SEC Comment Letter 0000000000-25-001875 to Jade Biosciences, Inc. (JBIO)
Jade Biosciences, Inc.
Date: Feb. 18, 2025 · CIK: 0001798749 · Accession: 0000000000-25-001875
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-283562
Show Raw Text
February 18, 2025
Timothy Noyes
Chief Executive Officer
Aerovate Therapeutics, Inc.
930 Winter Street, Suite M-500
Waltham, MA 02451
Re:Aerovate Therapeutics, Inc.
Amendment No. 1 to Registration Statement on Form S-4
Filed January 22, 2025
File No. 333-283562
Dear Timothy Noyes:
We have reviewed your registration statement and have the following comments.
Please respond to this letter by amending your registration statement and providing
the requested information. If you do not believe a comment applies to your facts and
circumstances or do not believe an amendment is appropriate, please tell us why in your
response.
After reviewing any amendment to your registration statement and the information
you provide in response to this letter, we may have additional comments.
Amendment No. 1 to Registration Statement on Form S-4
Cover Page
1.In the second paragraph on the prospectus cover page, you disclose what will happen
to each share of Jade common stock (including the shares to be issued in the Jade Pre-
Closing Financing) and each share of Jade Series Seed Convertible Preferred Stock
upon consummation of the merger. Please also disclose what will happen to the Jade
pre-funded warrants to be issued in the Jade Pre-Closing Financing. In this regard, we
note your disclosure on page 5 that the Jade pre-funded warrants will be exchanged
for Aerovate pre-funded warrants.
The description of Proposal 1 appears to contemplate the approval of two different
actions. Specifically, it appears to contemplate (i) approval of the issuance of shares
and (ii) approval of the change of control. Please revise the description of the proposal
to clarify, if true, that Proposal 1 covers one action (i.e., the issuance of shares), which
will (i) represent more than 20% of the shares of your common stock outstanding 2.
February 18, 2025
Page 2
immediately prior to the Merger and (ii) result in a change of control. Please make
similar revisions throughout the proxy statement prospectus as appropriate.
Alternatively, tell us why you do not believe these revisions are appropriate.
Questions and Answers about the Merger
Why am I receiving this proxy statement/prospectus?, page 2
3.In the second bullet point, you state that the proxy statement/prospectus serves as a
prospectus of Aerovate used to offer shares of Aerovate common stock, including
shares issuable upon the exercise of Aerovate pre-funded warrants and shares issuable
upon the conversion of Aerovate Series A Preferred Stock, which will be issued in
exchange for Jade pre-funded warrants and Jade Preferred Stock, respectively. Please
tell us whether the prospectus also is being used to offer the Aerovate pre-funded
warrants and the Aerovate Series A Preferred Stock or whether the issuance of such
securities will be made in reliance on an exemption from registration. If the latter,
please explain and provide us with your analysis as to the appropriateness of
registering the primary issuance of the shares underlying such securities.
What is the Jade Pre-Closing Financing?, page 2
4.Please revise this section to disclose the conversion price for the convertible notes and
the amount of the Jade Pre-Closing Financing that will be represented by the shares
issued upon conversion of the convertible notes.
Why is Aerovate seeking stockholder approval to issue shares..., page 4
5.You state that you expect to issue approximately 1.06 million shares of your common
stock, excluding shares underlying the Aerovate pre-funded warrants and the
Aerovate Series A Preferred Stock to be issued in connection with the merger. To the
extent known, please also disclose the number of shares of your common stock you
expect to underly such securities or otherwise advise. In this regard, we note your
disclosure regarding the Jade Pre-Closing Financing on page 310.
Will the common stock of the Combined Company trade on an exchange?, page 5
6.Given that the Nasdaq listing condition is waivable, please revise your disclosure to
indicate whether recirculation or resolicitation of stockholders will occur prior to the
vote if the listing application is not approved but the condition is waived. If
stockholders will not have certainty regarding the listing of the combined company's
shares at the time they are asked to vote, please clarify this fact. Please also provide
risk factor disclosure that addresses the potential consequences of the parties waiving
the condition and the closing occurring without the Nasdaq listing, including but not
limited to the liquidity implications thereof.
What happens if I do not return a proxy card..., page 7
You state that the failure to return a proxy card or otherwise vote or provide proxy
instructions will reduce the aggregate number of votes required to approve Proposal
Nos. 1, 5, 6 and 7 and will have the effect of a vote “AGAINST” Proposal Nos. 2, 3
and 4. Please revise your disclosure to clarify how proxies will vote shares
represented by a validly signed and returned proxy card that is not completed. In this 7.
February 18, 2025
Page 3
regard, we note your disclosures in your discussions of the proposals that, unless
otherwise instructed, it is the intention of the proxies to vote shares represented by
properly executed proxy cards "FOR" each of the proposals.
May I attend the Aerovate Special Meeting and vote in person?, page 7
8.To the extent applicable, please disclose how stockholders who hold their shares in
"street name" may attend the special meeting and vote in person.
What are the material U.S. federal income tax considerations of the Merger..., page 8
9.You state that there will be no U.S. federal income tax considerations to your
stockholders as a result of the merger. To the extent applicable, please briefly address
any U.S. federal income tax considerations to your stockholders resulting from the
cash payments to be made to your stockholders for the Aerovate ITM Options to be
cancelled in connection with the merger.
Prospectus Summary
The Companies, page 10
10.We note your discussion of JADE-001 on pages 10 and 11. Similar to your disclosure
on page 235, please disclose here that you were founded by Fairmount Funds
Management LLC in 2024 and launched to research and develop antibody candidates
licensed from Paragon Therapeutics, Inc., an antibody discovery engine founded by
Fairmount. In addition, your revised disclosure should:
•specifically disclose that you license JADE-001 from Paragon and that you have
an unexercised option to license JADE-002 and JADE-003 from Paragon;
•identify Fairmount and Paragon as related parties; and
•include a cross reference to a more fulsome discussion of your relationship, and
the nature of these arrangements, with Paragon.
The Special Meeting of Aerovate Stockholders
Required Vote, page 98
11.In the second sentence, you state that abstentions and broker non-votes will be
counted towards a quorum. However, in the second paragraph, you state that
abstentions and broker non-votes will not be treated as shares present for the purpose
of a quorum for the transaction of business at the special meeting. Please revise your
disclosures to reconcile this apparent inconsistency or otherwise advise.
The Merger
Aerovate's Reasons for the Merger, page 108
We note that one of the factors considered by your board of directors in support of its
decision to approve the merger agreement included the board’s conclusion that the
merger would provide your existing stockholders a "significant opportunity" to
participate in the potential growth of the combined company following the merger.
Please revise your disclosure to clarify what you mean by "significant opportunity." In
this regard, we note that your existing stockholders will in the aggregate hold
approximately 1.6% of the fully-diluted shares of your common stock immediately 12.
February 18, 2025
Page 4
following the merger, a substantially smaller percentage than proposed by the other
counterparties discussed in the "Background of the Transaction."
Opinion of Aerovate's Financial Advisor, page 114
13.We note your statement on page 115 that, in connection with the Lucid Opinion,
Lucid (i) reviewed certain pro forma financial effects of the merger and (ii) reviewed
and analyzed certain internal financial analyses, including the cash burn model over
the next year and whether concurrent capital raised would sufficiently cover select
programs, reports, and other information concerning Jade provided by Jade. However,
we do not see disclosure of these projections in the discussion regarding the Lucid
Opinion. Please provide us with your analysis as to whether these projections are
material. In your analysis, tell us whether these projections were used or relied upon
by your board of directors or Lucid in reaching the fairness determination, whether
they affected the merger consideration, exchange ratio or other material terms of the
transaction during negotiations, and how the projections relate to the merger
consideration. Alternatively, revise your discussion to disclose the projections.
Interests of Jade Directors and Executive Officers in the Merger
Frohlich and King Anti-Dilution Provisions, page 127
14.We note your disclosure regarding the anti-dilution rights held by Tom Frohlich and
Andrew King, including that the rights are applicable until Jade has raised an
aggregate of $200 million in financing. Please disclose whether the Jade Pre-Closing
Financing will trigger and/or extinguish these rights. If the Jade Pre-Closing
Financing will trigger these rights, disclose the approximate number of options, and
any applicable terms thereof, expected to be issued to Tom Frohlich and Andrew King
pursuant to these rights.
U.S. Federal Income Tax Considerations of the Merger, page 130
15.We note your disclosure that each of Jade and Aerovate "intends" that the merger
qualifies as a "reorganization" within the meaning of Section 368(a) of the Code.
Please revise to clearly state whether the transaction will qualify as a reorganization,
include an opinion of counsel covering the material tax consequences of the merger
and state that the disclosure in this section represents the opinion of counsel. If there is
uncertainty regarding the tax treatment of the transactions, counsel may (1) issue a
"should" or "more likely than not" opinion to make clear that the opinion is subject to
a degree of uncertainty and (2) explain why it cannot give a firm opinion. Refer to
Section III.C of Staff Legal Bulletin No. 19. Please also remove language assuming
certain consequences (e.g., assuming that the merger constitutes a reorganization).
For further guidance, refer to Item 601(b)(8) of Regulation S-K and Staff Legal
Bulletin No. 19.
Agreements Related to the Merger
Subscription Agreement, page 153
To the extent not already described in this section, please revise your disclosure to
briefly describe the material terms of the pre-funded warrants to be issued in
16.
February 18, 2025
Page 5
connection with the merger transactions, including, for example, the exercise period
and duration of the warrants.
Proposal No. 2 - The Reverse Stock Split Proposal, page 169
17.In the second paragraph under "General" on page 169, you state that your board of
directors may determine to effect the reverse stock split, if approved, even if the other
proposals to be acted upon at the meeting are not approved, including the issuance of
your common stock pursuant to the Merger Agreement. However, in the second two
paragraphs under "Required Vote" on page 174, you indicate that the reverse stock
split cannot and will not be effected unless the Nasdaq Stock Issuance Proposal and
the Authorized Share Increase Proposal are approved and the merger is consummated.
Please revise your disclosures as appropriate to reconcile this apparent inconsistency.
In addition, if the reverse stock split may be effected without consummation of the
merger, clarify whether the Jade board of directors will still have input regarding the
split ratio and in determining whether to effect the reverse stock split.
Proposal No. 4 - The Redomestication Proposal
Interest of Certain Persons, page 199
18.You state that others may allege, and stockholders should be aware, that the combined
company’s directors and executive officers may be considered to have interests in the
Nevada Redomestication that are different form, or in addition to, the interests of the
stockholders generally. Please revise your disclosure to briefly describe these
interests.
Jade's Business
Overview, page 233
19.On page 234, you state that Jade benefits from the availability of researchers, drug
developers, and manufacturers with experience in monoclonal antibodies that it can
access to support its efforts, subject to any restrictions related to intellectual property.
Please revise your disclosures to clarify the nature of this "access," and describe how
restrictions related to intellectual property may impact such access.
20.We note your references on page 235 to "accelerated approval." Please revise your
disclosures where you discuss qualifying for accelerated approval to include balancing
disclosure that an accelerated approval pathway may not lead to a faster development
or regulatory review or approval process and does not increase the likelihood that a
product candidate will receive marketing approval.
21.Please balance the statement that JADE-001 has the potential to capture a sizable
portion of what it estimates to be the $10 billion IgAN market with the fact that you
have not begun clinical development of JADE-001 and that it will be several years
before you will be able to commercialize JADE-001 if you are able to successfully
complete clinical trials.
Jade's Strategy, page 236
We note your disclosure in the second bullet point that Jade has commenced
preclinical discovery with respect to its JADE-002 and JADE-003 programs. Given 22.
February 18, 2025
Page 6
that Jade has not yet exercised its options to license the JADE-002 and JADE-003
targets from Paragon, please revise your disclosure as appropriate to clarify the nature
and extent of these preclinical discovery activities, including to clarify Paragon’s
involvement, if any, in such activities. For example, if true, disclose that, pursuant to
the terms of the Paragon Option Agreement and a related Research Plan, Paragon is
performing the preclinical discovery activities.
Jade's Collaboration, License and Services Agreements
Paragon Option Agreement, page 251
23.We note your disclosures regarding the Paragon Option Agreement. Please revise
your disclosures about the Paragon Option Agreement to clarify:
•when the separate license agreement is pre-negotiated (e.g., when selecting a
target or prior thereto or thereafter, before exercising an option, etc.); and
•which multispecific antibodies and products are covered by the right of first
negotiation described on pages 252 and 254.
JADE-001 License Agreement, page 253
24.Please disclose whether the key terms of the License Agreement described in this
section were "pre-negotiated," as suggested on pages 252, 296, and 311. If yes, clarify
whether you expect the "pre-negotiated" terms to be consistent across all options
under the Paragon Option Agreement, particularly JADE-002 and JADE-003.
25.In the first paragraph, you state that the License Agreement gives Jade an "exclusive
and sublicensable license" for "certain antibodies and products targeting APRIL."
However, your disclosures throughout the proxy statement/prospectus indicate that
Jade exercised an option, and entered into a license agreement, for JADE-001, which
you identify as Jade’s initial product candidate. To the extent applicable, please revise
your disclosures to clarify whether the exercised option extends beyond JADE-001
and/or a specific product candidate. If only the License Agreement extends beyond
JADE-001 and/or a specific product candidate, please briefly descri