot be assured, page 21 8. Please revise your disclosure to clarif y which third party entities currently providing credit enhancement services in relation to your products that lack the qualifications to provide those services . Please also identify the total amount, and percentage, of loans you facilitate that are subje ct to credit enhancement services by these entities. Delinquency Rate by Balance, page 85 9. We note that your delinquency rate is calculated excluding interest and only includes outstanding principal . We also note your guarantee agreement with ZhongAn includes both principal and interest . Please revise to present your delinquency rate including accrued and outstanding interest . 10. Please enhance your disclosure to discuss trends in delinquency rates in th e periods presented . On this topic, we noted that delinquency rates on loans 31 -90 days past due as a percentage of total loans increased from 0.30% to 0.51% from December 31, 2016 to June 30, 2017 and delinquency rates on loans 91 -180 days past due as a percentage of total loans increased from 0.21% to 0.41% from December 31, 2016 to June 30, 2017 . Please discuss in sufficient detail the drivers of these trends in the periods presented. Delinquency Rate by Vintage of Xiaoying Card Loans, page 86 11. Enhance your disclosure to explain the reason for the steady increase in delinquency rate from 0% in March 2017 to 6+% in November 2017 . Results of Operations, page 87 12. Please enhance your discussion to address the underlying reason for material change s in results, period -over-period . For example, explain the reason for the increase in Post - origination service fee from US$1.2 million in 2016 to US$3.2 million for the six months Yue (Justin) Zhang X Financial February 5, 2018 Page 4 ended June 30, 2017 . Consider providing enhanced disaggregating operating metrics such as loan volume to support your discussion . Operating Expenses, page 90 13. Please break out origination and servicing expenses by type (i.e ., credit assessment, customer acquisition, etc.) and discuss any material changes period over period. 14. Please break out general and administrative expenses by type (i.e ., salaries and benefits, research and development, etc.) and discuss any material changes period over period. Non-GAAP Measures, page 91 15. We note your presentation of Adjusted net (loss)/in come adding back share -based compensation expenses . Please confirm that the share -based compensation expenses added back to get to the Non -GAAP financial measure Adjusted net (loss)/income are net of taxes and update your disclosure accordingly. Liquidit y and Capital Resources, page 95 16. Please enhance your discussions to address the trends in your cash flows, including the impact of anticipated future growth and how you expect to fund future operations . Additionally, enhance your financing activities discussion to separately describe internal and external sources of liquidity, including any material unused sources of liquid assets . Refer to Regulation S -K, Item 30 3(a)(1). 17. We note your disclosure on page 95 that your, “primary sources of liquidity hav e been cash provided by . . . funds provided by our shareholders.” We note disclosures throughout the document, including in Related Party Transactions on page 170, of a single shareholder (Mr . Tang) providing financing cash flows . Please clarify in your next amendment if you receive related party loans from any other shareholders. 18. We note your disclosure on page 95 that your primary source of liquidity during the six months ended June 30, 2017 was from funds provided by your shareholders as a result of the negative operating cash flow generated . Please discuss further in your Liquidity section the ability and willingness of the shareholder(s) to continue to finance X Financial’s negative cash flows from operations . Please also consider adding a risk factor, or revise your risk factor on page 30, to discuss your reliance on a single shareholder or shareholders to finance current operations . Please factor into your disclosure in the Liquidity section and risk factors the potential impact of the legal proceedings related to Mr . Tang. 19. We note your disclosure on pages 95 and 96 concerning the loan to Zi Jin Zhong Hao (Tianjin) Investment Co., Ltd (ZJZH), an entity controlled by a shareholder (Mr . Tang), Yue (Justin) Zhang X Financial February 5, 2018 Page 5 of RMB 217.0 million . Please expand your disclosures in the Investing Activities section of your Liquidity discussion to address the following related to this loan: The business purpose of the loan; Why the loan was interest -free; Any credit analysis performed before extending a loan of this size given y our negative operating cash flow generated; Any commitments or plans to extend loans to ZJZH or any other entities controlled by Mr . Tang or other shareholder in the future; and Any loan concentrations as a result of the loan. Cash Flows and Working Ca pital, page 96 20. Please revise your disclosure of cash provided by operating activities of RMB 421,760 and US$ 62,213 . It appears you had cash used in operating activities of (RMB 421,760) and (US$ 62,213) as presented in your unaudited interim consolidate d statement of cash flows on page F -47. Intermediary Model, page 101 21. You state that you ceased the online intermediary model in April 2017 . Enhance your discussion to explain the reasons for the cessation and if you ceased all operations related to the intermediary model or just certain operations related to the intermediary model . We noted that you earned 76% of total net revenues in 2016 from loan facilitation service related to the intermediary model . Critical Accounting Policies, Judgments and Es timates Revenue Recognition Incentives to Investors, page 102 22. Please expand your disclosure in your next amendment to define “red packets.” 23. We note that you provide incentives to investors in a variety of forms that either reduces the amount of investm ent required to purchase financial products or entitles them to receive higher interest rates in products they purchase and that such incentives are accounted for as a reduction of revenue . Please disclose incentives provided to investors for the periods presented . Yue (Justin) Zhang X Financial February 5, 2018 Page 6 Industry Overview Online Consumer Finance and Investment Platforms are Filling the Gap, page 110 24. For greater balance and context, please revise to discuss recent developments in the peer - to-peer lending industry in China, such as recent len ding platform failures, over - leveraging, issues related to the industries’ fast growth in relation to regulation and any resulting impact on China’s online or mobile consumer finance marketplace industry in general, including the regulatory and political c limate and response . High -Credit -Limit Unsecured Loan Market, page 113 25. You state that the borrowers of property -owner loans will use their property ownership certificates as the proof of credit verification to obtain loans without providing properties as collateral . Clarify if property -owner loans are the same as Xiaoying Housing Loans and why for property -owner loans, properties are not provided as collateral whereas Xiaoying Housing Loans are secured by properties . Business Overview, page 117 26. To the extent that you experience seasonality in your business, please discuss accordingly . Refer to Item 4.B.3 of Form 20 -F. Our Borrowers and Loan Products, page 124 27. We note that you define your customers as “prime borrowers . . . .” Please clarify if the definition that you use for “prime borrowers” is unique to your business or an industry standard definition . In addition, please disclose the percentage of your active borrowers that are categorized as “prime.” To the extent there are other classifi cations of borrowers that comprise your active borrowers, please disclose as such. 28. Disclose how you calculated 1,200,914 cumulative borrowers . 29. You state that you price loans based on total borrowing costs, which comprises (i) nominal interest rates tha t borrowers pay investors, (ii) the service fee that you charge, payable by borrowers, for your services, including your guarantee service, if applicable; and (3) the insurance premium paid to ZhongAn . Tell us and clarify if there are circumstances in whi ch you would not provide guarantee services . 30. Enhance your discussions to clarify the terms of your loan products, including when principal payments are due, how interest is accrued and whether a borrower may have more than one loan outstanding at any on e time. Yue (Justin) Zhang X Financial February 5, 2018 Page 7 31. Please also disclose the range of annual interest rates for each of your loan products facilitated on your platform. Transaction Process, page 127 32. Enhance your discussion; Stage 3: Credit Assessment, to clarify how you consider updated borrower credit information, including if and how often you update a borrower’s credit grade . Borrower Acquisition and Retention, page 130 33. Tell us and disclose whether you pay any fees or offer any incentive rewards to borrowers directly . If material, please tell us how you account for incentive rewards to borrowers. Loan Facilitation Services to Other Platforms, page 131 34. We note that you “may also require” the selected financial technology company with which you cooperate to pay you a deposit. Please expan d your disclosure to clarify when a deposit is required and how the amount of the deposit is calculated . Investment Products and Services Loan Products, page 132 35. Please discuss the features driving variation within the range of expected annualized rate of returns. Other Products, page 133 36. In your discussion of Other Products, you identify money market and insurance products . On page F -61, you disclose that during the six months ended June 30, 2017, you recognized an expense of RMB 73,492,088 or US$ 10,840,660 for contingent liability concerning certain loans offered as part of “Other Products” in which the estimated default amount was in excess of the stand -ready liability provided . Tell us and clarify the types of products included in Other Product s, excluding money market and insurance products, that gave rise to the contingent liability, and if guarantees are provided, your accounting policy . 37. We note your disclosure that investors are able to “invest in a wide range of products, such as loans . . . facilitated on [your] platform, money market products and insurance products.” Please expand your disclosure to describe your money market products in more detail . For example, please identify the types of instruments offered . In addition, Yue (Justin) Zhang X Financial February 5, 2018 Page 8 in the Regulation section of your prospectus, please explicitly address the rules