SEC Company Response from Masterworks 010, LLC (CIK 0001806902) — May 5, 2020
Masterworks 010, LLC (CIK 0001806902)
Date: May 5, 2020 · CIK: 0001806902 · Accession: 0001493152-20-007745
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 024-11189
Referenced dates: May 5, 2020
Show Raw Text
CORRESP
1
filename1.htm
ANTHONY
L.G., PLLC
laura
aNTHONy, esq
www.ANTHONYPLLC.com
GEOFFREY
ASHBURNE, ESQ*
WWW.SECURITIESLAWBLOG.COM
JOHN
CACOMANOLIS, ESQ**
WWW.LAWCAST.COM
CHAD
FRIEND, ESQ, LLM
SVETLANA
ROVENSKAYA, ESQ***
OF
COUNSEL:
DIRECT
E-MAIL: LANTHONY@ANTHONYPLLC.COM
MICHAEL
R. GEROE, ESQ, CIPP/US****
CRAIG
D. LINDER, ESQ*****
PETER
P. LINDLEY, ESQ, CPA, MBA
Philip
magri, esq.******
STUART
REED, ESQ
MARC
S. WOOLF, ESQ
*licensed in CA
**licensed in FL and NY
***licensed in NY and NJ
****licensed in CA, DC, MO and NY
*****licensed in CA, FL and NY
******licensed in FL and NY
May
5, 2020
VIA
ELECTRONIC EDGAR FILING
Office
of Trade & Services
Division
of corporate Finance
Securities
and Exchange Commission
100
F. Street, N.E.
Washington,
D.C. 20549
Re:
Masterworks
010, LLC
Amendment
No. 1 to Offering Statement on Form 1-A
Filed
April 6, 2020
File
No. 024-11189
Dear
Sir or Madam:
The
following is a narrative response herein keyed to the comments
of the staff of the Division of Corporation Finance (the “Staff”) on the Form 1-A (“Form 1-A”) of Masterworks
010, LLC (the “Company”) set forth in the Staff’s comment letter to Josh Goldstein dated May 5, 2020. We
trust you shall deem the contents of this transmittal letter responsive to your comment letter.
Organizational
Structure, page 6
1.
Comment:
We note that you have listed some broad categories of risk factors applicable to an investment in your offering. Item 3 of
Form 1-A requires a carefully organized series of short, concise paragraphs, summarizing the most significant factors that
make the offering speculative or substantially risky. Please revise to make this clear or tell us how this depiction is appropriate.
Response:
The Company believes that the section of the Offering Circular entitled “Risk Factors” beginning on page 10 of
the Form 1-A meets the substantive requirements of Item 3(b) of Form 1-A, despite the fact that it does not immediately follow
the Summary section as provided in Item 3(b), but rather is presented immediately following “Determination of Offering Price”
and “Distribution Policy” on page 6 of the Form 1-A. Accordingly, the language in question was not intended
to meet the substantive requirements of Item 3(b), but rather was intended to satisfy the more generalized requirements of Item
3(a) to provide a brief summary of the more detailed “Risk Factor” section.
However,
in light of the Staff’s Comment, the Company proposes to replace the abbreviated bullet-point risk factors, with the following
more fulsome summary risk factor discussion:
“●
Risks
Related to Our Business Model. Our business model is relatively new and untested and we do not plan to generate any
revenues. Our strategy is to own the Painting for an extended period of time and sell it at a profit, but no assurance
can be given that we will be able to sell the Painting at a profit or the timing of any such sale.
●
Risks
Associated with an Investment in a Company owning Fine Art. Artwork can be highly illiquid and investors must be prepared
to hold their investment for an extended period of time. The Painting may decline in value or may not appreciate sufficiently
to exceed administration fees and expenses. There are a variety of other risks to art investing, including, without limitation,
the risk of claims that the artwork is not authentic, physical damage and market risks for any particular artist or work.
●
Risks
Relating to Our Relationship with Masterworks. Since we have minimal liquid assets, we are totally reliant on Masterworks
to administer our business. If Masterworks were to cease operations for any reason it would be difficult for us to find a
replacement administrator and we would likely be required to sell the Painting and dissolve the Company. In addition, since
Masterworks owns Class B shares, which represent “profits interests” and earns fees and incurs maintenance expenses
relating to the administration of our business, Masterworks may have economic interests that diverge from your interests.
●
Risks
Related to Ownership of the Class A shares and the Offering. Investors
in this Offering will have limited voting rights and Masterworks and its affiliates will have significant discretion to
operate the business and sell the Painting. In addition, the Class A shares may be illiquid and will not be listed for
trading on a national stock exchange.”
The
Company proposes to make this change in the final Offering Circular to be filed promptly following qualification of the Offering
Statement pursuant to Rule 253(g)(2).
General
2.
Comment:
On the landing page of your web-site, you include the banner “join an exclusive community of blue-chip art investors”
and you depict several pieces of art, as well as the purchase price and sale price, however, you do not make it clear that
you do not own any of these pieces of art and the purchase and sale prices do not represent prices at which you have bought
or sold. Please revise to make this clear or tell us how this depiction is appropriate.
Response:
In response to the Staff’s comment, the Company has added the following text on its website under the example
paintings to clarify that these are not intended to reflect artwork or securities that are or were owned, bought or sold by Masterworks.
“The
artwork and purchase and sale prices reflected on this page were obtained from public auction records. This information is presented
for illustrative purposes only and does not reflect works owned, securitized, purchased or sold by Masterworks.”
3.
Comment:
On the landing page of your web-site under the heading “Artists,” you identify several artists as well
as the median annual returns on art produced by the artists, however, you do not make it clear that you do not own art produced
by all of these artists nor are the returns for those artists in which you do own art representative of your returns, given
that you have yet to sell any art. Please revise to make these points clear or tell us why this presentation is appropriate.
In
response to the Staff’s comment, the Company has added the following text on its website to the legend in proximity
to the examples cited in the Staffs Comment:
“Artist
information is presented for illustrative purposes only and Masterworks does not own, securitize, purchase or sell works by all
of such artists.”
The
Company believes that such additional language, combined with the language already included in proximity to the artist data which
states that “Historical returns are also not comparable to or intended to represent or be a proxy for returns on Masterworks
shares” addresses the concerns raised in the Staff’s Comment.
Anthony
L.G., PLLC
By:
/s/
Laura Anthony
Laura
Anthony, Esq.
cc:
Scott Anderegg/U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission
Tony
Watson/ U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Donna
Di Silvio/U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Mara
Ransom/U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Joshua B. Goldstein/Masterworks 001, LLC
Craig D. Linder, Esq./Anthony L.G., PLLC
625
N. FLAGLER DRIVE, #600 ● WEST PALM BEACH,
FLORIDA ● 33401 ● PHONE: 561-514-0936 ● FAX 561-514-0832