SEC Comment Letter for World Monitor Trust III (CIK 0001305201) — Nov 10, 2004
World Monitor Trust III (CIK 0001305201)
Date: Nov. 10, 2004 · CIK: 0001305201 · Accession: 0000000000-04-036237
AI Filing Summary & Sentiment
File numbers found in text: 333-119612
Show Raw Text
<DOCUMENT> <TYPE>LETTER <SEQUENCE>1 <FILENAME>filename1.txt <TEXT> 20549-0409 November 10, 2004 Mr. Marc S. Goodman Preferred Investment Solutions Corporation Two American Lane Greenwich, Connecticut 06830 Re: World Monitor Trust III Registration Statement on Form S-1, filed on October 8, 2004 File No. 333-119612 Dear Mr. Goodman: We have reviewed your filing and have the following comments. Where indicated, we think you should revise your document in response to these comments. If you disagree, we will consider your explanation as to why our comment is inapplicable or a revision is unnecessary. Please be as detailed as necessary in your explanation. In some of our comments, we may ask you to provide us with supplemental information so we may better understand your disclosure. After reviewing this information, we may or may not raise additional comments. Please understand that the purpose of our review process is to assist you in your compliance with the applicable disclosure requirements and to enhance the overall disclosure in your filing. We look forward to working with you in these respects. We welcome any questions you may have about our comments or on any other aspect of our review. Feel free to call us at the telephone numbers listed at the end of this letter. General 1. Please revise your document significantly to bring it within the guidelines of Plain English. We note, for example, that your cover page is greater than one page in length, that you have defined terms throughout your document, and that you have embedded lists in various places. Please see Items 421(b) and (d) of Regulation C, as well as Staff Legal Bulletin 7A. 2. In connection with the above comment, it is not clear why you refer to World Monitor Trust III as the "Fund" since such term is not part of the pool`s name, nor is the pool a mutual fund registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940. Please revise to refer to the pool by its name or a variation of its name. 3. Please revise throughout the prospectus to provide disclosure substantially similar to the disclosures that would be required by Industry Guide 5 if real estate limited partnership units were being registered. For example, your revisions should include disclosure of the fees and expenses payable to the managing owner and its affiliates in the tabular format contemplated by Item 4 of Guide 5, together with estimates of the total amount of each fee and expense to the extent reasonably practicable, a narrative discussion under an appropriate major heading of the managing owner and its affiliates` experience over the past ten years similar to that required by Item 8.A of Guide 5, which includes such information as a description of any major adverse business developments and conditions that were experienced. 4. Please provide us with a complete copy of any sales material which includes all illustrations and other inserts in the form you expect to distribute to investors in accordance with Release No. 33-6900 and by analogy to Item 19D of Guide 5. We may have further comment after we receive your materials. 5. Please provide a Management`s Discussion and Analysis (MD&A) section within the registration statement prepared in accordance with Item 303 of Regulations S-K and specifically include the disclosures related to the following: 1) liquidity and capital resources, 2) off- balance sheet arrangements, and 3) a tabular disclosure of contractual obligations. Refer to FR-72 for the Commission`s guidance regarding management discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations. 6. In addition, please provide a discussion of what you expect to be your most critical accounting policies, which should include what you believe to be your most difficult and judgmental estimates, the most important and pervasive accounting policies used, and the areas most sensitive to material change from external factors. Refer to FR-60. 7. Please supplementally confirm to us, if true, that all units redeemed or otherwise re-acquired by the trust will not be re-issued to other investors. If you do intend to re-issue redeemed or re- acquired units, please tell us supplementally how you intend to register those re-issuances under the Securities Act. 8. We note that investors will be entitled to exchange their units in one series for units in a different series, so long as the exchange is for the same class of units. In addition, we refer to your statement that such an exchange will be treated as a redemption of one unit and the subsequent sale of a separate unit, except that no redemption fees would be charged. Please supplementally confirm to us what exemption from registration you will rely upon in connection with the exchanges. 9. Please summarize, immediately following the cover page, the suitability standards that investors must meet in order to invest in this offering. In addition, if suitability standards in individual states in which you intend to offer your units differ from these standards, please summarize the suitability standards of such states. 10. Please advise us supplementally whether the managing owner or its affiliates can purchase units in the offering so as to reach the minimum subscription. If so, please also disclose this fact on the cover page of the prospectus and in the prospectus summary. 11. Please revise to indicate the factors considered in determining the offering price. Refer to Item 505 of Regulation S-K. 12. We note that you propose to offer units in three series - G,H and I - as well as two classes within each series (Class I and II units). Please revise the facing page to indicate each security that you are registering and revise the facing page and cover page of the prospectus to allocate the number of shares being registered for each series as well as each class within each series. Please be aware that all shares being registered must be allocated to a specific series and class. 13. Please revise your outside cover page to reflect the respective series in the fee table. When you revise, please indicate which paragraph of Rule 457 you relied upon for calculation of the registration fee. 14. Refer to the disclosure concerning your share redemption program on pages 71-72. Supplementally, please provide a detailed analysis regarding the applicability of the tender offer rules to the share redemption program. Specifically, in your analysis please address your intention to redeem shares without any limit on the percentage of shares you may redeem and the fact that the redemptions will not be conducted pro rata. Refer to Rule 13e-4 and Regulation 14E of the Exchange Act. Prospectus Cover Page 15. Please confirm that your cover page will be one page only. We refer to Item 501(b)(3) of Regulation S-K. Please revise to remove information not required by Item 501, Guide 5 or the Part 4 Rules promulgated by the CFTC. 16. Please disclose, in the header, the minimum and maximum number of units being offered for each series and each class within each series. In connection with this, please briefly describe what Class I and Class II units are. 17. Please revise to briefly define what constitutes a "best efforts" offering. 18. Please disclose the termination date of the registered offering. Refer to Item 501(b)(8)(iii). 19. We note your statement in the first footnote to the table on the bottom of the cover page stating that should you not reach the minimum offering for any of the series, money tendered by subscribers will be returned without penalty together with interest "within 10 days or as soon thereafter as practicable." Please be aware that pursuant to Rule 10b-9(a)(1) any funds should be returned promptly. We do not agree that 10 days is consistent with Rule 10b-9, and the qualification included in this footnote casts doubt about whether funds would even be returned within this time period. Please revise accordingly. 20. Please revise the first cover page risk factor to clarify whether there is a limitation on the amount to which each fund may be leveraged. 21. Please revise the cover page risk factors to include the risk resulting from conflicts of interest, including a brief description of the nature of the conflicts and the identity of the parties to the conflicts. Please also revise your summary risk factors to address risks associated with conflicts of interest. When you revise, please clarify that you have no formal procedure to resolve conflicts. We note your disclosure on page 73. 22. Please revise the cover page risk factors to include the risk related to forwards, swaps, hybrids, and other derivatives not subject to CFTC regulation. 23. As one of your cover page risk factors, please briefly quantify the fees that you will be required to pay. Please also disclose, if true, that the managing owner has the authority to substantially increase the amount of those fees without the approval of the limited partners. 24. Please advise us supplementally under what circumstances the managing owner may extend the offering period up to ninety days. 25. Since this is not a firm commitment underwritten offering, it is not appropriate to highlight the Managing Owner at the bottom of the cover page. Please revise. We note that the Managing Owner is referenced in the second paragraph of the cover page. Commodity Futures Trading Commission Risk Disclosure Statement - page iii 26. Please revise to delete the references to public reference facilities in Chicago and New York, because they are no longer in operation. Summary 27. Your summary contains detailed information about the pool and the advisors you intend to utilize that is more appropriate for the body of the prospectus. Please limit your summary to the most significant aspects of the pool and your offering. In connection with this, please revise to remove repetitive disclosure found within the summary section. 28. We note that you have included a significant number of cross- references in the forepart of the prospectus. This indicates that the presentation could be better organized. Please reduce your reliance on cross-references, especially in the summary and risk factors sections of the prospectus and on the prospectus cover page. 29. It is inappropriate to qualify in entirety one section of your prospectus to the remaining body of the prospectus. Please revise. 30. Please revise to include an organizational diagram of World Monitor Trust III which includes the ownership percentages and material relationships among the entities pictured. 31. Please revise to include summary disclosure addressing reports to unit holders. Please refer to Guide 5, Item 15. Overview - page 2 32. It is not clear what the purpose of this section is since it contains only cross-references to other portions of the prospectus. A reliance on cross-references indicates that the prospectus could be better organized. Please revise to remove the cross-references and, if necessary, revise the summary to briefly include the information referenced under this heading. Risk Factors - page 2 33. Please expand the initial summary risk factor to clarify that your lack of operating history is a risk to investors because investors have no performance history to serve as the basis for evaluating an investment in the fund. 34. Please revise to include summary risk factor disclosure addressing the fact that the managing owner may at any time and in its sole discretion select and allocate the fund`s assets to commodity trading advisors other than those named within the prospectus, and investors will have to rely on the ability of the managing owner to select such additional advisors. 35. Please revise Risk Factor Four to succinctly quantify the "substantial charges" and "significant profits" you reference. Please clarify, if true, that you may never achieve profits, significant or otherwise. The fund and its objective - page 3 36. Please disclose the number of public pools run by the managing owner. The Advisors - page 3 37. Please revise your disclosure to specifically indicate which programs conduct technical, systematic, fundamental and discretionary trading programs. Who may subscribe - page 5 38. Please revise to convey that some states may require a greater investment, naming each state and quantify the minimum amount that exceeds your stated minimum initial investment of $5,000. How to Subscribe - page 6 39. This disclosure appears to be redundant of disclosure included under "How to Subscribe" on page 5. Please revise to combine the disclosures. Escrow of Funds - page 6 40. Please revise to indicate the time frame within which escrowed funds will be returned to investors in the event you do not meet your minimum subscription. Please also disclose any fees or other amounts that will be deducted from the amounts returned. Fees and Expenses - page 7 41. Please revise your fee disclosure to provide disclosure in tabular format in addition to the narrative disclosure you have included. The table should include a full explanation of each fee category, the nature of such fee, who specifically receives each fee and how the fee is calculated. Tax status of each series, page 9 42. We note your statement that counsel has opined that each of the series "will be" properly classified as a partnership and that they "will not be" treated as publicly traded partnerships. It is not clear why these statements are made in the future tense since the partnerships have been formed and counsel has provided such an opinion to the pool. Please revise or advise. Breakeven Table - page 10 43. Please revise to include redemption fees that certain investors may incur if they redeem their units during the first year. If you do not believe that this information is required or is impracticable to disclose, please tell us why in your response letter. In addition, please tell us why you have not included any incentive fees. 44. We note that, for purposes of the break-even table, you are assuming that 100 percent of the cash will earn interest income. However, on page 68 you indicate that each series will receive 80% - 100% of interest income on its assets. Please revise why you are assuming 100% here. The risks you face - page 12 45. Please revise your risk factor subheadings so that each one conveys the specific risk to you. Currently, some of your subheadings merely state a general risk or a fact about your business. We note the following examples: * Possible total loss of an investment. * Speculative and volatile Markets; Highly leveraged trading. * Fees and commissions are charged regardless of profitability and are subject to change. * Importance of market conditions to profitability. * No assurance of advisors` continued services. * Possible illiquid markets. * No series of the Fund acquires any asset with intrinsic value. * Non-correlated, not negatively correlated, performance objective. * Conflicts of interest. * Failure of brokerage firms; default by clearing broker. Speculative and Volatile Markets; Highly Leveraged Trading - page 12 46. Please revise to clarify, if true, that even a small movement in price could cause large losses for the fund. 47. Please quantify the maximum amount of leverage that each series may incur. In addition, please quantify the maximum amount of notional funds that the Managing Owner may allocate to the advisors. Fees and commissions are charged regardless of profitability and are subject to change - page 12 48. Please revise to briefly quantify the significant charges you reference in the first sentence. Importance of market conditions to profitability - page 12 49. Please revise to specify the advisors who will use technical, trend-following methods. Discretionary trading strategies may incur substantial losses - page 12 50. Please revise to specify which traders may implement discretionary-trading strategies. When you revise, please explain full