Correspondence 0002025968-24-000006 from BNY Mellon ETF Trust II (CIK 0002025968)
BNY Mellon ETF Trust II (CIK 0002025968)
Date: Aug. 29, 2024 · CIK: 0002025968 · Accession: 0002025968-24-000006
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-280471, 811-23977
Referenced dates: July 25, 2024
Show Raw Text
CORRESP 1 filename1.htm Beau Yanoshik Partner +1.202.373.6133 beau.yanoshik@morganlewis.com Via EDGAR Correspondence August 29, 2024 Ellie Quarles U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Division of Investment Management 100 F Street NE Washington, DC 20549 Re: BNY Mellon ETF Trust II (the “Registrant”) File Nos. 333-280471 and 811-23977 Dear Ms. Quarles: This letter responds to comments you provided in a letter dated July 25, 2024, with respect to the Registrant’s Registration Statement on Form N-1A (the “Registration Statement”). The Registration Statement was filed on June 26, 2024, and included disclosure with respect to the following two series of the Registrant: BNY Mellon Concentrated Growth ETF and BNY Mellon Dynamic Value ETF. Summaries of the comments and responses thereto on behalf of the Registrant are provided below. GENERAL COMMENTS 1. Comment: We note that substantial portions of the Registration Statement are incomplete. Please ensure all information is included in a pre-effective amendment, including the fee table, hypothetical expense examples, references to the auditor, auditor’s consent, and seed financial statements. A full financial review must be performed prior to declaring the Registration Statement effective. We may have additional comments on such portions when the Fund completes them in a pre-effective amendment, on disclosures made in response to this letter, on information supplied supplementally (including information about the Predecessor Fund), or on exhibits added in any amendment. Response: The Registrant acknowledges the staff’s comment and will complete all missing information in one or more pre-effective amendments. Morgan, Lewis & Bockius llp 1111 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20004 +1.202.739.3000 United States +1.202.739.3001 2. Comment: Please advise us if you have submitted or expect to submit any exemptive applications or no-action requests in connection with the Registration Statement. Response: The Registrant confirms it has not, and does not expect to, submit any exemptive applications or no-action requests in connection with the Registration Statement. 3. Comment: Please update each Fund’s ticker symbol in EDGAR and include the Fund’s ticker symbol on the cover page of the prospectus and the Statement of Additional Information. See Items 1(a)(2) and 14(a)(2) of Form N-1A; Regulation S-T, Rule 313(b)(1). Response: The Registrant confirms the ticker symbols will be updated on EDGAR, and the cover page of the Prospectuses and the Statements of Additional Information have been revised to include each Fund’s ticker symbol. PROSPECTUS BNY Mellon Concentrated Growth ETF General 4. Comment: In the “Performance” section, the Fund indicates that a Predecessor Fund will be reorganized at which time the Fund will commence operations. Please supplementally provide the staff with additional information and background on the Predecessor Fund, including the status of the reorganization. Response: The Registrant has provided the requested information to the staff supplementally. Fees and Expenses, page 1 5. Comment: Please supplementally provide a completed expense table and example for each Fund. Response: The Registrant has provided completed expense table and example for each Fund to the staff supplementally. 6. Comment: To the extent that the Predecessor Fund qualifies as a predecessor, please provide the fee table based on the fees and expenses of the Predecessor Fund for the prior fiscal year, restated to reflect the expenses for the current fiscal year. a. Please add a footnote explaining that this Fund is the successor to Predecessor Fund, and that the fees and expenses have been restated to reflect the fees and expenses for the current fiscal year. See Item 3 of Form N-1A. b. Please also remove footnote 1 to the fee table and reflect the Other Expenses of the Predecessor Fund or explain supplementally how the Fund is a New Fund as defined in Instruction 6 to Item 3 of Form N-1A. Response: With respect to a., the Registrant has added the requested footnote. With respect to b., the Registrant has removed the footnote as requested. 7. Comment: The footnote denoted by the asterisk provides extraneous information. The summary prospectus should not include disclosure in response to Item 3 of Form N-1A other than the disclosure that is required or permitted by the Item. See General Instruction C.3.(b) of Form N-1A. Response: The Registrant has removed the footnote as requested. Principal Investment Strategy, page 1 8. Comment: The Fund discloses that it will invest principally in common stocks. If the Fund’s principal investments will include other equity investments (e.g., investments in initial public offerings, master limited partnerships, limited liability companies, preferred stock, real estate investment trusts, or warrants, which are identified as equity securities in the SAI), please provide disclosure about those principal investments and related risks. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant confirms that the Fund does not currently intend to invest in other types of equity investments as part of its principal investment strategy. With respect to the BNY Mellon Dynamic Value ETF, the “Fund Details” section has been revised to indicate the Fund may invest in real estate investment trusts and depositary receipts as non-principal strategies. Corresponding non-principal risk discussions have also been included. 9. Comment: Please define how the Fund will determine whether a company is a foreign security. Response: The Registrant has revised the first sentence of the fourth paragraph as follows: The fund may invest up to 10% of its net assets in direct investments in foreign securities (i.e., issued by companies organized under the laws of countries other than the U.S.). In addition to direct investments in foreign securities, the fund also may invest in U.S. dollar-denominated American Depositary Receipts (ADRs). 10. Comment: Each Fund provides significant disclosure about derivatives in the SAI. To the extent a Fund uses derivatives as part of its principal investment strategies, or such use subjects the Fund to a principal risk, the principal investment strategies and principal risks sections should: (1) adequately discuss the specific derivative instruments used to achieve the Fund’s investment objective, and (2) specifically address the purposes for the use of such derivatives to ensure that the information provided is not too generic or standardized. See Barry Miller Letter to the ICI, available at https://www.sec.gov/divisions/investment/guidance/ici073010.pdf. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant confirms that neither the BNY Mellon Concentrated Growth ETF nor the BNY Mellon Dynamic Value ETF currently intends to use derivatives as part of its principal investment strategy. 11. Comment: As noted in the Fund’s SAI, with respect to the risks of stock investing, please disclose that holders of common stock have a lower priority in reorganization and bankruptcy proceedings. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant has revised the “Risks of stock investing” discussion as follows: Risks of stock investing. Stocks generally fluctuate more in value than bonds and may decline significantly over short time periods. There is the chance that stock prices overall will decline because stock markets tend to move in cycles, with periods of rising prices and falling prices. The market value of a stock may decline due to general market conditions or because of factors that affect the particular company or the company’s industry. Holders of common stock incur more risk than holders of preferred stock and debt obligations because common stockholders, as owners of the issuer, generally have inferior rights to receive payments from the issuer in comparison with the rights of holders of debt obligations or preferred stock issued by the issuer. 12. Comment: With respect to foreign investment risk, to the extent that the Fund will have principal investments in emerging markets, please discuss in response to the principal investment strategy and disclose the related risk. See ADI 2020-11 – Registered Funds’ Risk Disclosure Regarding Investments in Emerging Markets, available at https://www.sec.gov/about/divisions-offices/division-investment-management/accounting-disclosure-information/registered-funds-risk-disclosure-investments-emerging-markets. Please also consider whether disclosure regarding a specific country or region is warranted. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant confirms neither the BNY Mellon Concentrated Growth ETF nor the BNY Mellon Dynamic Value ETF currently intends to invest in emerging markets as part of its principal investment strategy. 13. Comment: We note the disclosure regarding fluctuation of net asset value, share premiums, and discounts risk. For clarity, consider disclosing that the market price may deviate from the value of the ETF’s underlying holdings and that this can be reflected as a spread between the bid and ask prices for the ETF quoted during the day or a premium or discount in the closing price from the ETF’s NAV. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant believes the current disclosure is appropriate. The Registrant notes an ETF’s shares may trade at prices above (premium) or below (discount) the value of the ETF’s underlying holdings throughout the day (i.e., the premium or discount is not only with respect to the closing price). The bid-ask spread refers to the highest price a buyer is willing to pay to purchase shares of an ETF (bid) and the lowest price a seller is willing to accept for shares of the ETF (ask), and is not necessarily a reflection of whether an ETF’s shares are trading at a premium or discount from the value of its underlying holdings. Performance, page 4 14. Comment: Please supplementally identify the broad-based securities market index that the Fund will use. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The BNY Mellon Concentrated Growth ETF currently intends to use the S&P 500 Index as its broad-based securities market index. The BNY Mellon Dynamic Value ETF currently intends to use the Russell 1000 Index as its broad-based securities market index. 15. Comment: Please clarify whether or not the Predecessor Fund had substantially similar objectives, policies, and investment strategies as the Fund. Response: The Registrant has revised the first paragraph in response to the comment and provided to the staff supplementally. 16. Comment: We may have further comments on this section once you have provided us with more information about the Predecessor Fund. Response: The Registrant acknowledges the staff’s comment. Goal and Approach, page 5 17. Comment: Please revise the disclosure related to your principal investment strategy and risks based on the comments on the disclosure provided in response to Item 4. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant has made applicable revisions as requested. 18. Comment: Please disclose how the sub-adviser is alert to companies that it considers undervalued and provide a plain English description of attribution software. Response: The Registrant has revised the second paragraph as follows: In choosing stocks, the fund’s sub-adviser first identifies sectors that it believes will expand over the next three to five years or longer. Using fundamental analysis, the fund’s sub-adviser then invests in growth companies within these sectors that it believes have dominant positions in their industries and that have demonstrated sustained patterns of profitability, strong balance sheets and/or an expanding global presence. The fund’s sub-adviser also is alert to seeks to identify companies which it considers undervalued in terms of current earnings, assets, or growth prospects. The sub-adviser routinely evaluates the fund’s portfolio for changing qualitative risks, which may include, but is not limited to, shifting company competitive status, turnover in company management, and adverse industry developments. As a supplement to its primarily qualitative approach to risk, the fund’s sub-adviser utilizes attribution software designed to quantify the contribution of various investment factors to overall portfolio performance and equity risk factor models to conduct scenario analysis to enhance its understanding and management of the risk profile of the fund’s portfolio. The fund’s portfolio typically will consist of 25-35 companies. 19. Comment: The disclosure indicates that the Fund sells a stock when there is a “significant adverse change in the company’s business fundamentals that may lead to a sustained impairment in earnings power.” Please provide examples of the types of changes the sub-adviser would consider. Response: The Registrant has revised the sixth paragraph as follows: The fund typically sells a stock when the fund’s sub-adviser believes there is a significant adverse change in the company’s business fundamentals (e.g., an increase in market competition, a decrease in the company’s market share, and/or a decrease in customer demand for the company’s product) that may lead to a sustained impairment in earnings power. Investment Risks 20. Comment: We note the risk disclosure about the fluctuation of net asset value, share premiums, and discount risk. Please delete the parenthetical regarding the trading of closed-end funds as it is not relevant to the operations of the Fund and could cause investor confusion. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant has removed the parenthetical as requested. 21. Comment: At the end of the risk disclosure, the Fund provides disclosure about risks that “are not anticipated to be principal risks.” Please include a heading that indicates that the following risks are non-principal risks or relocate these risks to the SAI. See June 2014 Guidance Regarding Mutual Fund Enhanced Disclosure, available at https://www.sec.gov/investment/im-guidance-2014-08.pdf. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant has added the requested heading. Additional Purchase and Sale Information, page 11 22. Comment: With respect to the disclosure in clause (vi), the staff reminds the Funds that such information must be maintained for at least one year thereafter. See Rule 6c-11(c)(1)(vi) under the Investment Company Act of 1940. This comment applies to both Funds. Response: The Registrant acknowledges the staff’s comment. Financial Highlights, page 16 23. Comment: Please provide the auditor’s consent for the Predecessor Fund financial information. Response: The Registrant confirms an auditor’s consent for the Predecessor Fund financial information will be included as an exhibit to a pre-effective amendment filing. BNY Mellon Dynamic Value ETF Principal Investment Strategy, page 1 24. Comment: In the second paragraph, please provide additional summary disclosure about how the sub-adviser considers the three key factors. See Item 4(a) of Form N-1A. Response: The Registrant has revised the second paragraph as follows: The fund’s sub-adviser identifies potential investments through extensive quantitative and fundamental research. The fund focuses on individual stock selection (a “bottom-up” approach), emphasizing three key factors: intrinsic value, sound business fundamentals and positive business momentum. • intrinsic value: the sub-adviser analyzes a company’s traditional measures, such as price-to-earnings ratio, price-to-book ratio, price-to-sales ratio, and cash flows, to determine if the company is priced below its intrinsic value; • sound business fundamentals: the sub-adviser analyzes a company’s balance sheet, income, and cash flow data to determine the company’s financial history and cu