Correspondence 0001193125-24-211116 from Ecofin Tax-Exempt Private Credit Fund, Inc. (CIK 0001725295)
Ecofin Tax-Exempt Private Credit Fund, Inc. (CIK 0001725295)
Date: Aug. 30, 2024 · CIK: 0001725295 · Accession: 0001193125-24-211116
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 811-23318
Show Raw Text
CORRESP 1 filename1.htm Ecofin Tax-Exempt Private Credit Fund, Inc. Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP 900 G STREET NW WASHINGTON, DC 20001 TELEPHONE: +1-202-636-5500 FACSIMILE: +1-202-636-5502 Direct Dial Number 212-455-2516 E-mail Address bwells@stblaw.com August 30, 2024 Via EDGAR Securities and Exchange Commission Division of Investment Management 100 F Street, N.E. Washington, D.C. 20549 Attn: Eileen Smiley, Senior Counsel Re: Ecofin Tax-Exempt Private Credit Fund, Inc. Preliminary Proxy Statement on Form PRE14A, File No. 811-23318 Dear Ms. Smiley: On behalf of Ecofin Tax-Exempt Private Credit Fund, Inc. (the “Fund”), we are providing the following responses to comments received by telephone from the staff (the “Staff”) of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “Commission”) via telephone on August 12, 2024, relating to the preliminary proxy statement filed with the Commission on Form PRE14A on August 6, 2024. All capitalized terms used but not defined in this letter have the meanings given to them in the preliminary proxy statement. 1. Please confirm the Fund will stay current on all filing obligations. The Fund confirms that it will stay current on all filing obligations. 2. Please be sure to mark the series as “inactive” and “deregistered” in EDGAR once the liquidation is finalized. The Fund confirms that it will mark the series as “inactive” and “deregistered” in EDGAR once the liquidation is finalized. 3. Please confirm that the Fund will use reasonable efforts to locate all shareholders. The Fund confirms that it will use reasonable efforts to locate all shareholders. 4. Please confirm the Fund will decide on the collectability of all receivables and will include in liquidation costs anything it believes will not be collectible. Securities and Exchange Commission August 30, 2024 The Fund confirms that it will decide on the collectability of all receivables and will include in liquidation costs an estimate of anything it believes will not be collectible. The Fund does not believe there will be any uncollectable amounts if the liquidation is approved. As such, no uncollectable amounts are expected to be included in liquidations costs. 5. Please include an estimate of the liquidation costs. The Fund has revised the disclosure in the section, “Dissolution of the Fund,” to state the following: “Q: How will the Fund Dissolution work? A: . . . The Fund will bear the costs in connection with the liquidation, including with respect to sales of assets and repayment of debt. The approximate costs associated with the liquidation are $128,363 for the printing and mailing of this Proxy Statement and legal fees. As a result of these costs, as well as potential market movements, Shareholders may receive less than the Fund’s net asset value per Share as of the date of this Proxy Statement and as of the date of any approval of the Fund Dissolution.” 6. Please disclose whether Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) Topic 450 or Financial Accounting Board No. 5 will be used in accounting for the liquidation. The Fund respectfully confirms that it will not be using either standard in accounting for the liquidation. 7. The prospectus supplement filed by the Fund on June 21, 2024 states that the Adviser anticipates a mid-2027 distribution date. Please rephrase this language to reconcile the timing of the liquidation distribution with the timing of the liquidation in other parts of the prospectus supplement as well as in the proxy statement. The Fund respectfully clarifies that in both the prospectus supplement and the proxy statement, the 2027 distribution date given is the date of the final distribution, whereupon the liquidation will be completed. This target date is not inconsistent with the other dates given as a part of the liquidation process. 8. Please disclose in the proxy statement in an appropriate place the anticipated impact of the termination of the fee waiver agreement on the Fund’s operating expense ratio during this time. The Fund has revised the disclosure in the section, “Other Information about the Proposals,” to add the following language: “The Termination of the Expense Limitation and Reimbursement Agreement As disclosed in the prospectus supplement filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission on June 21, 2024, the Board has approved, if shareholders approve the 2 Securities and Exchange Commission August 30, 2024 Dissolution, the termination of the Expense Limitation and Reimbursement Agreement between the Adviser and the Fund. As a result, the Adviser would no longer be obligated to waive its fees and/or reimburse expenses of the Fund so that the Fund’s Specified Expenses (as defined in the Fund’s prospectus) will not exceed 0.25% of net assets (annualized) and would no longer be entitled to reimbursement of any previous expenses borne by the Adviser on behalf of the Fund. As a result of the termination of this Agreement, it is expected that the Fund’s expenses as a percentage of net assets will increase. The termination of the Agreement is also expected to raise the Fund’s operating expense ratio during the liquidation process.” 9. Given that the Fund will be terminating repurchase offers with distribution dates, please explain to the Staff if the Adviser will earn fees on cash generated by sales until the proceeds are distributed to shareholders. The Adviser will not earn significant management fees on cash generated by sales, as such funds will be distributed to shareholders within 30 days of monetization, less any capital required to maintain the operations of the Fund until the liquidation has concluded. 10. We note that in the prospectus supplement filed on June 21, 2024 that Courtney Gengler stepped down as Principal Financial Offer. Please explain to the Staff whether the Fund has entered into agreements to retain advisory personnel until the Fund has liquidated. If the Fund has not done so, please disclose the risk of advisory personnel leaving and any potential impact of such departures to the Fund. The Fund has not entered into agreements with advisory personnel as the Fund does not have employees. However, Adviser personnel and other members of the Fund’s investment team are expected to remain with the Fund through the end of the liquidation process. Additionally, the Adviser also manages other funds and is planning to continue the management of those products beyond the liquidation period, and for the foreseeable future. 11. Please consider including the plan of liquidation as an exhibit to the proxy statement. The Fund has considered and does not believe that there is any additional material information in the plan of liquidation. The plan of liquidation is also subject to change (but would not be changed in a way that is inconsistent with the description of the liquidation in the proxy statement). Thus, the Fund respectfully declines to include the plan of liquidation as an exhibit to the proxy statement. 12. Please disclose the impact of the termination of the quarterly repurchase policy that the shareholders will not have guaranteed liquidity events, except for periodic installments. The Fund has revised the disclosure to include the impact of the termination of the quarterly repurchase policy on shareholders’ guaranteed liquidity events. Please see the new language that was added to the disclosure in the response to Comment 19 below. 3 Securities and Exchange Commission August 30, 2024 13. If the Adviser will earn advisory fees on cash generated by sales until distributed to shareholders, please disclose that fact. The Fund has also revised the disclosure in the section, “Dissolution of the Fund,” to state the following: “Q: How will the Fund Dissolution work? A: If Shareholders approve the Fund Dissolution Proposal, the Fund expects to implement a plan of liquidation and termination (the “Plan of Liquidation and Termination”) pursuant to which the Fund will seek to conduct an orderly liquidation to harvest the value of its assets, pay debts, make liquidating distributions to Shareholders and otherwise wind up its affairs with the goal of maximizing value for Shareholders. If the Fund Dissolution Proposal is approved, the Fund currently expects to return liquidation proceeds through periodic distributions as assets are liquidatedon one or more installments, ion such date or dates as the officers of the Fund, the Adviser or their delegates shall determine, while aiming to complete the liquidation around mid-2027, all subject to market conditions and the timing of the Shareholder approval. The Adviser will earn advisory fees on the cash generated by sales for a period of up to 30 days after monetization, at which time such funds will be distributed to shareholders, less any capital required to maintain the operations of the Fund until the liquidation has concluded. The mid-2027 target final liquidation date is not definitive, and the completion of the liquidation may occur before or after this target date.” 14. Please disclose the impact of the termination of the fee waiver agreement if it is expected to raise the Fund’s operating expense ratio during liquidation. The Fund has revised the disclosure to include the impact of the termination of the fee waiver agreement on the Fund’s operating expense ratio. Please see the new language that was added to the disclosure in the response to Comment 8 above. 15. Please consider adding disclosure regarding the impact of the termination of the fee waiver agreement on the Fund’s costs and any impact an increase in the operating expense ratio will have on the amount shareholders receive. The Fund has revised the disclosure in the section, “Other Information about the Proposals,” to state the following: “In reaching its determination to approve the Proposals, the Board, including the Independent Directors, considered various relevant factors. The considerations below reflect such reviews and discussions. The Board’s evaluation of the Proposals took into account not only all of this information, but information about the Fund received by the Board since its inception and that reflected the knowledge and familiarity gained as members of the Board during regularly scheduled quarterly meetings. Among the factors considered by the Board were: • The projected expenses that the Fund would experience if the Proposals were approved, including an increase in the operating expense ratio as a result of the termination of the Expense Limitation and Reimbursement Agreement between the Adviser and the Fund.” 4 Securities and Exchange Commission August 30, 2024 16. The proxy statement states that, “The Plan of Liquidation and Termination also provides that the Fund may maintain a reserve to fund future liabilities of the Fund after the liquidation.” Please disclose if the plan contemplates a specific reserve, and if so disclose the specific amount of the reserve and when it would be distributed to shareholders. The Fund confirms that it does not currently contemplate maintaining a specific reserve. 17. Please confirm to the Staff that if a reserve is maintained, that the Fund will maintain a list of shareholders entitled to receive the remainder of any such reserve established. The Fund confirms that if a reserve is maintained, it will maintain a list of the shareholders entitled to receive the remainder of any such reserve established. 18. Please confirm whether, if a reserve is established, advisory fees or other fees will be charged for holding the reserve and if so, consider disclosing this information. The Fund confirms that if a reserve is established, no advisory fees or other fees will be charged for holding the reserve. 19. On page 8, please add disclosure in the response to the question, “How will the Fundamental Policy Removal work?” to state that the removal of the policy will result in shareholders only having liquidity events based on the distributions of the liquidation proceeds, which will be in one or more installments, the timing of which will be in the discretion of the Adviser. The Fund has revised the disclosure as follows: “Q: How will the Fundamental Policy Removal work? A: The Fund operates as a closed-end interval fund; therefore, it conducts periodic repurchase offers of its shares pursuant to Rule 23c-3 under the 1940 Act. Pursuant to its interval fund status, in order to provide liquidity to Shareholders, the Fund has adopted a fundamental policy to make quarterly offers to repurchase between 5% and 25% of its outstanding shares at net asset value, and if Shareholders tender more shares than the Fund offers to repurchase, the Fund will repurchase the shares tendered on a pro rata basis (the “Fundamental Policy”). If Shareholders approve the Fundamental Policy Removal Proposal, the Fund will remove the Fundamental Policy. Please note that the termination of the Fundamental Policy will mean that Shareholders will no longer have 5 Securities and Exchange Commission August 30, 2024 guaranteed liquidity events, and instead will have periodic installments of liquidating distributions, the timing of which is not assured and will be in the discretion of the Adviser. The Adviser believes removing the Fundamental Policy is in the best interests of Shareholders and will facilitate an efficient liquidation.” 20. On page 9, under “The Board’s and the Adviser’s Rationale for the Proposals,” the second paragraph of the first bullet point states that, “An orderly liquidation would allow the Fund to harvest the value of its assets over time with the goal of maximizing value for Shareholders while also making liquidating distributions to provide Shareholders with liquidity.” Please reconcile this disclosure with the earlier disclosure that the Fund can do distributions in one or more installments, as this disclosure gives the impression that the Fund will be making periodic liquidation distributions. The Fund has revised the disclosure in the above-referenced section as follows: “An orderly liquidation would allow the Fund to harvest the value of its assets over time with the goal of maximizing value for Shareholders while also making liquidatingperiodic distributions as assets are liquidated to provide Shareholders with liquidity.” The Fund has also revised the disclosure in the section, “Dissolution of the Fund,” to state the following: “Q: How will the Fund Dissolution work? A: If Shareholders approve the Fund Dissolution Proposal, the Fund expects to implement a plan of liquidation and termination (the “Plan of Liquidation and Termination”) pursuant to which the Fund will seek to conduct an orderly liquidation to harvest the value of its assets, pay debts, make liquidating distributions to Shareholders and otherwise wind up its affairs with the goal of maximizing value for Shareholders. If the Fund Dissolution Proposal is approved, the Fund currently expects to return liquidation proceeds through periodic distributions as assets are liquidatedon one or more installments, ion such date or dates as the officers of the Fund, the Adviser or their delegates shall determine, while aiming to complete the liquidation around mid-2027, all subject to market conditions and the timing of the Shareholder approval.” 21. On page 9, the last paragraph states that, “The Board reviewed reasons for liquidation, the other potential alternative courses of actions that might address each of these considerations, input from the Fund’s selling agents, an overview of the current portfolio, the proposed Plan of Liquidation and Termination, anticipated changes in expenses and the proposed liquidation process.” Please disclose the anticipated changes in expenses that the Board considered, and in particular whether the total operating expense ratio will increase during this process.